- Foundation
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
Agriculture: the green revolution and the subsidy debate
Explain the green revolution, its two phases, marketed surplus and buffer stocks, the risks and how government met them, both sides of the subsidy debate, and why so many stayed in agriculture.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Define the green revolution and HYV seeds and describe its two phases.
- Explain marketed surplus and how the green revolution benefited consumers and the government.
- Present both sides of the debate on agricultural subsidies and explain why the share of people in agriculture stayed high.
According to the textbook, about 75 per cent of India's population depended on agriculture at independence. Productivity was very low because of old technology and lack of infrastructure, and farming depended on the monsoon; few farmers had irrigation to fall back on. The textbook says the stagnation of colonial times was permanently broken by the green revolution.
What the green revolution was
The green revolution refers to the large increase in production of food grains resulting from the use of High Yielding Variety (HYV) seeds, especially for wheat and rice. HYV seeds needed fertiliser and pesticide in correct quantities and a regular supply of water; applying these inputs in correct proportions was vital. So the farmers who could benefit needed reliable irrigation and money to buy fertiliser and pesticide.
| Phase | Approximate period | Spread |
|---|---|---|
| First phase | Mid-1960s to mid-1970s | Restricted to more affluent states such as Punjab, Andhra Pradesh and Tamil Nadu; mainly benefited wheat-growing regions |
| Second phase | Mid-1970s to mid-1980s | Spread to more states and benefited a larger variety of crops |
By the late 1960s, productivity had risen enough for India to become self-sufficient in food grains, so it no longer had to depend on America or any other nation for food.
Marketed surplus and its benefits
Higher output matters to the whole economy only if much of it reaches the market. The part of agricultural produce that farmers sell in the market is called the marketed surplus. During the green revolution a good share of rice and wheat was sold. As a result, the price of food grains fell relative to other goods, which helped low-income groups, who spend a large share of income on food. It also let the government procure enough food grains to build a stock for times of shortage.
How the green revolution reached the wider economy
- HYV seeds plus inputs Fertiliser, pesticide and assured water.
- Higher grain output Especially wheat and rice.
- Large marketed surplus Farmers sell a good share in the market.
- Relative food prices fall Low-income groups gain.
- Government builds stocks Grain stored for times of shortage.
Worked example 1: marketed surplus
Illustrative numbers (made up): a farm family grows 120 quintals of wheat. It keeps 18 quintals for food, 4 for seed and 3 for paying labour in kind. Marketed surplus = 120 − 18 − 4 − 3 = 95 quintals. As a share of output, 95 ÷ 120 × 100 ≈ 79 per cent. Before HYV seeds the family grew 40 quintals and kept the same 25, so the surplus was only 15 quintals (37.5 per cent). Higher output raised the marketed surplus more than six times.
Risks and how the government met them
- Risk 1, disparity: only big farmers could afford the inputs, so they might reap most of the benefit and the gap between small and big farmers could widen. Response: the government gave loans at low interest to small farmers and subsidised fertilisers. In time, output on small farms equalled that on large farms, so both gained.
- Risk 2, pests: HYV crops were more prone to pest attack, and small farmers could lose everything. Response: research institutes set up by the government considerably reduced this risk.
The textbook concludes that the green revolution would have favoured only rich farmers if the state had not played an extensive role in ensuring that small farmers also gained.
The debate over subsidies
Should agricultural subsidies continue?
-
Phase them out
- Needed only to encourage adoption of a risky new technology
- Purpose served once HYV is widely adopted
- Much of the fertiliser subsidy benefits the fertiliser industry
- Mainly helps farmers in prosperous regions
- Huge burden on government finances
-
Continue them
- Farming in India is still risky
- Most farmers are poor and cannot afford inputs
- Removing them would raise inequality and violate equity
- Fix the targeting so only poor farmers benefit, rather than abolish
It is generally agreed that subsidies were needed at first, because farmers see any new technology as risky. The textbook also explains prices as signals: when a good becomes scarce its price rises, telling users to economise. Some economists argue that subsidies stop prices from signalling scarcity. If water or electricity is free, it is used wastefully; farmers may grow water-intensive crops in water-scarce regions; and subsidised fertiliser and pesticide may be overused, harming the environment.
