• Foundation
  • About 13 min
  • 5 practice questions

How should we assess the outcomes of democracy?

Recall why democracy is considered better than its alternatives, explain the dilemma that democracy seems good in principle but less so in practice, and explain why democracy should be judged as a form of government that creates conditions rather than guarantees results.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • List the reasons why democracy is considered better than other forms of government.
  • Explain the dilemma between democracy in principle and democracy in practice.
  • Explain why democracy should be judged as a form of government that creates conditions for achieving goals.

As we end our study of democracy, we ask some general questions. What does democracy actually do? What outcomes can we reasonably expect from it, and does it deliver them? This lesson sets out how to think about these questions before we examine the record in later lessons.

Why democracy is considered better

In Class IX we concluded that democracy is a better form of government than dictatorship or other alternatives because it:

  • promotes equality among citizens;
  • enhances the dignity of the individual;
  • improves the quality of decision-making;
  • provides a method to resolve conflicts; and
  • allows room to correct mistakes.

A dilemma

Most people support democracy over rule by a monarch, the military or religious leaders. Yet many are not satisfied with democracy as it works in practice. So democracy is seen as good in principle but felt to be not so good in practice. This invites a careful question: do we prefer democracy only for moral reasons, or are there prudential reasons too - better outcomes that we can point to?

More than a hundred countries today practise some kind of democratic politics: formal constitutions, elections, parties and rights. But they differ greatly in social situations, economic achievements and cultures, so what each achieves will differ. The question is what we can expect from every democracy simply because it is a democracy.

Democracy is a form of government

Our enthusiasm for democracy sometimes leads us to think it can solve all social, economic and political problems. When some expectations are not met, we blame the idea of democracy, or doubt whether we live in one at all. The first step in thinking carefully is to recognise that democracy is just a form of government. It can only create conditions for achieving goals; citizens must take advantage of those conditions to achieve them.

Democracy is a form of government: it creates conditions for achieving goals, and citizens must use those conditions to reach them.

Outcomes we can reasonably examine

  • Quality of government Accountable, responsive and legitimate.
  • Economic growth and development Does democracy grow the economy?
  • Inequality and poverty Does it reduce disparities?
  • Social differences and conflict Does it accommodate diversity?
  • Dignity and freedom Does it respect every individual?

Worked example 1: a fair or unfair expectation?

Statement: 'Our country is a democracy, so every village should have had a hospital by now; since it has not, democracy has failed.' Reasoning: Step 1 - democracy gives conditions such as elections, rights and public debate through which people can demand hospitals. Step 2 - whether hospitals are built also depends on resources, priorities and how actively citizens use their rights. Step 3 - so the lack of hospitals is not proof that democracy as an idea has failed. Answer: the expectation treats democracy as a guarantee of results rather than a form of government that creates conditions.

Worked example 2: moral or prudential?

Question: Classify these reasons for supporting democracy: (a) 'Every person deserves to be treated with dignity and to have a say.' (b) 'Democratic decisions, made after discussion, are more widely accepted and so work better.' Answer: (a) is a moral reason - it values democracy for what it is. (b) is a prudential reason - it values democracy for its better outcomes.

Key takeaways: Democracy is considered better because it promotes equality and dignity, improves decision-making, resolves conflicts and allows mistakes to be corrected. People support it in principle but are often dissatisfied in practice. To judge it fairly, we must see democracy as a form of government that creates conditions; citizens must use those conditions to achieve their goals.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which is NOT one of the reasons the textbook gives for considering democracy better than its alternatives?

    1. It promotes equality among citizens
    2. It enhances the dignity of the individual
    3. It guarantees that every problem will be solved quickly
    4. It allows room to correct mistakes
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Democracy promotes equality and dignity, improves decision-making, resolves conflicts and allows correction of mistakes. It does not guarantee quick solutions to every problem.

  2. 2. The 'dilemma' about democracy described in the chapter is that:

    1. democracy is seen as good in principle but felt to be not so good in practice
    2. no country has ever held elections
    3. dictatorships are always preferred by people
    4. democracy has no supporters
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Most people support democracy over alternatives, yet many are dissatisfied with how it works in practice.

  3. 3. Why should democracy be recognised as 'just a form of government'?

    1. Because it has no value
    2. Because it only creates conditions for achieving goals, which citizens must use
    3. Because it is the same as dictatorship
    4. Because it cannot hold elections
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Recognising democracy as a form of government means it creates conditions; achieving goals depends on citizens using them.

  4. 4. Which of these is a prudential reason for supporting democracy?

    1. People have a right to be consulted
    2. Democracy is the spirit of equality
    3. Every person deserves dignity
    4. Decisions taken after deliberation tend to be more acceptable and effective
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Prudential reasons stress better outcomes, such as more acceptable and effective decisions. The others are moral reasons.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): We should not blame the idea of democracy for every unmet expectation. Reason (R): Democracy can only create conditions; citizens must take advantage of them to achieve goals.

    1. A is false, but R is true.
    2. A is true, but R is false.
    3. Both A and R are true, but R does not explain A.
    4. Both A and R are true, and R correctly explains A.
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Because democracy provides conditions rather than guaranteed results, unmet expectations are not automatically the fault of democracy itself. R explains A.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery