- Foundation
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Evidence and persuasion: the zoo, the four systems and population
Explain the Lusaka zoo notice, how the Earth's biological systems are being depleted, why population growth is called a major threat, and how Palkhivala uses quotations and images to persuade.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain what the notice at the Lusaka zoo signifies.
- Describe how fisheries, forests, grasslands and croplands are being depleted.
- Explain why the writer sees population growth as a major threat to the future.
- Identify the writer's persuasive techniques and discuss the chapter's debate topics.
The chapter's comprehension questions focus on four parts of the argument. This lesson takes each in turn, then looks at how the writer convinces his readers.
The world's most dangerous animal
At the zoo in Lusaka, Zambia, a cage carries a notice saying it holds the world's most dangerous animal. Inside there is no animal, only a mirror, so every visitor sees himself or herself. The point is that human beings are the greatest threat to the planet, through greed, pollution and destruction. The writer adds hopefully that humans are now realising the need to move from domination of nature to partnership with it.
How the four biological systems are being depleted
The Earth's principal biological systems (as Lester Brown identifies them)
-
Fisheries
- Over-fishing to meet the demand for protein
- Fish stocks collapse
-
Forests
- Cut for firewood and land
- Tropical forests, a powerhouse of evolution, are shrinking
- Species face extinction
-
Grasslands
- Over-grazed and over-used
- Turn into barren wasteland
-
Croplands
- Over-used soil deteriorates
- Burning dung for fuel robs fields of natural manure
These four systems supply our food and almost all the raw materials for industry except minerals and petroleum-based products. When human demands go beyond what they can renew, their productivity is damaged. The writer uses a striking saying: forests come before people, and deserts come after them.
Forests in India
The writer notes that Article 48A of the Constitution asks the State to protect the environment and the forests and wildlife. Yet he complains that laws in India are too often neither respected nor enforced, and cites a parliamentary committee report on the alarming loss of forests, with large areas officially called forest land that have almost no trees.
Why population growth matters
- Population had grown faster and faster over the last two centuries, as the article's 1994 figures show.
- Rising numbers put more pressure on every natural system.
- Fertility falls as incomes rise, education spreads and health improves, so development is the best answer; but rapid growth itself can block development.
- More children in poor families do not mean more workers, only more people without work, so poverty continues.
- The writer rejects force and calls for voluntary family planning; the choice, he says, is between controlling population and continuing poverty.
How the writer persuades
| Technique | Example in the article (in our words) |
|---|---|
| Extended metaphor | The Earth as a patient whose vital signs show declining health |
| Quoting experts and leaders | The World Commission, the Brandt Report, Lester Brown, a World Resources Institute president, Margaret Thatcher |
| Striking anecdote | The mirror in the cage at Lusaka zoo |
| Memorable sayings | We have borrowed the earth from our children, not inherited it from our ancestors |
| Facts and figures | Rates of forest loss and population growth (as of 1994) |
| Hopeful close | The environmental problem as a passport to the future; an Era of Responsibility |
Two closing ideas sum up the article. Margaret Thatcher said, in effect, that no generation owns the Earth outright: each is only a tenant for life, responsible for keeping it in good repair. Lester Brown's saying makes the same point: we have borrowed the Earth from our children. Industry too must act, as the chairman of the chemical company Du Pont did when he called himself its chief environmental officer.
Worked example: significance of the zoo notice
Model answer (about 50 words): The notice promises the world's most dangerous animal, but the cage holds only a mirror. Each visitor sees himself, realising that humans, by destroying forests, over-using resources and polluting, are the greatest threat to life on Earth. It is a sharp reminder that we must change our behaviour.
We do not own the Earth; we hold it on a life tenancy, and must hand it on in good repair.
Key takeaways: the mirror shows that humans are the real danger. Over-use is degrading fisheries, forests, grasslands and croplands. Rapid population growth deepens poverty and pressure on nature. Palkhivala persuades through metaphor, expert quotations, anecdote and memorable sayings.
Check your understanding
-
1. What does the mirror in the cage at Lusaka zoo signify?
- Humans are the most dangerous animal on Earth.
- The zoo has no animals.
- Visitors should look smart.
- Animals like mirrors.
Show answer
Answer: A. Visitors see themselves in the mirror under a notice about the most dangerous animal, showing that humans are the greatest threat to the planet.
-
2. Which of these is NOT one of the four principal biological systems named in the article?
- Fisheries
- Forests
- Croplands
- Mines
Show answer
Answer: D. Lester Brown names fisheries, forests, grasslands and croplands. Minerals come from mines, which the article treats separately.
-
3. Why does the writer call development 'the best contraceptive'?
- Because development needs more workers
- Because fertility falls as incomes, education and health improve
- Because rich people have more children
- Because laws force small families
Show answer
Answer: B. The article says fertility falls as incomes rise, education spreads and health improves, so development naturally reduces birth rates.
-
4. What does burning dung for fuel do, according to the article?
- It deprives the soil of a natural fertiliser.
- It cleans the air.
- It improves fish stocks.
- It saves forests completely.
Show answer
Answer: A. Dung is a natural manure; burning it as fuel means the soil loses an important source of fertility.
-
5. What is the main idea behind the saying that we have borrowed the Earth from our children?
- Children own all land.
- We should borrow money for the environment.
- We must hand the Earth on in good condition to future generations.
- Parents should give land to children.
Show answer
Answer: C. The saying means the present generation is only a temporary caretaker, responsible to future generations for the Earth's health.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.