- Foundation
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
Humanist individuals, women's aspirations and the Reformation
Explain the humanist view of human beings, the position and aspirations of women, the northern humanists' critique of the Church, the Protestant Reformation and the Catholic Church's reform from within.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Describe the new concept of human beings, with views of Barbaro, Valla and Machiavelli.
- Compare the position of aristocratic and merchant women and describe women such as Cassandra Fedele and Isabella d'Este.
- Explain the causes and course of the Protestant Reformation and the Catholic response.
Humanism changed ideas about what a person is and how faith should be practised. This lesson looks at the new individual, the limits of that ideal for women, and the great debates within Christianity.
A new concept of human beings
A feature of humanist culture was a slackening of religion's control over life. Italians were drawn to riches, power and fame, yet this did not make them unbelievers. The Venetian humanist Francesco Barbaro (1390-1454) argued that making money could be a virtue. Lorenzo Valla (1406-1457), who believed studying history leads a person to strive for perfection, criticised in On Pleasure the Christian injunction against pleasure. There was also interest in good manners: speaking politely, dressing correctly and learning the skills of a cultured person.
Humanism also held that individuals could shape their lives by means other than power and money, and that human nature was many-sided - an idea that went against the three separate orders of feudal society. Niccolo Machiavelli, in The Prince (1513), observed that people are praised or blamed for many contrasting qualities, believed that all men are bad and that human desires are insatiable, and saw self-interest as the most powerful motive behind every action.
Two humanist views of human nature
-
Many-sided human nature
- Individuals can shape their own lives
- Not confined to one order of society
- Wealth, pleasure and manners can be virtues
-
Machiavelli's view (The Prince, 1513)
- People show many contrasting qualities
- Human desires are insatiable
- Self-interest is the strongest motive
The aspirations of women
The new ideal of individuality and citizenship excluded women. In aristocratic families, men dominated public life and family decisions, educating sons for business or public life and sometimes sending younger sons to the Church. Women's dowries were invested in family businesses, yet wives usually had no say in how husbands ran them. Marriages often strengthened business alliances; daughters without adequate dowries were sent to convents as nuns. Women were seen as keepers of the household.
In merchant families women's position was somewhat different: shopkeepers' wives often helped run the shop, merchants' and bankers' wives looked after the business when men were away, and a merchant's early death compelled his widow to take a larger public role. A few women were intellectually creative. The Venetian Cassandra Fedele (1465-1558) argued that every woman should pursue learning even though it offered women no reward; she was admired for her command of Greek and Latin and was asked to deliver speeches at the University of Padua. She was one of many Venetian women writers who criticised the republic's limited definition of freedom that favoured men. Isabella d'Este (1474-1539), Marchesa of Mantua, ruled the state in her husband's absence, and her court was famed for intellectual brilliance. Women's writings show a conviction that they needed economic power, property and education to achieve an identity. By contrast, the diplomat Balthasar Castiglione, in The Courtier (1528), wanted women to be graceful and unlike men in manner, while sharing virtues of the mind.
Women in Renaissance Italy
-
Aristocratic families
- Dowries invested in family business, without a say
- Marriages for business alliances
- Daughters without dowries sent to convents
-
Merchant families
- Wives helped run shops
- Managed business when men were away
- Widows took larger public roles
-
Women who spoke out
- Cassandra Fedele: learning for every woman
- Isabella d'Este ruled Mantua in her husband's absence
Debates within Christianity
Very few new ideas reached the ordinary person, who could not read. But in the fifteenth and early sixteenth centuries humanism attracted scholars in north Europe, where, unlike Italy, many members of the Church joined the movement. They called on Christians to practise religion as laid down in its ancient texts, discarding rituals they saw as later additions, and saw human beings as free and rational agents. Christian humanists such as Thomas More (1478-1535) in England and Erasmus (1466-1536) in Holland felt the Church had become greedy, extorting money from ordinary people - notably by selling 'indulgences', documents that supposedly freed the buyer from the burden of sins. Printed translations of the Bible in local languages showed Christians that their religion did not permit such practices.
