- Foundation
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Retained earnings, trade credit and factoring
Explain retained earnings (ploughing back of profits), trade credit and factoring, including recourse and non-recourse factoring, with their merits and limitations.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain retained earnings and evaluate it as a source.
- Explain trade credit and its merits and limitations.
- Explain factoring, distinguishing recourse from non-recourse factoring.
We now study individual sources. There is no single best source for every organisation: the choice depends on the situation, purpose, cost and risk. We begin with three sources that arise from a firm's own trading.
Retained earnings
A company usually keeps part of its net earnings instead of paying it all as dividend. This is retained earnings, also called self-financing or ploughing back of profits, an internal source. How much is available depends on net profit, dividend policy and the age of the organisation.
| Merits | Limitations |
|---|---|
| Permanent source of funds | Excessive ploughing back may upset shareholders who get lower dividends |
| No explicit cost: no interest, dividend or flotation cost | Uncertain, because profits fluctuate |
| Operational freedom and flexibility | Its opportunity cost is often ignored, leading to sub-optimal use |
| Helps absorb unexpected losses | - |
| May raise the market price of equity shares | - |
Trade credit
Trade credit is credit given by one trader to another for purchase of goods and services, allowing supplies to be bought without immediate payment. It appears in the buyer's books as sundry creditors or accounts payable and is a common short-term source. It is granted to customers with reasonable financial standing and goodwill; its amount and period depend on the buyer's reputation, the seller's finances, volume of purchases, past payment record and competition.
Trade credit
-
Merits
- Convenient and continuous
- Readily available if creditworthiness is known
- Promotes sales
- Can finance extra stock before a sales rise
- Creates no charge on assets
-
Limitations
- Easy credit may lead to overtrading and risk
- Only limited funds
- Generally costly compared with most sources
Factoring
Factoring is a financial service in which a factor (a) discounts bills and collects the client's debts: the client's receivables are sold to the factor at a discount, and the factor handles credit control and collection; and (b) provides information on the creditworthiness of prospective customers, and may offer consultancy. The factor charges a fee. According to the textbook, factoring appeared in India in the early 1990s as a result of RBI initiatives.
Two methods of factoring
-
Recourse factoring
- Client is NOT protected against bad debts
- If the customer does not pay, the loss comes back to the client
-
Non-recourse factoring
- Factor bears the entire credit risk
- Client gets the full invoice amount even if the debt goes bad
| Merits of factoring | Limitations of factoring |
|---|---|
| Cheaper than other means such as bank credit | Expensive when invoices are many and small |
| Faster cash flow lets the client pay its own liabilities promptly | Advance finance usually costs more than the normal interest rate |
| Flexible; gives a definite pattern of cash inflows from credit sales | Customers may be uncomfortable dealing with a third party |
| Creates no charge on assets | - |
| Client can concentrate on other functions | - |
Retained earnings: internal, permanent, no explicit cost. Trade credit: convenient short-term credit from suppliers. Factoring: selling receivables to a factor who collects them; non-recourse means the factor bears bad debts.
Worked example 1: how much is ploughed back?
Illustrative: a made-up company, Rivera Tiles Ltd, earns a net profit after tax of ₹50 lakh and pays a dividend of ₹18 lakh. Working: retained earnings = 50 - 18 = ₹32 lakh. Retention ratio = 32 ÷ 50 = 64%. If shareholders press for a ₹30 lakh dividend, retained earnings fall to ₹20 lakh, illustrating the tension between dividends and self-financing.
Worked example 2: factoring with and without recourse
Illustrative: Rivera Tiles sells invoices worth ₹10,00,000 to a factor that pays 95% (keeping 5% as its discount and fee). Working: cash received now = 0.95 × 10,00,000 = ₹9,50,000; cost = ₹50,000. Later a customer owing ₹1,00,000 defaults. Under recourse factoring, Rivera bears this loss (it must make good the ₹1,00,000). Under non-recourse factoring, the factor bears it and Rivera keeps its ₹9,50,000. Non-recourse factoring therefore usually costs more.
Key takeaways: retained earnings are a permanent internal source with no explicit cost but depend on fluctuating profits and lower dividends; trade credit is convenient, continuous short-term credit from suppliers but limited and costly and may encourage overtrading; factoring turns receivables into cash and shifts collection to a factor, with bad-debt risk on the client (recourse) or the factor (non-recourse).
Check your understanding
-
1. Which source of finance involves no explicit cost such as interest, dividend or flotation cost?
- Debentures
- Retained earnings
- Public deposits
- Trade credit
Show answer
Answer: B. Retained earnings are generated internally, so there is no explicit cost, though there is an opportunity cost.
-
2. Trade credit appears in the buyer's books as:
- sundry creditors or accounts payable
- share capital
- fixed assets
- retained earnings
Show answer
Answer: A. Credit received from suppliers is recorded as sundry creditors or accounts payable.
-
3. Under non-recourse factoring:
- the client bears all bad debts
- no fee is charged
- the client must collect its own debts
- the factor assumes the entire credit risk
Show answer
Answer: D. In non-recourse factoring the factor bears the risk and pays the full invoice amount even if the debt goes bad.
-
4. Illustrative: a company earns net profit of ₹80 lakh and pays dividends of ₹30 lakh. Its retained earnings are:
- ₹110 lakh
- ₹30 lakh
- ₹50 lakh
- ₹80 lakh
Show answer
Answer: C. Retained earnings = 80 - 30 = ₹50 lakh.
-
5. Case: A made-up retailer uses easy supplier credit to stock far more goods than it can sell or pay for. Which limitation of trade credit does this show?
- Overtrading
- Dilution of control
- Charge on assets
- Lack of secrecy
Show answer
Answer: A. Easy and flexible trade credit may induce a firm to overtrade, adding to its risk.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.