• Foundation
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Writing: appreciating the poem and a diary entry on an old photograph

Write a short critical appreciation of A Photograph, compare it with The Portrait of a Lady, and write a diary entry about finding an old photograph, using models and a checklist.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Write a structured critical appreciation of a poem in about 150 words.
  • Compare the poem with The Portrait of a Lady on theme and treatment.
  • Write a diary entry with the correct format and a reflective tone.
  • Use a checklist to improve your draft.

Questions on a poem in Class 11 often ask for a long answer: the central idea, the significance of the title, or how the poet expresses loss. A clear plan helps. The diary task lets you practise reflective writing on the poem's theme. The people in our models are made up.

Planning a critical appreciation

A poem appreciation in five parts

  • Introduction
    • Title, poet, form
    • Central idea in one sentence
  • Content
    • What happens, stanza by stanza
    • Keep it short
  • Themes
    • Time and change
    • Memory and loss
  • Devices and language
    • Two or three devices with their effect
  • Conclusion
    • Tone and your response
    • Why the poem matters

Worked example 1: model appreciation (written for this lesson)

*Shirley Toulson's 'A Photograph' is a free-verse poem in which a single old photograph opens up three moments in time. In the first stanza the poet's mother, about twelve, paddles at the seaside with two cousins while an uncle takes a picture; the second shows the grown-up mother laughing at the snapshot; the third finds the poet, years after her mother's death, with nothing left to say. The poem sets the almost unchanging sea against fragile human lives, and shows loss twice: the mother loses her childhood, the poet loses her mother. Words such as 'transient' and the paradox of an easy loss that takes effort show how calmly the pain is carried, while the final personified silence shows grief beyond words. The tone moves from affection to wistfulness to mourning. The poem reminds us how precious, and how brief, our time with loved ones is.*

Comparing the poem and the memoir

PointThe Portrait of a LadyA Photograph
Loved oneThe author's grandmotherThe poet's mother
FormProse memoirFree-verse poem
Can the young imagine the old as young?No; the narrator finds it hard to believeYes; the photograph shows the mother as a girl
How death is shownPeaceful death in prayer; silent sparrowsSilence that leaves the poet without words
Shared themesTime, change, love, lossTime, change, love, loss

Writing a diary entry

A diary entry is personal and reflective. Format: place and date (top), day and time (optional), a salutation such as Dear Diary (optional), the body in the first person with your feelings, and your name or initial at the end. Use past tenses for events and present tense for your feelings now.

Worked example 2: model diary entry (written for this lesson)

*Pune / 14 May / 9:30 p.m. / Dear Diary, / Today, while clearing Nani's cupboard, I found a photograph I had never seen: three girls in frocks on a beach, the tallest one squinting and laughing into the sun. Mother said it was Nani at about thirteen. I could not stop looking at it. I have only known Nani with her walking stick and reading glasses; here she was, barefoot, with sand on her knees. Mother told me Nani used to laugh about the frocks, which had been stitched by her aunt for that one trip. Nani is no longer with us, and I suddenly felt how much I had never asked her. I have put the photograph in my desk drawer. Tomorrow I will ask Mother for the rest of the story, before it too is lost. / Riya (a made-up writer)*

  • Format: place, date, time, salutation, signature.
  • First person and reflective tone.
  • Past tense for events, present for feelings now, future for a resolve.
  • One clear event and a thought it led to.

Appreciation: introduction, content, themes, devices with effect, conclusion. Diary: place, date, time, Dear Diary, first person, feelings, signature.

Key takeaways: a good appreciation is structured and explains the effect of devices. Comparing the poem with the memoir shows their shared themes. A diary entry is personal, reflective and correctly formatted.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. What should the first sentence of a poem appreciation include?

    1. The poet's address
    2. The title, poet and central idea
    3. A list of all difficult words
    4. A question for the examiner
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The introduction names the poem and the poet, and states the central idea briefly so the reader knows what follows.

  2. 2. Which point is a difference between the memoir and the poem?

    1. Both deal with loss.
    2. Both involve an older loved one.
    3. Both are about time and change.
    4. The memoir is prose; the poem is free verse.
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The other three are similarities. The form, prose memoir versus free-verse poem, is a difference.

  3. 3. Which tense is most suitable for describing your feelings now in a diary entry?

    1. Present tense
    2. Past perfect
    3. Future perfect
    4. Past continuous
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Events of the day are in the past tense, but feelings you have while writing are best in the present tense.

  4. 4. Which feature does NOT belong in a diary entry?

    1. Date
    2. First-person voice
    3. A subject line and the receiver's address
    4. Personal feelings
    Show answer

    Answer: C. A subject line and the receiver's address belong to a formal letter. A diary has a date, a personal voice and feelings.

  5. 5. In an appreciation, after naming a device, you should ______.

    1. move straight to the next device
    2. copy the whole stanza
    3. explain its effect on the reader
    4. count the words in the line
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Naming a device earns little unless you explain what it does, for example how a transferred epithet stresses that human life is short.

Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.

Next lesson → Final self-assessment: A Photograph

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery