• Foundation
  • About 13 min
  • 5 practice questions

Challenges to political parties

Explain the four main challenges that weaken political parties - lack of internal democracy, dynastic succession, money and muscle power, and lack of meaningful choice - and why each harms democracy.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Describe four challenges faced by political parties.
  • Explain how each challenge harms party members and democracy.
  • Identify which challenge a given situation illustrates.

Because parties are the most visible face of democracy, people blame them for whatever goes wrong. All over the world, people express dissatisfaction with how parties perform. In India, criticism focuses on four problem areas that parties must overcome to remain effective instruments of democracy.

1. Lack of internal democracy

Parties everywhere tend to concentrate power in one or a few leaders at the top. Many do not keep membership registers, hold organisational meetings or conduct internal elections regularly. Ordinary members get little information about what happens inside the party and lack the means to influence decisions. Leaders take decisions in the party's name; those who disagree find it hard to stay; and personal loyalty to the leader becomes more important than loyalty to the party's principles and policies.

2. Dynastic succession

Related to the first: since many parties lack open, transparent procedures, it is hard for an ordinary worker to rise to the top. Leaders are in a position to favour people close to them, even family members, and in many parties the top positions are controlled by members of one family. This is unfair to other members and bad for democracy, because people without adequate experience or popular support come to hold power. The tendency exists in some measure worldwide, including in some older democracies.

3. Money and muscle power

Focused on winning elections, parties are tempted by short-cuts. They tend to nominate candidates who have or can raise a lot of money. Rich people and companies who fund parties can influence their policies and decisions. In some cases parties support criminals who can win elections. Democrats all over the world worry about the growing role of rich people and big companies in politics.

4. Lack of meaningful choice

To offer a meaningful choice, parties must differ significantly. In recent years ideological differences among parties have declined in most of the world; the textbook gives the example of Britain's two main parties, which agree on fundamentals and differ only in details. In India too, differences among major parties on economic policy have narrowed, so voters who want very different policies may have no option. Sometimes voters cannot even choose very different leaders, as the same leaders keep shifting from one party to another.

Four challenges to political parties

  • Lack of internal democracy Power concentrated at the top; no registers, meetings or internal elections.
  • Dynastic succession Top posts kept within one family.
  • Money and muscle power Rich candidates, influence of donors, support to criminals.
  • No meaningful choice Few ideological differences; leaders switch parties.

Parties are the instruments of democracy, but they work well only when they are democratic inside, open to talent, free of undue money and muscle power, and offer voters real choices.

Worked example 1: identifying the challenge

Cases (made up): (a) A party has held no internal election for its president in fifteen years, and members learn of decisions from the news. (b) A party gives tickets mostly to candidates who can spend large sums on campaigns. (c) Voters complain that the two main parties promise nearly identical economic policies. Answer: (a) lack of internal democracy; (b) money power; (c) lack of meaningful choice.

Worked example 2: explaining a link

Question: Why is dynastic succession described as related to lack of internal democracy? Reasoning: Step 1 - without open procedures such as internal elections, there is no fair route for ordinary workers to rise. Step 2 - this leaves leaders free to pass positions to those close to them. Step 3 - so posts stay within one family. Answer: the absence of internal democracy creates the conditions in which dynastic succession thrives.

Key takeaways: Parties face four main challenges: lack of internal democracy (power at the top, personal loyalty), dynastic succession (top posts within one family), money and muscle power (rich candidates, donor influence, criminal candidates), and lack of meaningful choice (narrowing differences, leaders switching parties). Each weakens parties as instruments of democracy.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which situation shows a lack of internal democracy in a party?

    1. Regular internal elections and open membership registers
    2. Members freely debating policy in meetings
    3. Power concentrated in one or a few leaders, with no internal elections
    4. Publishing the party's accounts
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Lack of internal democracy means power is concentrated at the top, with no registers, meetings or regular internal elections.

  2. 2. Dynastic succession in parties is bad for democracy because:

    1. people without adequate experience or popular support may come to hold power
    2. it gives every worker an equal chance
    3. it increases internal elections
    4. it reduces the role of money
    Show answer

    Answer: A. When top posts stay within a family, less experienced or less popular people may get power, which is unfair to other members and harms democracy.

  3. 3. Which is an example of the challenge of money and muscle power?

    1. A party holding open internal elections
    2. A party nominating candidates mainly because they can raise large funds
    3. A party publishing a clear manifesto
    4. A party with very different policies from others
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Choosing candidates for their wealth, letting donors influence policy, or backing criminals who can win are forms of money and muscle power.

  4. 4. Why do voters sometimes lack a meaningful choice?

    1. Because there are no elections
    2. Because only one party exists in all democracies
    3. Because voting is compulsory
    4. Because ideological differences among major parties have declined and leaders shift between parties
    Show answer

    Answer: D. When parties' policies converge and the same leaders move between parties, voters who want different policies or leaders have few options.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): Ordinary party members often cannot influence party decisions. Reason (R): Many parties do not share information with members or hold regular organisational meetings and elections.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R correctly explains A.
    2. Both A and R are true, but R does not explain A.
    3. A is true, but R is false.
    4. A is false, but R is true.
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Without information, meetings or internal elections, members have no means to influence decisions. R explains A.

Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.

Next lesson → Reforming political parties

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery