- Foundation
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Why democracies need parties, and party systems
Explain why modern representative democracies cannot work without political parties, and compare one-party, two-party and multiparty systems, including alliances, and why each country's party system evolves from its own circumstances.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain, by imagining a democracy without parties, why parties are necessary.
- Distinguish one-party, two-party and multiparty systems with examples.
- Explain why no single party system is ideal for all countries.
The functions of parties already suggest why we need them. But why can modern democracies not exist without them at all? A thought experiment helps.
Imagine a democracy without parties
If there were no parties, every candidate would be independent. No one could promise major policy changes, because no single independent could deliver them. A government might be formed, but its usefulness would be uncertain. Representatives would answer to their own constituencies for local work, but no one would be responsible for how the country as a whole is run. Even where panchayat elections are formally non-party, villages often split into factions, each putting up a 'panel' of candidates - which is exactly what a party does.
The rise of parties is directly linked to representative democracy. Large, complex societies need an agency to gather views on many issues and present them to government, to bring representatives together so that a responsible government can be formed, and to support or restrain the government, make policies and justify or oppose them. Parties meet these needs, so they are a necessary condition for democracy.
Without parties, no one could promise or deliver national policies, and no one would be responsible for running the country - which is why parties are a necessary condition for representative democracy.
How many parties?
In a democracy any group of citizens may form a party, so many parties exist, but usually only a handful are serious contenders. Party systems are classified by the number of effective parties.
| Type | Meaning | Example from the textbook |
|---|---|---|
| One-party system | Only one party is allowed to control and run the government; no free competition for power | China |
| Two-party system | Power usually changes between two main parties; others exist but rarely win a majority | USA, United Kingdom |
| Multiparty system | More than two parties have a reasonable chance of coming to power, alone or in alliance | India |
A one-party system is not a democratic option, because any democracy must allow at least two parties to compete and give them a fair chance of coming to power. In a multiparty system, governments are often formed by several parties in a coalition. When several parties join hands to contest elections and win power, it is called an alliance or a front. A multiparty system can look messy and lead to political instability, but it allows a variety of interests and opinions to be represented.
Two-party and multiparty systems
-
Two-party system
- Two main parties alternate in power
- Clear choice for voters
- Single-party governments common
- Fewer interests directly represented
-
Multiparty system
- Several parties can come to power
- Coalitions and alliances common
- Can appear messy or unstable
- Wider range of interests represented
Which system is best?
The textbook suggests this is not a very good question. A party system is not chosen; it evolves over a long time from the nature of society, its social and regional divisions, its political history and its electoral system. India has a multiparty system because the social and geographical diversity of a large country is not easily absorbed by two or three parties. No system is ideal for all countries and situations.
Worked example 1: classifying a system
Case (made up): In Country P, five parties win seats; in most elections no party wins a majority, and governments are formed by two or three parties together. In Country Q, ten parties exist, but for decades government has passed between the same two. Reasoning: P has more than two parties with a real chance of power - multiparty. Q has only two effective contenders - two-party, despite many small parties. Answer: P is multiparty; Q is two-party.
Worked example 2: why is India multiparty?
Question: Why has India developed a multiparty system rather than a two-party one? Reasoning: Step 1 - India has vast social diversity: many languages, religions, castes and regions. Step 2 - different groups and regions have distinct interests. Step 3 - two parties cannot represent all of these. Step 4 - so many parties, including state-based ones, emerged over time. Answer: the party system grew out of India's social and geographical diversity.
Key takeaways: Without parties, no one could promise national policies or be responsible for running the country; parties are a necessary condition for representative democracy. Party systems may be one-party (not democratic), two-party (USA, UK) or multiparty (India), where alliances and coalitions are common. Party systems evolve from each country's circumstances; none is ideal for all.
Check your understanding
-
1. What would most likely happen in a democracy with no political parties?
- Every candidate would be independent and no one would be responsible for how the country is run
- Governments would become more stable
- Policies would be easier to promise
- Elections would no longer be needed
Show answer
Answer: A. With only independents, no one could promise major policies and no one would be responsible for running the country as a whole.
-
2. Why is a one-party system not considered a democratic option?
- Because it has too many parties
- Because it does not allow free competition for power among at least two parties
- Because it always has coalitions
- Because it has no government
Show answer
Answer: B. A democracy must allow at least two parties to compete and give them a fair chance of coming to power.
-
3. When several parties in a multiparty system join hands to contest elections and win power, it is called:
- a one-party system
- a pressure group
- an alliance or front
- a defection
Show answer
Answer: C. An alliance or front is formed when parties come together to contest elections; if elected, they form a coalition government.
-
4. The USA and the United Kingdom are examples of which party system?
- One-party system
- Multiparty system
- No-party system
- Two-party system
Show answer
Answer: D. In these countries power usually alternates between two main parties, though others exist.
-
5. Assertion (A): India has evolved a multiparty system. Reason (R): The social and geographical diversity of a large country is not easily absorbed by two or even three parties.
- Both A and R are true, but R does not explain A.
- A is true, but R is false.
- Both A and R are true, and R correctly explains A.
- A is false, but R is true.
Show answer
Answer: C. India's diversity produced many parties representing different groups and regions. R explains A.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.