Revision notes

Chapter 7 The Ailing Planet: the Green Movement’s Role: Foundation

The key points, rules to remember, tables and diagrams from all 5 lessons, on one page for quick revision. To keep a copy, use your browser's Print and choose "Save as PDF".

Lesson 1

The Ailing Planet: the article and its argument

How the article builds its case

  1. The Green Movement No movement has caught the world's imagination so fast; the first nationwide Green party was founded in New Zealand in 1972.
  2. A new world view We are moving from seeing the world as a machine to seeing it as a whole, living system, a change as great as Copernicus's discovery.
  3. A sick patient The Earth's vital signs show declining health; we must be good stewards for future generations; sustainable development is the way.
  4. Humans as the danger A zoo notice and a mirror make the point that man is the most dangerous animal, now learning partnership instead of domination.
  5. Damage to natural systems Fisheries, forests, grasslands and croplands are being over-used; forests are vanishing, in India too, despite the Constitution.
  6. Population Rapid population growth threatens development and keeps the poor poor; voluntary family planning is urgent.
  7. An Era of Responsibility Concern now reaches the survival of the planet itself; industry and every generation must act as caretakers.
The article's sequence of ideas, summarised in our words.
Facts as reported in the 1994 article.
PointAs the article gives it
First nationwide Green partyFounded in New Zealand in 1972
Sustainable developmentPopularised in 1987 by the World Commission on Environment and Development
Earth's four principal biological systems (Lester Brown)Fisheries, forests, grasslands and croplands
Constitutional dutyArticle 48A asks the State to protect and improve the environment and safeguard forests and wildlife
An early commission on these issuesThe Brandt Commission, with the Indian member L.K. Jha
Meanings explained in our own words.
ExpressionMeaning in context
a holistic and ecological viewseeing the world as one connected whole in which all living things depend on each other
sustainable developmentprogress that meets today's needs without using up what future generations will need
languishremain neglected, in a weak or forgotten state
ignominious darknessshameful obscurity; here, species that remain unknown and unnamed
inter aliaamong other things (Latin)
decimateddestroyed in large numbers
catastrophic depletiona disastrous using-up or loss
transcending concerna concern that rises above all others

The Earth is a patient, not a machine: diagnose its illness, accept responsibility, and treat it for the sake of those who come after us.

Key takeaways: the article (1994) argues that the Earth is ailing because of human over-use and population pressure, and that the Green Movement has brought a new, holistic view and an Era of Responsibility. Learn its order of ideas and key terms.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 2

Evidence and persuasion: the zoo, the four systems and population

The Earth's principal biological systems (as Lester Brown identifies them)

  • Fisheries
    • Over-fishing to meet the demand for protein
    • Fish stocks collapse
  • Forests
    • Cut for firewood and land
    • Tropical forests, a powerhouse of evolution, are shrinking
    • Species face extinction
  • Grasslands
    • Over-grazed and over-used
    • Turn into barren wasteland
  • Croplands
    • Over-used soil deteriorates
    • Burning dung for fuel robs fields of natural manure
TechniqueExample in the article (in our words)
Extended metaphorThe Earth as a patient whose vital signs show declining health
Quoting experts and leadersThe World Commission, the Brandt Report, Lester Brown, a World Resources Institute president, Margaret Thatcher
Striking anecdoteThe mirror in the cage at Lusaka zoo
Memorable sayingsWe have borrowed the earth from our children, not inherited it from our ancestors
Facts and figuresRates of forest loss and population growth (as of 1994)
Hopeful closeThe environmental problem as a passport to the future; an Era of Responsibility

We do not own the Earth; we hold it on a life tenancy, and must hand it on in good repair.

Key takeaways: the mirror shows that humans are the real danger. Over-use is degrading fisheries, forests, grasslands and croplands. Rapid population growth deepens poverty and pressure on nature. Palkhivala persuades through metaphor, expert quotations, anecdote and memorable sayings.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 3

Unseen passage practice: the lake that came back

From damage to recovery

  1. Awareness Students test the water.
  2. Action Letters, posters, clean-up.
  3. Stopping the source Drains diverted to treatment.
  4. Healing Native plants, patience.
  5. Recovery Birds, fish and people return.

Factual answers come from the lines; inference answers come from between them; summaries keep only the main ideas.

Key takeaways: the passage illustrates Palkhivala's idea of partnership with nature. Practise finding main ideas, inferring causes and condensing a passage into notes and a summary.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 4

Words: Latin phrases, connotations, and literal and figurative meanings

ExpressionMeaningOur own example
inter aliaamong other thingsThe report discussed, inter alia, water shortages.
prima facieat first sight; based on first impressionThere is prima facie evidence of negligence.
ad hocmade for a particular purpose onlyAn ad hoc committee was formed to plan the fair.
in camerain private, not in open courtThe case was heard in camera.
ad infinitumendlessly, for everHe could talk about cricket ad infinitum.
mutatis mutandiswith the necessary changes madeThe same rules apply, mutatis mutandis, to the junior team.
caveata warning or conditionThe offer comes with a caveat: tickets cannot be refunded.
tabula rasaa blank slate; a mind without ideas yetA newborn's mind was once thought to be a tabula rasa.
PhraseConnotation (the feeling or idea it suggests)
gripped the imagination ofcaptured attention powerfully and suddenly, like a firm hold
dawned upona realisation that came slowly and clearly, like daylight
ushered inintroduced or began a new period, as an usher leads people in
passed into current coinbecame widely used, like money in everyday circulation
passport to the futurea means of entry to a better future

Same word, two senses

  • Literal (our own sentences)
    • grip: Grip the rope tightly.
    • dawn: We set off at dawn.
    • usher: The usher showed us to our seats.
    • coin: He found a five-rupee coin.
    • passport: Keep your passport safe when travelling abroad.
  • Figurative (our own sentences)
    • grip: Fear gripped the village.
    • dawn: It dawned on me that I had forgotten the keys.
    • usher: The internet ushered in a new age.
    • coin: She coined a catchy slogan.
    • passport: Good education is a passport to success.

Literal: the word's basic, physical meaning. Figurative: an extended, imaginative meaning. Connotation: the feeling a word carries beyond its dictionary sense.

Key takeaways: Latin expressions such as inter alia, prima facie and ad hoc are common in formal English. Many words, like grip, dawn, usher, coin and passport, have both literal and figurative meanings, and good writers use the figurative sense for vivid effect.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 5

Writing: a letter to the editor and a poster

Parts of a formal letter

  1. Sender's address and date Top left (a made-up address in practice).
  2. Receiver's address The Editor, name of newspaper, city.
  3. Subject line Short and clear.
  4. Salutation Sir/Madam.
  5. Body Introduction, problem and effects, suggestions.
  6. Closing Yours faithfully, signature, name.
ParagraphPurpose in the model
1States the issue politely and why the writer is writing
2Describes the problem and its effects
3Gives practical suggestions
4Closes with hope for action

Letter to the editor: addresses, date, subject, Sir/Madam, problem, effects, suggestions, Yours faithfully. Poster: heading, slogan, image, points, issuer.

Key takeaways: a letter to the editor is formal, polite and organised into problem, effects and suggestions. A poster communicates quickly through a heading, slogan, image and a few action points.

Read the full lesson

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery