Revision notes

Chapter 5 Outcomes of Democracy: Foundation

The key points, rules to remember, tables and diagrams from all 5 lessons, on one page for quick revision. To keep a copy, use your browser's Print and choose "Save as PDF".

Lesson 1

How should we assess the outcomes of democracy?

Democracy is a form of government: it creates conditions for achieving goals, and citizens must use those conditions to reach them.

Outcomes we can reasonably examine

  • Quality of government Accountable, responsive and legitimate.
  • Economic growth and development Does democracy grow the economy?
  • Inequality and poverty Does it reduce disparities?
  • Social differences and conflict Does it accommodate diversity?
  • Dignity and freedom Does it respect every individual?

Key takeaways: Democracy is considered better because it promotes equality and dignity, improves decision-making, resolves conflicts and allows mistakes to be corrected. People support it in principle but are often dissatisfied in practice. To judge it fairly, we must see democracy as a form of government that creates conditions; citizens must use those conditions to achieve their goals.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 2

Accountable, responsive and legitimate government

Fast decisions and deliberated decisions

  • Non-democratic rule
    • Quick decisions
    • No deliberation or public debate
    • Decisions may not be accepted
    • Little transparency
  • Democratic rule
    • Slower, follows procedures
    • Deliberation and negotiation
    • Decisions more acceptable and effective
    • Transparency: citizens can check the process

Transparency: a citizen's right and means to examine whether a decision was taken through the correct procedures.

Key takeaways: The basic outcome expected of democracy is accountable, responsive government. Deliberation makes decisions slower but more acceptable and effective, and transparency lets citizens check procedures. The record is mixed: better on elections and public debate, weaker on information-sharing, responsiveness and corruption, though not worse than non-democracies. Democracy's clearest advantage is legitimacy - it is the people's own government.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 3

Economic growth, inequality and poverty

Average growth rates, 1950-2000 (as given in the textbook)
Type of regimeGrowth rate (%)
All democratic regimes3.95
All dictatorial regimes4.42
Poor countries under dictatorship4.34
Poor countries under democracy4.28
Share of national income in selected countries (as given in the textbook)
CountryTop 20% (%)Bottom 20% (%)
South Africa64.82.9
Brazil63.02.6
Russia53.74.4
USA50.04.0
United Kingdom45.06.0
Denmark34.59.6
Hungary34.410.0

Political equality - one person, one vote - has not automatically produced economic equality; democracies have not been very successful at reducing economic inequality.

Democracy's economic record

  • What evidence shows
    • Growth slightly lower overall than dictatorships
    • Almost no difference among poor countries
    • High inequality in some democracies
    • Poverty not reduced as much as expected
  • What we can reasonably expect
    • Not lagging behind dictatorships
    • Conditions for the poor to press demands
    • Room to correct policies through elections
    • Other outcomes that make it preferable

Key takeaways: Evidence for 1950-2000 shows dictatorships grew slightly faster overall, but among poor countries the difference is negligible; development depends on many factors, so democracy is not a guarantee of growth but need not lag behind. Despite political equality, democracies have not been very successful in reducing economic inequality and poverty.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 4

Accommodation of social diversity

Democracy accommodates diversity only when the majority works with the minority, and when majorities are formed afresh on each issue rather than fixed by birth into a community.

Accommodative and non-accommodative majority rule

  • Accommodative
    • Majority works with minority
    • Majorities change from issue to issue
    • Every citizen can be in the majority sometimes
    • Example: Belgium's arrangements
  • Not accommodative
    • Majority ignores minority
    • Majority fixed by religion, race or language
    • Some are permanently in the minority by birth
    • Example: majoritarian measures in Sri Lanka

Key takeaways: No society can permanently end conflicts among groups, but democracy is best suited to respecting and negotiating differences, while non-democracies often ignore or suppress them. To accommodate diversity, democracy must not be simple majority rule - the majority must work with the minority - and majority must not become a fixed majority community; every citizen must have a chance of being in the majority.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 5

Dignity and freedom of citizens: democracy's continuing examination

Once equality is recognised in principle, discrimination loses its legal and moral foundation - and those who face it gain firm ground on which to struggle.

Democracy's continuing examination

  1. Democracy meets an expectation
  2. People enjoy the benefit
  3. They grow more aware and expect more
  4. They voice complaints and new demands
  5. Democracy faces a new test

Then back to step 1: Democracy meets an expectation

Key takeaways: Democracy is superior in promoting dignity and freedom. Recognising equality in principle gives women and disadvantaged castes a legal and moral basis to struggle against discrimination, even though discrimination persists. Democracy's examination never ends: each success produces new expectations. Public complaints show that people have become citizens who expect and criticise, which is itself a success of democracy.

Read the full lesson

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery