• Foundation
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Accountable, responsive and legitimate government

Explain why democracy should produce accountable and responsive government, weigh speed against deliberation, explain transparency, assess democracy's mixed record, and explain why legitimacy is its clearest advantage.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain why accountable and responsive government is the most basic outcome of democracy.
  • Explain why democratic decision-making may be slower but more effective, and what transparency means.
  • Assess democracy's record on accountability and responsiveness, and explain its legitimacy.

In a democracy we care most that people can choose their rulers and control them, and can take part in decisions that affect them. So the most basic outcome of democracy should be a government that is accountable to citizens and responsive to their needs and expectations.

Is democratic government inefficient?

Some argue that democracy is less efficient. Non-democratic rulers need not bother with debate in assemblies, majorities or public opinion, so they can decide and act quickly. Democracy rests on deliberation and negotiation, so some delay is bound to happen. But think in terms of costs: a fast government may take decisions people do not accept, which then run into trouble. A democratic government takes more time to follow procedures, but its decisions are more likely to be accepted and effective. The cost of time may be worth it.

Fast decisions and deliberated decisions

  • Non-democratic rule
    • Quick decisions
    • No deliberation or public debate
    • Decisions may not be accepted
    • Little transparency
  • Democratic rule
    • Slower, follows procedures
    • Deliberation and negotiation
    • Decisions more acceptable and effective
    • Transparency: citizens can check the process

Transparency

Democracy ensures that decisions follow norms and procedures. A citizen who wants to know whether a decision was taken correctly has the right and the means to examine the process. This is called transparency, and it is often missing in non-democratic governments. So we can expect democracy to develop mechanisms for citizens to hold government accountable and to take part in decisions. To measure this, we look for regular, free and fair elections; open public debate on major policies and laws; and citizens' right to information about the government.

Transparency: a citizen's right and means to examine whether a decision was taken through the correct procedures.

The record: mixed

  • Democracies have done better at holding regular, free elections and creating conditions for open public debate.
  • Most fall short of elections that give everyone a fair chance, and of subjecting every decision to public debate.
  • Their record on sharing information with citizens is not very good - though still much better than non-democratic regimes.
  • We may expect governments attentive to people's needs and largely free of corruption; here the record is not impressive. Democracies often frustrate people's needs, and corruption is common - but nothing shows non-democracies are less corrupt or more sensitive to people.

Legitimacy: democracy's clear advantage

In one respect democratic government is certainly better: it is legitimate. It may be slow, less efficient, not always responsive or clean, but it is the people's own government. That is why support for the idea of democracy is overwhelming. The textbook's survey evidence from South Asia shows strong support for rule by elected representatives and a belief that democracy suits one's own country, in countries with and without democratic regimes. Democracy's ability to generate its own support is itself an outcome.

Worked example 1: using the right to information

Case (based on the textbook's exercise): a daily wage earner applies for a duplicate ration card; for months officials ignore him. He then files an application under the Right to Information Act asking for the daily progress on his application, the names of officials responsible and what action would be taken for their inaction. Within a week an inspector tells him the card is ready, and the officer in charge is suddenly courteous. Analysis: the right to information made officials answerable - an example of transparency producing accountability and responsiveness.

Worked example 2: weighing time against acceptance

Case (made up): Town A's ruler orders a new market built overnight on a site traders dislike; traders refuse to move and the market lies empty. Town B's council consults traders for two months, chooses a site they agree on, and the market fills up. Reasoning: A saved time but produced a decision people did not accept; B spent time on deliberation but its decision worked. Answer: democracy's 'cost of time' can produce more effective outcomes.

Key takeaways: The basic outcome expected of democracy is accountable, responsive government. Deliberation makes decisions slower but more acceptable and effective, and transparency lets citizens check procedures. The record is mixed: better on elections and public debate, weaker on information-sharing, responsiveness and corruption, though not worse than non-democracies. Democracy's clearest advantage is legitimacy - it is the people's own government.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. What is the most basic outcome expected of democracy?

    1. The fastest possible decisions
    2. A government that is accountable to citizens and responsive to their needs
    3. The highest economic growth in the world
    4. No disagreements among people
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The textbook says the most basic outcome should be a government accountable to citizens and responsive to their needs and expectations.

  2. 2. Transparency in a democracy means:

    1. citizens have the right and the means to examine whether decisions were taken through correct procedures
    2. the government keeps its decisions secret
    3. decisions are taken without any procedure
    4. only officials know the rules
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Transparency lets citizens examine the decision-making process, which is often missing in non-democratic governments.

  3. 3. In which respect is democratic government certainly better than its alternatives, according to the textbook?

    1. It is always the fastest
    2. It is completely free of corruption
    3. It always produces higher growth
    4. It is legitimate - the people's own government
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Democracy may be slow, less efficient and not always clean, but it is legitimate because it is the people's own government.

  4. 4. Democracies have had greater success in which of these?

    1. Sharing all information with citizens
    2. Eliminating corruption
    3. Setting up regular and free elections and conditions for open public debate
    4. Ensuring every decision is publicly debated
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The textbook says democracies have done better at regular, free elections and open debate, but fall short on fair chances for all, debate on every decision and information-sharing.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): Democratic decisions may take longer. Reason (R): Democracy is based on deliberation and negotiation, which takes time.

    1. A is true, but R is false.
    2. Both A and R are true, but R does not explain A.
    3. A is false, but R is true.
    4. Both A and R are true, and R correctly explains A.
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Because democracy involves debate, negotiation and following procedures, some delay is bound to occur. R explains A.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery