• Foundation
  • About 17 min
  • 5 practice questions

Choosing an economic system and the start of planning

Compare capitalism, socialism and the mixed economy through the three central questions, explain why India chose planning, and describe the Planning Commission and the role of Mahalanobis.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • State the three questions every economy must answer and how capitalism, socialism and a mixed economy answer them.
  • Explain why India's leaders chose a mixed economy with planning.
  • Define a plan and a perspective plan, and describe Mahalanobis's role in Indian planning.

When India became independent on 15 August 1947, nation building was in its own hands for the first time in about two hundred years. Among the first decisions its leaders had to make was the type of economic system that would promote the welfare of all rather than a few. This lesson explains the choice they made and how planning began.

The three central questions

Every society has to answer three questions: what goods and services to produce, how to produce them (with more human labour or more capital, that is, machines), and how to distribute them among people. Different economic systems answer these questions differently.

How the three systems answer the central questions
QuestionMarket economy (capitalism)Socialist economyMixed economy
What to produceGoods that are in demand and can be sold profitablyGovernment decides, according to the needs of societyMarket produces what it can do well; government provides essential goods the market fails to provide
How to produceCheaper method: labour-intensive if labour is cheaper than capital, and vice versaGovernment decidesShared between market and government
How to distributeBy purchasing power, the ability to buyIn principle by need, not ability to payMarket by purchasing power, with government support for essentials
PropertyPrivateStrictly, no private property; the state owns everythingBoth private and public

In a market economy, a much-needed good such as low-cost housing for the poor may not be produced, because the poor lack purchasing power to back their need with money; it does not count as demand in the market sense. This did not appeal to Jawaharlal Nehru, India's first Prime Minister, because it would leave most people behind. Socialism appealed to him most, but not the Soviet kind, where the government owned all factories and farms and there was no private property. In a democracy like India, the government could not change the ownership of land and property in that way.

India's answer: a mixed economy with planning

Nehru and many other leaders sought an alternative to the extreme versions of capitalism and socialism. According to the textbook, they chose a system which, in their view, combined the best features of socialism without its drawbacks: a socialist society with a strong public sector, but also with private property and democracy. The government would plan for the economy, and the private sector would be encouraged to be part of the plan effort. The Industrial Policy Resolution of 1948 and the Directive Principles of the Constitution reflected this outlook. In 1950 the Planning Commission was set up with the Prime Minister as its Chairperson, and the era of five year plans began.

Three types of economic system

  • Capitalism
    • Market forces of supply and demand decide
    • Distribution by purchasing power
    • Private property
  • Socialism
    • Government decides according to social needs
    • Distribution by need
    • State owns everything
  • Mixed economy
    • Government and market together decide
    • Government supplies essentials the market fails to provide
    • Private and public property; India's choice

What a plan is

A plan sets out how a nation's resources are to be used, with general goals and specific objectives to be achieved within a fixed period. In India the period was five years, so the plans were called five year plans.

India borrowed the idea of five year plans from the former Soviet Union, the pioneer of national planning. According to the textbook, India's plan documents up to 2017 also stated what was to be achieved over twenty years; this long-term plan is called the perspective plan, and the five year plans were meant to provide its basis. Indian plans did not state how much of every good was to be produced; that is neither possible nor necessary (the Soviet Union tried and failed). It is enough for a plan to be specific about sectors where it plays a commanding role, such as power generation and irrigation, leaving the rest to the market.

Mahalanobis: the architect of Indian planning

Among many contributors, the statistician Prasanta Chandra Mahalanobis stands out. According to the textbook, planning in the real sense began with the Second Five Year Plan, which was based on his ideas, so he can be regarded as the architect of Indian planning. Born in 1893 in Calcutta and educated at Presidency College, Calcutta and Cambridge University, he was made a Fellow of Britain's Royal Society in 1945. He founded the Indian Statistical Institute (ISI) in Calcutta and started the journal Sankhya. He invited economists from India and abroad to advise on the plan, including critics of its socialist principles, showing he was willing to listen to critics. The book notes that many economists today reject his approach to planning, but he is remembered for putting India on the road to economic progress.

Worked example 1: what the market produces

Illustrative numbers (made up): a builder can sell flats to rich buyers at a profit of ₹5 lakh each, or build low-cost homes that poor families need but can pay only ₹2 lakh for, while each costs ₹3 lakh to build. Profit on a low-cost home = 2 − 3 = −₹1 lakh (a loss). A purely market-driven builder will build only the profitable flats. Step by step this shows the textbook's point: need without purchasing power is not demand, so a mixed economy expects the government to step in for such essentials.

Worked example 2: choosing a method of production

Illustrative numbers (made up): a firm can make 1,000 bags either with 20 workers at ₹300 a day each, or with one machine costing ₹4,500 a day plus 5 workers. Labour-intensive cost = 20 × 300 = ₹6,000. Capital-intensive cost = 4,500 + 5 × 300 = ₹6,000. They tie. If wages fell to ₹250, the labour method would cost 20 × 250 = ₹5,000 against 4,500 + 1,250 = ₹5,750, so a market firm would choose more labour. This is how a market economy answers the question of how to produce.

Key takeaways: every economy answers what, how and for whom to produce. Capitalism relies on market forces and purchasing power; socialism on government decisions and need; a mixed economy combines them. India chose a mixed economy with a strong public sector, private property and democracy, reflected in the Industrial Policy Resolution of 1948 and the Directive Principles. The Planning Commission was set up in 1950 with the Prime Minister as Chairperson. A plan sets goals for a fixed period; a perspective plan covers twenty years. Mahalanobis, whose ideas shaped the Second Plan, is regarded as the architect of Indian planning.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. In a capitalist economy, goods are distributed among people on the basis of:

    1. what people need
    2. a government ration list
    3. purchasing power
    4. equal shares for all
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Under capitalism goods are distributed not by need but by purchasing power, the ability to buy. That is why low-cost housing for the poor may not count as demand.

  2. 2. When was the Planning Commission set up, and who was its Chairperson?

    1. 1948, the President
    2. 1950, the Prime Minister
    3. 1956, the Finance Minister
    4. 1947, the Governor-General
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The Planning Commission was set up in 1950 with the Prime Minister as its Chairperson. 1948 is the year of the first Industrial Policy Resolution and 1956 of the second.

  3. 3. Why did Nehru reject Soviet-style socialism for India?

    1. Because India had no public sector
    2. Because in a democracy the government could not change the ownership of land and property as the Soviet Union had done
    3. Because he favoured pure capitalism
    4. Because socialism did not allow planning
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The chapter says it is not possible in a democracy like India to change citizens' ownership of land and property the way the Soviet Union did, where the state owned all farms and factories.

  4. 4. Assertion (A): Mahalanobis can be regarded as the architect of Indian planning. Reason (R): The Second Five Year Plan, with which planning in the real sense began, was based on his ideas.

    1. A is false, but R is true
    2. A is true, but R is false
    3. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    4. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The chapter says planning in the real sense began with the Second Plan, which was based on Mahalanobis's ideas, and that in this sense he can be regarded as the architect of Indian planning. So R explains A.

  5. 5. What is a perspective plan?

    1. A long-term plan covering about twenty years, for which five year plans provide the basis
    2. A plan for a single year
    3. A plan that fixes the output of every good
    4. A plan made only for the private sector
    Show answer

    Answer: A. According to the chapter, plan documents also set out what is to be achieved over twenty years; this long-term plan is the perspective plan, and five year plans were meant to provide its basis.

Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.

Next lesson → The four goals of the five year plans

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery