- Foundation
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
The Ailing Planet: the article and its argument
Understand Nani Palkhivala's 1994 newspaper article on the Earth's declining health: its context, the order of its argument, and the meaning of expressions such as holistic, sustainable development, decimated and inter alia.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Say who wrote the article, when and where it was published, and what kind of writing it is.
- Summarise its argument in the right order, in your own words.
- Explain the key expressions listed in the chapter from context.
- Find the lines of thought that support the title The Ailing Planet.
The Ailing Planet: the Green Movement's Role is a newspaper article by Nani Palkhivala (1920-2002), one of India's most respected lawyers and constitutional experts, also known as an economist and public speaker. It was published in The Indian Express on 24 November 1994. The textbook notes that the problems he raised about the Earth's health are still relevant. The article is an argumentative essay: it presents evidence and quotations from experts to persuade readers that the planet is sick and that everyone must act responsibly.
The argument in order (our summary)
How the article builds its case
- The Green Movement No movement has caught the world's imagination so fast; the first nationwide Green party was founded in New Zealand in 1972.
- A new world view We are moving from seeing the world as a machine to seeing it as a whole, living system, a change as great as Copernicus's discovery.
- A sick patient The Earth's vital signs show declining health; we must be good stewards for future generations; sustainable development is the way.
- Humans as the danger A zoo notice and a mirror make the point that man is the most dangerous animal, now learning partnership instead of domination.
- Damage to natural systems Fisheries, forests, grasslands and croplands are being over-used; forests are vanishing, in India too, despite the Constitution.
- Population Rapid population growth threatens development and keeps the poor poor; voluntary family planning is urgent.
- An Era of Responsibility Concern now reaches the survival of the planet itself; industry and every generation must act as caretakers.
Key facts from the article
| Point | As the article gives it |
|---|---|
| First nationwide Green party | Founded in New Zealand in 1972 |
| Sustainable development | Popularised in 1987 by the World Commission on Environment and Development |
| Earth's four principal biological systems (Lester Brown) | Fisheries, forests, grasslands and croplands |
| Constitutional duty | Article 48A asks the State to protect and improve the environment and safeguard forests and wildlife |
| An early commission on these issues | The Brandt Commission, with the Indian member L.K. Jha |
Expressions from the chapter
| Expression | Meaning in context |
|---|---|
| a holistic and ecological view | seeing the world as one connected whole in which all living things depend on each other |
| sustainable development | progress that meets today's needs without using up what future generations will need |
| languish | remain neglected, in a weak or forgotten state |
| ignominious darkness | shameful obscurity; here, species that remain unknown and unnamed |
| inter alia | among other things (Latin) |
| decimated | destroyed in large numbers |
| catastrophic depletion | a disastrous using-up or loss |
| transcending concern | a concern that rises above all others |
Worked example 1: lines that support the title
Question: which ideas in the article support the title The Ailing Planet? Answer: the writer says the Earth's vital signs show a patient in declining health; he quotes a commission asking whether we will leave our successors a scorched, ailing planet; he describes collapsing fisheries, disappearing forests and degraded land; and he cites a United Nations study that found the environment critical in many countries.
Worked example 2: sustainable development
Question: explain sustainable development in your own words with an example. Answer: it means meeting our needs today without stripping nature of what our grandchildren will need. For example, a village that cuts only as much wood as its forest can regrow each year, and plants new trees, is developing sustainably.
The Earth is a patient, not a machine: diagnose its illness, accept responsibility, and treat it for the sake of those who come after us.
Key takeaways: the article (1994) argues that the Earth is ailing because of human over-use and population pressure, and that the Green Movement has brought a new, holistic view and an Era of Responsibility. Learn its order of ideas and key terms.
Check your understanding
-
1. Who wrote The Ailing Planet, and where was it first published?
- Lester Brown, in a book on economics
- Nani Palkhivala, in The Indian Express
- Margaret Thatcher, in a speech
- L.K. Jha, in the Brandt Report
Show answer
Answer: B. The article was written by Nani Palkhivala and published in The Indian Express on 24 November 1994.
-
2. What does 'holistic' mean in 'a holistic and ecological view'?
- Seeing the world as a machine
- Religious
- Damaged
- Seeing the world as one connected whole
Show answer
Answer: D. A holistic view sees the whole system and the links between its parts, rather than isolated pieces.
-
3. Which shift in thinking does the writer compare to Copernicus's discovery?
- From a mechanistic view to a holistic, ecological view of the world
- From farming to industry
- From poverty to wealth
- From kings to democracy
Show answer
Answer: A. He says the move from seeing the world as a machine to seeing it as a living whole is as revolutionary as Copernicus's teaching that planets revolve round the sun.
-
4. What does 'decimated' mean in the context of forests?
- Planted
- Measured
- Destroyed in large numbers
- Protected
Show answer
Answer: C. The article says local forests are being decimated for firewood, that is, destroyed on a large scale.
-
5. Where was the world's first nationwide Green party founded, according to the article?
- India
- Zambia
- New Zealand
- Britain
Show answer
Answer: C. The article says the first nationwide Green party was founded in New Zealand in 1972.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.