• Foundation
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Themes, tone and poetic devices in A Photograph

Explain the poem's themes of time, change, memory and loss, its nostalgic and elegiac tone, and devices such as contrast, metonymy, transferred epithet, oxymoron and personification.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain the central contrast between the sea and human life.
  • Interpret the mother's laughter and the poet's wry feeling of loss.
  • Identify and explain the poem's main devices with original examples.
  • Describe the tone and mood of each stanza.

Short as it is, the poem packs a great deal into a few words. Board questions often ask what has not changed over the years, what the mother's laugh shows, what the wry line in stanza 2 means and what 'this circumstance' refers to. This lesson prepares you for all of them.

Theme 1: the sea and human life

The poet notes that the sea seems to have changed less than the people in the picture. Nature appears almost permanent; human life is brief. The girls' feet are called terribly transient: the same waves still wash the shore, but the girls have grown up, grown old and, in the mother's case, died. This contrast is the heart of the poem.

Permanence and transience

  • The sea
    • Has hardly changed over the years
    • Still washes the shore as before
    • Stands for nature and time going on
  • The people
    • The girl grew up, aged and died
    • The cousins and the uncle are part of the past
    • Stand for brief, changing human life

Theme 2: memory and loss, twice over

In stanza 2, the mother looks at her own childhood and laughs. Her laughter is affectionate, but it carries a touch of sadness: that carefree time is gone for ever. The poet, in turn, remembers her mother's laughter, which is now also gone. So there are two losses: the mother lost her childhood; the poet has lost her mother. Both feelings are wry, a mix of amusement and pain, and both are borne with a 'laboured ease': the people appear to accept the loss calmly, but the calm takes effort.

Theme 3: grief beyond words

By the third stanza the mother has been dead almost as long as the girl in the picture had lived, that is, roughly twelve years. 'This circumstance' refers to her death. The poet says there is nothing to say about it, and the final line suggests that death's silence makes her silent as well. Grief is so deep that words fail.

Poetic devices

Examples in the third column are written for this lesson.
DeviceWhere in the poemOur own example of the device
MetonymyThe cardboard stands for the photographThe pen is mightier than the sword (pen = writing, sword = war).
Transferred epithetTransient describes the feet, but it is human life that is passingHe spent a sleepless night (the person, not the night, could not sleep).
ContrastThe lasting sea against brief human livesThe old banyan watched three generations of children come and go.
Oxymoron or paradoxThe ease of loss is called laboured: an easy feeling that takes effortTheir sweet sorrow at parting lasted all evening.
Personification and repetitionSilence is given the power to silence the poetThe empty house whispered of days gone by.
Free verseNo fixed rhyme or metre in the whole poemLines that follow thought rather than a beat.

Tone and mood

StanzaTone or mood
1Gentle and affectionate, with a hint of sadness about passing time
2Nostalgic and wry: amusement mixed with a sense of loss
3Elegiac (mourning), sombre and silent

Worked example 1: what has not changed?

Question: what has not changed over the years, and what does this suggest? Working: the poet says the sea seems to have changed less than the people. Answer: the sea has stayed much the same. This suggests that nature lasts while human beings and their happy moments are brief.

Worked example 2: the mother's laugh

Question: what does the mother's laughter at the snapshot show? Working: she is amused by the old clothes and fond of her cousins, but the holiday is long over. Answer: it shows affectionate nostalgia for her childhood, tinged with a quiet sadness that those days are gone.

Nature endures; people pass. The photograph freezes a moment, but memory turns it into both a smile and a loss.

Key takeaways: the poem contrasts the unchanging sea with transient human life, shows a double loss (the mother's childhood, then the mother herself) and ends in a grief too deep for words. Watch for metonymy, transferred epithet, oxymoron and personification.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. What is the main contrast in the first stanza?

    1. The unchanging sea and the passing lives of the girls
    2. The uncle and the camera
    3. Summer and winter
    4. The city and the village
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The sea seems to have changed less than the girls, whose feet are called transient. Nature lasts; human life passes.

  2. 2. In the second stanza, the mother's past is the sea holiday. What is the poet's past?

    1. Her own beach holiday
    2. The uncle's camera
    3. Her cousins Betty and Dolly
    4. Her mother's laughter at the snapshot
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The poet remembers her mother laughing at the photograph; now that the mother is dead, that laughter is the poet's lost past.

  3. 3. What does 'this circumstance' in the third stanza refer to?

    1. The seaside holiday
    2. The mother's death
    3. The old clothes
    4. The poet's birthday
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The third stanza says the mother has been dead for many years; 'this circumstance' is her death, about which the poet says nothing can be said.

  4. 4. Which device is used in calling the feet 'transient'?

    1. Transferred epithet
    2. Simile
    3. Onomatopoeia
    4. Alliteration
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Feet do not pass away; human lives do. The quality of the people is transferred to their feet, which makes it a transferred epithet.

  5. 5. Which word best describes the tone of the last stanza?

    1. Comic
    2. Angry
    3. Elegiac
    4. Excited
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The last stanza mourns the mother's death and ends in silence, so its tone is elegiac (mournful) and sombre.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery