- Foundation
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
Shares and debentures
Explain equity shares, preference shares and debentures with their merits and limitations, the types of preference shares and debentures, and compare the three.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain equity shares and why equity shareholders are residual owners.
- Explain preference shares and their types.
- Explain debentures and their types, and compare shares with debentures.
A company's capital is divided into small units called shares, each with a nominal value; for example, 1,00,000 shares of ₹10 each give ₹10,00,000. Companies can also borrow long-term by issuing debentures. These are the main long-term sources of a company.
Equity shares
Equity shares are the most important source of long-term capital and represent ownership; the capital raised is owner's funds, and equity capital is a prerequisite for forming a company. Equity shareholders get no fixed dividend; they are residual owners, receiving what is left after all other claims. They bear the risk and reward of ownership, have limited liability, and vote, so they participate in management.
| Merits of equity shares | Limitations of equity shares |
|---|---|
| Suit investors who accept risk for higher returns | Not for investors wanting steady income: returns fluctuate |
| Dividend not compulsory, so no fixed burden | Cost of equity is generally higher than other sources |
| Permanent capital, repaid only on liquidation; a cushion for creditors | New issues dilute voting power and earnings of existing holders |
| Builds creditworthiness and lender confidence | More formalities and procedural delays |
| No charge on assets, so assets stay free to mortgage | - |
| Democratic control through voting rights | - |
Preference shares
Preference shareholders have two preferences over equity shareholders: (i) a fixed rate of dividend out of net profit before any equity dividend, and (ii) repayment of capital before equity shareholders (after creditors) on liquidation. They resemble debentures (fixed return) and also equity (dividend only out of profit, at directors' discretion). They generally have no voting rights.
- Merits: steady income and safety; suit low-risk investors; no effect on equity holders' control; fixed dividend may allow higher equity dividends in good times; preferential repayment; no charge on assets.
- Limitations: unattractive to risk-takers wanting high returns; dilutes equity holders' claim on assets; dividend rate usually higher than debenture interest; no assured return because dividend depends on profit; dividend is not tax-deductible.
| Type of preference share | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Cumulative / non-cumulative | Unpaid dividends accumulate and are paid later / are lost if not paid in a year |
| Participating / non-participating | Share in surplus profit after equity dividend at a set rate / do not |
| Convertible / non-convertible | Can be converted into equity shares within a set period / cannot |
Debentures
A debenture acknowledges that the company has borrowed money and will repay it at a future date; debenture holders are creditors and receive fixed interest at set intervals. The textbook notes that a public issue of debentures must be rated by a credit rating agency on track record, profitability, debt-servicing capacity and risk, and that zero interest debentures carry no explicit interest: the investor's return is the difference between face value and purchase price.
Debentures
-
Merits
- Fixed income at lower risk for investors
- Fixed charge funds; do not share profits
- Suitable when sales and earnings are stable
- No voting rights, so control not diluted
- Cheaper than preference or equity: interest is tax-deductible
-
Limitations
- Permanent burden on earnings; risky if earnings fluctuate
- Redeemable debentures must be repaid on time even in difficulty
- Reduce the capacity to borrow further
| Type of debenture | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Secured / unsecured | Create a charge on company assets / carry no security |
| Registered / bearer | Recorded in the register, transferred by an instrument of transfer / transferable by mere delivery |
| Convertible / non-convertible | Can be converted into equity after a set period / cannot |
| First / second | Repaid before other debentures / repaid after the first |
Equity: owners, residual, voting, no fixed dividend. Preference: fixed dividend and prior repayment, usually no vote. Debentures: creditors, fixed interest whether or not there is profit, tax-deductible.
Worked example 1: who gets what?
Illustrative: a made-up company, Orchid Fabrics Ltd, has 9% debentures of ₹10,00,000, 10% preference shares of ₹5,00,000 and 1,00,000 equity shares. Profit before interest (after tax, for simplicity) is ₹4,00,000. Working: debenture interest = 9% of 10,00,000 = ₹90,000 (paid first, as it is a charge). Preference dividend = 10% of 5,00,000 = ₹50,000. Left for equity = 4,00,000 - 90,000 - 50,000 = ₹2,60,000, that is ₹2.60 per equity share if all is distributed. In a bad year with profit of only ₹1,00,000, interest of ₹90,000 must still be paid, leaving ₹10,000, not enough for the full preference dividend.
Worked example 2: cumulative preference dividend
Illustrative: Orchid's 10% preference shares (₹5,00,000) are cumulative. No dividend is paid in Year 1. Working: arrears = ₹50,000. In Year 2, before any equity dividend, preference holders must get Year 1 arrears plus Year 2's dividend: 50,000 + 50,000 = ₹1,00,000. Had they been non-cumulative, Year 1's dividend would simply be lost.
Key takeaways: equity shares give ownership, voting and residual returns, are permanent and create no charge, but are costly and dilute control; preference shares give fixed dividend and prior repayment without votes and come as cumulative, participating or convertible types; debentures are debt with fixed, tax-deductible interest that burdens earnings, and may be secured, registered, convertible or first types.
Check your understanding
-
1. Equity shareholders are called residual owners because they:
- get a fixed dividend
- receive what is left after all other claims are settled
- are paid before creditors
- have no voting rights
Show answer
Answer: B. They receive the residue of income and assets after all other claims, bearing the risk and reward of ownership.
-
2. Preference shares on which unpaid dividends accumulate and are paid in later years are:
- cumulative preference shares
- participating preference shares
- convertible preference shares
- non-cumulative preference shares
Show answer
Answer: A. Cumulative preference shares carry the right to accumulate unpaid dividends.
-
3. Debenture holders are the company's:
- owners
- partners
- preference shareholders
- creditors
Show answer
Answer: D. A debenture acknowledges a loan; debenture holders are creditors entitled to fixed interest.
-
4. Illustrative: a company has 8% debentures of ₹20,00,000 and earns ₹3,00,000 before interest. How much remains after debenture interest?
- ₹1,40,000
- ₹2,40,000
- ₹1,60,000
- ₹3,00,000
Show answer
Answer: A. Interest = 8% of 20,00,000 = ₹1,60,000. Remaining = 3,00,000 - 1,60,000 = ₹1,40,000.
-
5. Assertion (A): Raising funds through debentures is cheaper than through preference or equity shares. Reason (R): Interest on debentures is tax-deductible.
- A is true but R is false
- Both A and R are false
- Both A and R are true and R explains A
- A is false but R is true
Show answer
Answer: C. Tax deductibility of interest lowers the effective cost of debentures. R explains A.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.