Worked example 2: a subsidy and its targeting
Illustrative numbers (made up): the government spends ₹1,000 crore on fertiliser subsidy. Suppose ₹300 crore effectively benefits the fertiliser industry and, of the remaining ₹700 crore, farmers in prosperous regions get 60 per cent. Benefit to prosperous-region farmers = 0.6 × 700 = ₹420 crore; to all other farmers = 700 − 420 = ₹280 crore, only 28 per cent of the spending. This is the targeting problem behind the debate: one side says abolish, the other says redesign so poor farmers gain.
Why so many stayed in agriculture
As a nation becomes more prosperous, both agriculture's share of GDP and the share of people working in it usually fall considerably. In India, between 1950 and 1990, agriculture's share of GDP declined significantly, but according to the textbook the share of the population depending on it fell only from 67.5 per cent in 1950 to 64.9 per cent by 1990. The reason: the industrial and service sectors did not absorb people from agriculture. Many economists call this an important failure of the policies of 1950-1990.
Marketed surplus is the part of farm output that farmers sell in the market. A large marketed surplus lowers relative food prices and lets the government build food stocks.
Key takeaways: the green revolution was the large rise in food grain output from HYV seeds (especially wheat and rice) used with fertiliser, pesticide and assured water. Its first phase (mid-1960s to mid-1970s) was limited to affluent states and wheat; the second (mid-1970s to mid-1980s) spread wider. India became self-sufficient in food grains by the late 1960s. A large marketed surplus lowered relative food prices and allowed buffer stocks. Low-interest loans, fertiliser subsidies and research institutes helped small farmers. Subsidies are debated on grounds of cost, targeting and price signals versus risk and equity. People did not leave agriculture because industry and services did not absorb them.
Check your understanding
-
1. In the first phase of the green revolution, the use of HYV seeds was restricted mainly to:
- affluent states such as Punjab, Andhra Pradesh and Tamil Nadu, and mainly wheat
- all states and all crops equally
- rice-growing eastern states only
- dry, rain-fed regions
Show answer
Answer: A. In the first phase (about mid-1960s to mid-1970s) HYV seeds were used in the more affluent states such as Punjab, Andhra Pradesh and Tamil Nadu, and mainly benefited wheat-growing regions.
-
2. Illustrative data (made up): a farmer produces 80 quintals of rice, keeps 12 for family use and 3 for seed. What is the marketed surplus?
- 68 quintals
- 77 quintals
- 65 quintals
- 15 quintals
Show answer
Answer: C. Marketed surplus = output − amount kept = 80 − 12 − 3 = 65 quintals. The 15 quintals kept back is not part of the marketed surplus.
-
3. How did the green revolution help low-income groups?
- It raised the price of food grains
- Large marketed surplus lowered the price of food grains relative to other goods, and the poor spend a large share of income on food
- It gave every poor family land
- It ended the need for food stocks
Show answer
Answer: B. Because a good share of rice and wheat was sold in the market, food grain prices fell relative to other items. Low-income groups, who spend a large percentage of income on food, benefited.
-
4. Assertion (A): The green revolution benefited small as well as rich farmers. Reason (R): The government gave small farmers loans at low interest and subsidised fertilisers.
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is true, but R is false
- A is false, but R is true
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
Show answer
Answer: D. The chapter says these steps let small farmers obtain the required inputs, so output on small farms came to equal that on large farms and the green revolution benefited both. R explains A.
-
5. According to the textbook, why did about 65 per cent of the population remain in agriculture even in 1990?
- Agriculture was the most profitable sector
- Land reforms forced people to stay on farms
- Industry and services did not absorb people working in agriculture
- The green revolution needed more workers on each farm
Show answer
Answer: C. The share depending on agriculture fell only from 67.5 to 64.9 per cent between 1950 and 1990 (according to the textbook) because the industrial and service sectors did not absorb these workers, which many economists call a policy failure.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.