• Foundation
  • About 18 min
  • 5 practice questions

Industry and trade: public sector, IPR 1956 and import substitution

Explain why the state led industrialisation, the IPR 1956 and licensing, small-scale industry policy, import substitution through tariffs and quotas, and the achievements and criticisms that led to the 1991 reforms.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain why the public sector was given a leading role and describe the three categories of IPR 1956 and the licence system.
  • Explain small-scale industry policy and import substitution through tariffs and quotas.
  • Weigh the achievements of industrial policy against the criticisms that led to the new economic policy of 1991.

Economists have found that poor nations progress only with a good industrial sector: industry gives more stable employment than agriculture and promotes modernisation and prosperity. At independence India's industry was narrow, largely cotton textiles and jute, with two well-managed iron and steel firms, one in Jamshedpur and one in Kolkata. The plans therefore stressed industrial development.

Why the state led industrialisation

  • Indian industrialists lacked the capital for the investment the economy needed.
  • The market was too small to encourage major projects even if capital existed.
  • The decision to develop on socialist lines led to the state controlling the commanding heights of the economy, as the Second Plan put it: complete control of industries vital to the economy, with the private sector complementing the public sector.

Industrial Policy Resolution 1956

The Industrial Policy Resolution of 1956 (IPR 1956) was adopted in line with the goal of state control of the commanding heights. It formed the basis of the Second Five Year Plan, which tried to build the basis for a socialist pattern of society. It classified industries into three categories.

Industrial Policy Resolution 1956

  • Category 1
    • Exclusively owned by the government
  • Category 2
    • Private sector could supplement the public sector
    • Government solely responsible for starting new units
  • Category 3
    • Remaining industries, in the private sector
    • Still controlled through licences

Even the third category was kept under state control through licences. No new industry could start without one. Licences were easier to get for units in economically backward areas, which also received concessions such as tax benefits and cheaper electricity, to promote regional equality. Even an existing firm needed a licence to expand output or diversify (produce a new variety of goods), to ensure output did not exceed what the economy required.

Small-scale industry

In 1955 the Village and Small-Scale Industries Committee, also called the Karve Committee, saw scope for using small-scale industries to promote rural development. A small-scale industry is defined by the maximum investment allowed on a unit's assets. The limit has changed over time; according to the textbook, in 1950 it was ₹5 lakh. Small units are believed to be more labour intensive, so they generate more employment, but they cannot compete with big firms. So the production of a number of products was reserved for them, and they got concessions such as lower excise duty and bank loans at lower interest.

Trade policy: import substitution

Trade in the first seven plans followed an inward looking trade strategy, technically called import substitution: replacing imports with domestic production, for example making vehicles in India instead of importing them. Domestic industries were protected in two ways. Tariffs are a tax on imported goods, making them dearer. Quotas specify the quantity of a good that can be imported. Protection rested on the belief that industries of developing countries could not yet compete with those of developed countries but would learn to in time. Planners also feared foreign exchange would be spent on luxury imports. No serious thought was given to promoting exports until the mid-1980s.

Worked example 1: how a tariff protects

Illustrative numbers (made up): an imported radio costs ₹800 landed in India; a domestic radio costs ₹1,000. Buyers prefer the import. A tariff of 40 per cent adds 0.40 × 800 = ₹320, so the import now costs 800 + 320 = ₹1,120, more than the domestic ₹1,000. Demand shifts to the domestic producer. A quota of, say, 5,000 imported radios a year would protect in a different way, by limiting quantity rather than raising price.

Achievements

According to the textbook, industry's share of GDP rose from 13 per cent in 1950-51 to 24.6 per cent in 1990-91, and the industrial sector grew at about six per cent a year, which it calls commendable. Industry became well diversified by 1990, largely due to the public sector. Small-scale industry let people without much capital enter business, and protection enabled indigenous electronics and automobile industries to develop.

Criticisms

  • Public sector beyond need: state enterprises kept producing goods and services, often as monopolies, after this was no longer needed. Telecommunication stayed reserved for the public sector, and according to the textbook one had to wait a long time for a telephone connection even in the late 1990s. A government bread firm, Modern Bread, was set up as if the private sector could not make bread; it was sold to the private sector in 2001.
  • Losses: many public sector firms made huge losses but kept running because it is difficult to close a government undertaking.
  • Permit licence raj: big industrialists sometimes obtained licences not to start firms but to block competitors. Industrialists spent more time lobbying for licences than improving products.
  • Protection too long: with a captive market, producers had no incentive to improve quality and could sell low-quality goods at high prices.

The textbook also gives the other side: some economists hold that the public sector should be judged by its contribution to welfare, not profit, and that India should protect its producers as long as rich nations protect theirs. These conflicts, with other problems, led to a new economic policy in 1991.

Worked example 2: change in industry's share

Using the textbook's figures: industry's share rose from 13 per cent to 24.6 per cent of GDP. Increase in percentage points = 24.6 − 13 = 11.6 points. Relative increase = 11.6 ÷ 13 × 100 ≈ 89 per cent, so industry's share nearly doubled over the first seven plans. Notice the difference between a change in percentage points (11.6) and a percentage change (about 89 per cent).

Import substitution means producing at home what was imported, protected by tariffs (a tax on imports) and quotas (a limit on the quantity of imports).

Key takeaways: the state led industrialisation because private capital and the market were small and India chose to control the commanding heights. IPR 1956 set three categories of industry and a licence system that also promoted regional equality. The Karve Committee (1955) promoted small-scale industry, protected by reservation and concessions. Import substitution used tariffs and quotas. According to the textbook, industry's GDP share rose from 13 to 24.6 per cent and the sector became diversified. Criticisms of inefficient public enterprises, the permit licence raj and over-long protection led to the new economic policy of 1991.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Under IPR 1956, the second category of industries was one in which:

    1. only the private sector could operate
    2. the private sector could supplement the public sector, with the government solely responsible for starting new units
    3. industries were exclusively owned by the government
    4. no licence was required
    Show answer

    Answer: B. IPR 1956 had three categories: exclusively government-owned; private sector supplementing the public sector with the government solely responsible for new units; and the remaining industries in the private sector, still under licences.

  2. 2. Illustrative data (made up): an imported fan costs ₹1,500 and a domestic fan ₹1,800. What is the smallest whole-number tariff rate that makes the imported fan at least as costly as the domestic one?

    1. 15 per cent
    2. 30 per cent
    3. 25 per cent
    4. 20 per cent
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The tariff must add at least 1,800 − 1,500 = ₹300. Rate = 300 ÷ 1,500 × 100 = 20 per cent. At 20 per cent the import costs exactly 1,500 + 300 = ₹1,800.

  3. 3. The Karve Committee of 1955 is associated with:

    1. promoting small-scale industries for rural development
    2. abolishing zamindari
    3. setting up the Planning Commission
    4. the green revolution
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The Village and Small-Scale Industries Committee, also called the Karve Committee (1955), noted the possibility of using small-scale industries for promoting rural development.

  4. 4. Assertion (A): Protection from imports reduced the incentive of Indian producers to improve quality. Reason (R): With imports restricted, producers had a captive market and could sell low-quality goods at high prices.

    1. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    2. A is false, but R is true
    3. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    4. A is true, but R is false
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The chapter says consumers had to buy whatever Indian producers made; knowing they had a captive market, producers had no incentive to improve quality. R explains A.

  5. 5. Case: An industrialist obtains a licence for a new cement unit but never builds it, because holding the licence stops rivals from getting one. Which criticism from the chapter does this illustrate?

    1. Losses of public sector enterprises
    2. Misuse of the licence system under the permit licence raj
    3. Over-reservation for small-scale industry
    4. Excessive export promotion
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The chapter says the need for licences was misused: a big industrialist would get a licence not to start a new firm but to prevent competitors from starting one. This is part of the permit licence raj.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery