• Foundation
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

How federalism is practised: linguistic states, language policy and Centre-State relations

Explain how democratic politics strengthened Indian federalism through the creation of linguistic states, a flexible language policy and the change in Centre-State relations after 1990.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain why linguistic states were created and how they affected national unity.
  • Explain India's language policy and how it differed from Sri Lanka's.
  • Explain how Centre-State relations changed after 1990.

Constitutional provisions are necessary but not sufficient for federalism to succeed. Its real success in India owes much to the nature of democratic politics, which made the spirit of federalism, respect for diversity and the desire to live together shared ideals. Three major tests show how.

1. Linguistic states

The creation of linguistic states was the first and a major test of Indian democracy. Compare the map of 1947 with today's: many old states have vanished, new ones have been created, and boundaries and names have changed. After Independence the boundaries of several old states were changed so that people who spoke the same language lived in the same state. Some states were created to recognise differences of culture, ethnicity or geography rather than language, such as Nagaland, Uttarakhand and Jharkhand. When the demand for linguistic states arose, some national leaders feared it would break up the country, and the Central Government resisted for a time. But experience showed that linguistic states actually made the country more united and administration easier.

2. Language policy

The Constitution did not give any one language the status of national language. Hindi was identified as the official language, but it is the mother tongue of only a minority of Indians (about 44 per cent, according to the 2011 Census figures in the textbook). So there are many safeguards for other languages. Besides Hindi, there are 21 other Scheduled Languages (22 in all, in the Eighth Schedule). A candidate in an examination for Central Government positions may write it in any of these languages, and states have their own official languages.

Unlike Sri Lanka, Indian leaders spread Hindi cautiously. The Constitution said the use of English for official purposes would stop in 1965, but many non-Hindi-speaking states demanded that it continue; in Tamil Nadu the movement turned violent. The Central Government agreed to continue English along with Hindi for official purposes. Some critics argue this favoured the English-speaking elite. Promoting Hindi remains official policy, but promotion does not mean the Centre can impose Hindi on states where people speak other languages. This flexibility helped India avoid a situation like Sri Lanka's.

3. Centre-State relations

How constitutional arrangements work depends largely on how ruling parties and leaders follow them. For a long time the same party ruled at the Centre and in most states, so state governments did not use their rights as autonomous units. When a different party ruled a state, the party at the Centre often tried to undermine it, sometimes misusing the Constitution to dismiss state governments run by rival parties, which harmed the spirit of federalism. This changed significantly after 1990, with the rise of regional parties and the era of coalition governments at the Centre, since no single party won a clear majority in the Lok Sabha and national parties had to ally with regional parties. A coalition government is one formed by two or more parties, usually with a common programme. This created a culture of power sharing and respect for state autonomy, supported by a major Supreme Court judgement that made it difficult to dismiss state governments arbitrarily.

How Centre-State relations changed

  1. Early decades Same party at Centre and in most states; states rarely asserted autonomy.
  2. Misuse of power State governments of rival parties sometimes dismissed.
  3. After 1990 Regional parties rise; coalition governments at the Centre.
  4. Supreme Court judgement Arbitrary dismissal of state governments made difficult.
  5. Today Federal power sharing more effective than in early years.

Federalism succeeded in India not only because the Constitution provided for it, but because democratic politics made respect for diversity and the desire to live together shared ideals.

Worked example 1: comparing India and Sri Lanka

Question: How did India's approach to language differ from Sri Lanka's, and with what result? Reasoning: Sri Lanka made Sinhala the only official language in 1956, alienating Tamil speakers. India gave no language national status, recognised many Scheduled Languages, let states use their own languages, and kept English when non-Hindi states objected. Answer: India accommodated linguistic diversity flexibly and avoided the conflict that Sri Lanka suffered.

Worked example 2: evaluating a view

View: 'Language-based states have divided us by making everyone conscious of their language.' Evaluating with the chapter: the fear was real at first - leaders worried about disintegration. But the textbook concludes that experience showed linguistic states made the country more united, because people felt their language and culture were respected, and administration in the people's own language became easier. Answer: the chapter's evidence supports the opposite view - accommodation strengthened unity.

Key takeaways: Democratic politics made Indian federalism work. Linguistic states, feared at first, made India more united and easier to administer. Language policy gave no single national language, recognised 22 Scheduled Languages and kept English alongside Hindi, avoiding imposition. After 1990, regional parties and coalition governments, along with a Supreme Court judgement, increased respect for state autonomy.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which states, according to the textbook, were created on grounds of culture, ethnicity or geography rather than language?

    1. Nagaland, Uttarakhand and Jharkhand
    2. Kerala, Karnataka and Tamil Nadu
    3. Punjab, Haryana and Gujarat
    4. Bihar, Odisha and Bengal
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The textbook names Nagaland, Uttarakhand and Jharkhand as states created to recognise differences of culture, ethnicity or geography.

  2. 2. What status does Hindi have under the Constitution?

    1. National language
    2. Only language allowed in states
    3. Official language, with safeguards for other languages
    4. No status at all
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The Constitution gave no language national-language status; Hindi was identified as the official language, with many safeguards for others.

  3. 3. What happened when non-Hindi-speaking states opposed ending the official use of English in 1965?

    1. English was banned
    2. The Centre agreed to continue English along with Hindi for official purposes
    3. Hindi was dropped as an official language
    4. All states were merged
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The Central Government responded by agreeing to continue English along with Hindi, showing flexibility.

  4. 4. Which development after 1990 strengthened federal power sharing?

    1. One party winning every state
    2. Abolition of the Supreme Court
    3. Ending of state elections
    4. Rise of regional parties and coalition governments at the Centre
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Regional parties and coalition governments created a culture of power sharing and respect for state autonomy, supported by a Supreme Court judgement against arbitrary dismissals.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): Constitutional provisions alone do not explain the success of federalism in India. Reason (R): The nature of democratic politics made respect for diversity and the desire to live together shared ideals.

    1. A is false, but R is true.
    2. A is true, but R is false.
    3. Both A and R are true, and R correctly explains A.
    4. Both A and R are true, but R does not explain A.
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The textbook says provisions are necessary but not sufficient; the real success lies in democratic politics making federal values shared. R explains A.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery