• Foundation
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Reforming political parties

Describe the reforms already made - the anti-defection law, candidates' affidavits and the Election Commission's order on internal elections and tax returns - evaluate further suggestions, and explain the role of citizens in reforming parties.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Describe three steps already taken to reform parties and their effects and limits.
  • Explain further suggested reforms and why over-regulation can be counter-productive.
  • Explain how citizens can push parties to reform.

To meet their challenges, parties need reform. But who will reform them? In a democracy, final decisions are made by leaders of political parties. People can replace them only with another set of party leaders. If none wish to reform, how can anyone force them? This is a question citizens everywhere face. Let us look at efforts and suggestions in India.

Steps already taken

  1. Anti-defection law: Defection means changing party allegiance from the party on whose ticket one was elected. Because many representatives defected to become ministers or for cash rewards, the Constitution was amended: an MP or MLA who changes parties loses the seat. This has reduced defection, but it has also made dissent more difficult, as members must accept whatever party leaders decide.
  2. Affidavits: a Supreme Court order made it mandatory for every candidate to file an affidavit - a signed, sworn statement - giving details of property and pending criminal cases. Much information is now public, but there is no system to check whether it is true, and it is not yet clear whether the influence of the rich and criminals has declined.
  3. Internal elections and tax returns: the Election Commission ordered parties to hold organisational elections and file income tax returns. Parties have started doing so, though sometimes only as a formality, and it is unclear whether internal democracy has grown.
Reforms, their aims and their limits
ReformAimLimit noted in the textbook
Anti-defection amendmentStop representatives switching parties for gainMakes dissent harder; members must obey leaders
Candidates' affidavits (Supreme Court order)Reduce influence of money and criminalsNo system to verify the information
Organisational elections and tax returns (Election Commission order)Increase internal democracy and transparencySometimes a mere formality

Further suggestions

  • A law to regulate internal affairs of parties: compulsory membership registers, following the party's own constitution, an independent authority to judge disputes, and open elections to the highest posts.
  • Mandatory tickets for women - about one-third - and a quota for women in party decision-making bodies.
  • State funding of elections: support in kind (petrol, paper, telephone) or in cash based on votes won in the last election.

Parties have not accepted these suggestions. They could bring some improvement, but we must be careful about legal solutions to political problems: over-regulation can be counter-productive, pushing parties to find ways to cheat the law, and parties will not easily pass laws they dislike.

The role of citizens

There are two other routes to reform. First, people can put pressure on parties through petitions, publicity and agitations; citizens, pressure groups, movements and the media all play a part. If parties fear losing public support, they take reform seriously. Second, parties can improve if those who want reform join them. The quality of democracy depends on public participation; reform is difficult if citizens only criticise from outside.

The problem of bad politics can be solved by more and better politics - by citizens who press for reform and take part themselves.

Routes to reforming parties

  • Legal and institutional steps
    • Anti-defection law
    • Candidates' affidavits
    • Organisational elections and tax returns
  • Suggested laws
    • Regulate internal affairs
    • One-third tickets for women
    • State funding of elections
  • Public pressure
    • Petitions, publicity, agitations
    • Media, pressure groups, movements
  • Participation
    • Reform-minded citizens join parties

Worked example 1: evaluating a reform

Question: The anti-defection law reduced defections. Why does the textbook also see a cost? Reasoning: Step 1 - a member who leaves the party loses the seat. Step 2 - so members are unwilling to oppose party leaders even on matters of conscience. Step 3 - this strengthens leaders and weakens internal debate. Answer: it curbed opportunistic switching but made dissent more difficult - a trade-off.

Worked example 2: matching a reform to a challenge

Question: Which challenge does each of these address? (a) Candidates' affidavits on property and criminal cases. (b) A law requiring open elections to a party's highest posts. (c) Reserving one-third of tickets for women. Answer: (a) money and muscle power; (b) lack of internal democracy (and dynastic succession); (c) under-representation of women, linked to lack of internal democracy.

Key takeaways: Reforms so far include the anti-defection amendment (less defection, harder dissent), affidavits on assets and criminal cases (more information, but unverified) and orders on internal elections and tax returns (sometimes a formality). Suggested reforms include regulating internal affairs, one-third tickets for women and state funding of elections, though over-regulation can backfire. Public pressure and citizens' participation are key to reform.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Under the anti-defection law, what happens to an MP or MLA who changes parties?

    1. He or she becomes a minister
    2. He or she loses the seat in the legislature
    3. Nothing happens
    4. He or she must pay a small fine only
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The Constitution was amended so that a legislator who changes parties loses the seat.

  2. 2. What must every candidate file under the Supreme Court's order?

    1. An affidavit giving details of property and pending criminal cases
    2. A list of party members
    3. The party's income tax return
    4. A request for state funding
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Candidates must file an affidavit on their property and criminal cases pending against them, making this information public.

  3. 3. Which is a limit of the affidavit system noted in the textbook?

    1. Candidates are not allowed to file them
    2. It increases defection
    3. There is no system to check whether the information given is true
    4. It makes parties hold internal elections
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The information is public, but there is no system to verify it, so its effect on the role of money and crime is unclear.

  4. 4. Why does the textbook warn against relying only on legal solutions to reform parties?

    1. Because laws are never passed
    2. Because citizens cannot read laws
    3. Because courts cannot hear party cases
    4. Because over-regulation can be counter-productive and push parties to cheat the law
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Excessive regulation may make parties find ways around the law, and parties will not pass laws they dislike; public pressure and participation are also needed.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): The anti-defection law has made dissent within parties more difficult. Reason (R): Legislators who oppose their party by leaving it lose their seats, so they tend to accept the leaders' decisions.

    1. A is true, but R is false.
    2. Both A and R are true, but R does not explain A.
    3. A is false, but R is true.
    4. Both A and R are true, and R correctly explains A.
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Fear of losing the seat makes members follow party leaders, which reduces dissent. R explains A.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery