• Foundation
  • About 13 min
  • 5 practice questions

Dignity and freedom of citizens: democracy's continuing examination

Explain why democracy is superior in promoting dignity and freedom, using the examples of women and disadvantaged castes, and explain why democracy's examination never ends and why public complaints are a sign of its success.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain why democracy is superior to other forms of government in promoting dignity and freedom.
  • Explain how recognising equality in principle helps women and disadvantaged castes struggle for equal treatment.
  • Explain why democracy's examination never ends and why complaints show its success.

Democracy stands much superior to any other form of government in promoting the dignity and freedom of the individual. Every person wants respect from others, and many conflicts arise when people feel they are not treated with due respect. The passion for respect and freedom is the basis of democracy.

Recognising equality in principle

Democracies around the world have recognised dignity and freedom at least in principle, achieved in different degrees. For societies long built on subordination and domination, recognising that all individuals are equal is not simple.

  • Women: most societies were historically male-dominated. Long struggles by women have created sensitivity that respect for and equal treatment of women are necessary in a democratic society. Women are not always treated with respect, but once the principle is recognised, it becomes easier to struggle against what is now legally and morally unacceptable. In a non-democratic set-up, such a struggle would lack this legal and moral basis.
  • Caste: democracy in India has strengthened the claims of disadvantaged and discriminated castes for equal status and equal opportunity. Caste-based inequalities and atrocities still occur, but they lack moral and legal foundations.

Once equality is recognised in principle, discrimination loses its legal and moral foundation - and those who face it gain firm ground on which to struggle.

An examination that never ends

Expectations from democracy also serve as criteria for judging any democratic country. What is most distinctive is that democracy's examination never gets over: as it passes one test, it produces another. As people enjoy some benefits, they ask for more and want to make democracy better. So people will always have more expectations and many complaints.

The fact that people complain is itself a testimony to democracy's success. It shows they have developed awareness and the ability to expect, and to look critically at those in power. Public dissatisfaction shows the success of the democratic project: it transforms people from the status of subjects into citizens. Most individuals today believe their vote makes a difference to how government is run and to their own interest; the textbook's South Asia survey shows a majority in each country it covers holding this belief.

Democracy's continuing examination

  1. Democracy meets an expectation
  2. People enjoy the benefit
  3. They grow more aware and expect more
  4. They voice complaints and new demands
  5. Democracy faces a new test

Then back to step 1: Democracy meets an expectation

Worked example 1: principle and struggle

Case (adapted from the textbook's exercise): following a High Court directive, a temple that had separate entry doors for Dalits and others allowed everyone to enter through the same door. Reasoning: Step 1 - equal dignity is recognised in law, so separate entry lacks legal and moral foundation. Step 2 - this allowed the discriminated group to seek a remedy through the courts. Step 3 - the court enforced equality. Answer: recognising equality in principle gave disadvantaged citizens the basis to win equal treatment in practice.

Worked example 2: is a complaint a failure?

Statement: 'People in our country keep complaining about the government, so our democracy must be failing.' Reasoning: complaints show people are aware, expect more and dare to criticise those in power - qualities of citizens, not subjects. In a non-democratic regime, people may not be free or confident to complain. Answer: public complaints are, according to the textbook, a sign of democracy's success, though the problems complained about still need solving.

Key takeaways: Democracy is superior in promoting dignity and freedom. Recognising equality in principle gives women and disadvantaged castes a legal and moral basis to struggle against discrimination, even though discrimination persists. Democracy's examination never ends: each success produces new expectations. Public complaints show that people have become citizens who expect and criticise, which is itself a success of democracy.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. In which respect does the textbook say democracy stands 'much superior' to any other form of government?

    1. Economic growth
    2. Speed of decisions
    3. Promoting the dignity and freedom of the individual
    4. Reducing all inequality
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The textbook says democracy is much superior in promoting the dignity and freedom of the individual.

  2. 2. How does recognising equality in principle help women in a democracy?

    1. It makes it easier to struggle against what has become legally and morally unacceptable
    2. It guarantees they are always treated with respect
    3. It removes the need for any struggle
    4. It applies only to men
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Once equality is recognised, discrimination becomes legally and morally unacceptable, giving women firm ground for their struggle, though respect is not automatic.

  3. 3. Why does the textbook say democracy's 'examination never gets over'?

    1. Because elections are cancelled
    2. Because democracy fails every test
    3. Because people stop expecting anything
    4. Because as democracy passes one test, people's expectations grow and it faces another
    Show answer

    Answer: D. As people gain benefits, they ask for more, so democracy always faces new tests.

  4. 4. According to the textbook, public expression of dissatisfaction with democracy shows that:

    1. democracy has completely failed
    2. people have changed from subjects into citizens who expect and criticise
    3. people should stop voting
    4. only dictators listen to complaints
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Complaints show awareness and the ability to look critically at power holders - the transformation of subjects into citizens.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): Caste-based inequalities and atrocities still occur in India. Reason (R): Such inequalities now lack moral and legal foundations in a democracy.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R correctly explains A.
    2. Both A and R are true, but R does not explain A.
    3. A is true, but R is false.
    4. A is false, but R is true.
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Both are true: inequalities and atrocities persist, and they lack moral and legal foundations. But R does not explain why they still occur; it explains why they can be challenged.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery