- Foundation
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Lease financing, public deposits and commercial paper
Explain lease financing (lessor, lessee, lease rental), public deposits and commercial paper, along with inter-corporate deposits, and evaluate their merits and limitations.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain lease financing and its merits and limitations.
- Explain public deposits and why both depositor and company may gain.
- Explain commercial paper and inter-corporate deposits as the textbook describes them.
Not every asset must be bought, and not every rupee must come from a bank. A firm can rent equipment, borrow directly from the public, or, if it is highly rated, borrow for a few months by issuing a promissory note to investors.
Lease financing
A lease is a contract in which the owner of an asset (lessor) grants another party (lessee) the right to use it in return for a periodic payment called lease rental. At the end of the lease the asset returns to the lessor. Leasing helps modernisation and diversification and is common for computers and electronic equipment that become obsolete quickly. The cost of leasing should be compared with the cost of owning. The textbook lists lessors such as specialised leasing companies, banks, financial institutions and manufacturer-lessors, and lessees such as public sector units, mid-market companies, consumers (for example car leasing) and government departments.
| Merits of leasing (for the lessee) | Limitations of leasing |
|---|---|
| Asset acquired with lower investment | Restrictions on use, such as no alteration |
| Simple documentation | Operations may suffer if the lease is not renewed |
| Lease rentals are deductible in computing taxable profit | Higher payout if terminated early |
| No dilution of ownership or control | Lessee never owns the asset and loses its residual value |
| Does not affect debt-raising capacity | - |
| Risk of obsolescence borne by the lessor | - |
Public deposits
Public deposits are deposits raised by organisations directly from the public, usually at a higher rate than banks pay. A depositor fills a form and gets a deposit receipt. They meet medium- and short-term needs and benefit both sides: the depositor earns more than from a bank, and the company pays less than bank borrowing would cost. According to the textbook, companies generally invite them for up to three years, and their acceptance is regulated by the Reserve Bank of India.
Public deposits
-
Merits
- Simple procedure without restrictive loan conditions
- Cheaper than bank and institutional loans
- Usually no charge on assets
- Depositors have no vote, so control is not diluted
-
Limitations
- New companies find it hard to raise them
- Unreliable: public may not respond when needed
- Difficult to collect when large sums are needed
Commercial paper
Commercial paper (CP) is an unsecured money-market instrument issued as a promissory note. According to the textbook it was introduced in India in 1990 so that highly rated companies could diversify their short-term borrowing; later, primary dealers and all-India financial institutions were also allowed to issue it. As the book states, CP can be issued for 7 days up to one year, in denominations of ₹5 lakh or multiples, and its maturity cannot go beyond the validity of the issuer's credit rating.
| Merits of commercial paper | Limitations of commercial paper |
|---|---|
| Unsecured; no restrictive conditions | Only financially sound, highly rated firms can issue it |
| Freely transferable, so highly liquid | Amount limited to the surplus liquidity with lenders at the time |
| Usually cheaper than bank loans; can provide more funds | Impersonal: maturity cannot be extended if the firm cannot repay |
| Continuous source: new CP can repay maturing CP | - |
| Firms can park surplus funds in CP | - |
Inter-corporate deposits (ICDs) are unsecured short-term deposits made by one company with another for short-term cash management. The textbook notes that, as per RBI guidelines, the minimum period is 7 days, extendable to a year, and that the three types are three-month deposits, six-month deposits and call deposits; the interest rate is higher than banks', fixed or floating.
Lease: use without owning. Public deposits: borrow directly from the public, medium or short term. Commercial paper: an unsecured promissory note for short-term funds, open only to highly rated firms.
Worked example 1: lease or buy?
Illustrative: a made-up firm, Pixel Studio, needs editing computers for 3 years. Buying costs ₹6,00,000 and they would be worth ₹1,20,000 after 3 years. Leasing costs ₹1,80,000 a year. Working (ignoring tax and interest for simplicity): net cost of buying = 6,00,000 - 1,20,000 = ₹4,80,000. Cost of leasing = 3 × 1,80,000 = ₹5,40,000. Buying looks ₹60,000 cheaper, but leasing needs no large payment now, and if the computers became obsolete sooner, the lessor would bear that risk. The decision weighs cost against flexibility.
Worked example 2: why both gain from public deposits
Illustrative: a bank pays depositors 6% and charges borrowers 11% (made-up rates). A company offers public deposits at 8%. Working: the depositor earns 8 - 6 = 2 percentage points more than from the bank; the company pays 11 - 8 = 3 percentage points less than a bank loan. On ₹10 lakh, the company saves 3% of 10 lakh = ₹30,000 a year in interest.
Key takeaways: leasing gives the use of an asset for lease rentals without ownership, with obsolescence risk on the lessor; public deposits, regulated by the RBI, are a cheap, simple medium- and short-term source but unreliable for new firms; commercial paper is an unsecured short-term promissory note available only to highly rated firms; ICDs are short-term deposits between companies.
Check your understanding
-
1. In a lease, the party who owns the asset is the:
- lessee
- lessor
- factor
- depositor
Show answer
Answer: B. The owner is the lessor; the user who pays lease rentals is the lessee.
-
2. Which is a merit of lease financing for the lessee?
- The lessee becomes owner at the end
- There are no restrictions on use
- The risk of obsolescence is borne by the lessor
- The residual value goes to the lessee
Show answer
Answer: C. The lessor bears the obsolescence risk, giving the lessee flexibility to replace the asset; the lessee never owns it.
-
3. Commercial paper is:
- a secured long-term bond
- a preference share
- a form of trade credit
- an unsecured money-market instrument issued as a promissory note
Show answer
Answer: D. CP is an unsecured promissory note used by highly rated firms for short-term funds.
-
4. Illustrative: a company borrows ₹20 lakh through public deposits at 9% instead of a bank loan at 12%. Its yearly interest saving is:
- ₹60,000
- ₹1,80,000
- ₹2,40,000
- ₹30,000
Show answer
Answer: A. Saving = (12 - 9)% of 20 lakh = 3% of 20,00,000 = ₹60,000.
-
5. Assertion (A): New companies find it difficult to raise public deposits. Reason (R): The public is more willing to deposit money with established, trusted companies.
- A is false but R is true
- Both A and R are false
- A is true but R is false
- Both A and R are true and R explains A
Show answer
Answer: D. The textbook lists difficulty for new companies as a limitation; the reason is that depositors trust established firms. R explains A.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.