Peasants across Europe rebelled against Church taxes, and princes resented the Church's interference in government. They welcomed the humanists' proof that the clergy's claim to judicial and fiscal powers rested on the 'Donation of Constantine', supposedly issued by the first Christian Roman emperor, which humanists showed was a later forgery. In 1517 the young German monk Martin Luther (1483-1546) launched a campaign against the Catholic Church, arguing that a person did not need priests to reach God and that faith alone could guide people to the right life and to heaven. This Protestant Reformation led churches in Germany and Switzerland to break with the Pope. In Switzerland, Ulrich Zwingli and later Jean Calvin popularised Luther's ideas. Backed by merchants, reformers appealed more in towns; the Catholic Church kept its influence in rural areas.
The Anabaptists were more radical: since God created all people equal, they said, people need not pay taxes and could choose their priests - an idea that appealed to peasants. Luther did not support radicalism and called on German rulers to crush the peasants' rebellion, which they did in 1525. Radicalism survived, merging with the resistance of French Protestants, who, persecuted by Catholic rulers, claimed the right of a people to remove an oppressive ruler. Eventually in France, as elsewhere, Protestants were allowed to worship as they chose. In England, rulers ended the connection with the Pope, and the king or queen became head of the Church (the Anglican Church, 1559 in the chapter's timeline). The Catholic Church also reformed from within: churchmen in Spain and Italy stressed simple living and service to the poor, and in 1540 Ignatius Loyola founded the Society of Jesus, whose members, the Jesuits, served the poor and studied other cultures.
From criticism to Reformation and response
- Christian humanists criticise More and Erasmus attack greed and the sale of indulgences.
- Bible in local languages Readers see that such practices are not in their religion.
- Luther, 1517 Faith alone; no need of priests to reach God.
- Protestant churches break with Rome Germany and Switzerland; Zwingli and Calvin.
- Catholic reform Simple living, service to the poor; Jesuits founded in 1540.
Worked example 1: how far did the new ideals reach women?
Question: did the Renaissance ideal of individuality include women? Build a balanced answer. Working: (1) the book states that the ideal of individuality and citizenship excluded women; (2) aristocratic women had no say over their own dowries and could be sent to convents; (3) merchant wives and widows had larger roles in business; (4) a few women, such as Cassandra Fedele and Isabella d'Este, achieved learning or rule and argued for women's education and property. Answer: largely no, but merchant-class women and a few exceptional women carved out wider roles and voiced new aspirations.
Worked example 2: who supported the Reformation, and why?
Question: explain why different groups supported or opposed the Reformation. Working: (1) ordinary people resented the Church's extortion and taxes; (2) princes disliked the Church's interference and welcomed proof that the Donation of Constantine was forged; (3) merchants backed the reformers, so they were strongest in towns; (4) in rural areas the Catholic Church kept its influence; (5) peasants were drawn to Anabaptist ideas of equality, but Luther opposed radicalism and their rising was crushed in 1525. Answer: support depended on each group's interests - money, power and social equality.
Protestant Reformation (from 1517): Luther taught that faith alone, not priests, connects a person to God. Churches in Germany and Switzerland broke with the Pope; the Catholic Church answered with reform from within, including the Jesuits (1540).
Key takeaways: humanists loosened religion's hold, praising wealth (Barbaro), pleasure (Valla), manners and a many-sided human nature; Machiavelli saw self-interest as the chief motive. The new ideals excluded most women, though merchant women and figures such as Cassandra Fedele and Isabella d'Este sought education, property and power. Northern Christian humanists such as More and Erasmus attacked indulgences; the Donation of Constantine was exposed as forged; Luther's campaign of 1517 began the Reformation, followed by Zwingli, Calvin and the radical Anabaptists, and a Catholic reform that produced the Jesuits.
Check your understanding
-
1. According to Machiavelli in The Prince (1513), the most powerful motive behind every human action is:
- faith
- self-interest
- love of the city
- fear of God
Show answer
Answer: B. Machiavelli believed human desires are insatiable and saw self-interest as the most powerful incentive for every human action.
-
2. Cassandra Fedele of Venice was known for:
- ruling Mantua
- founding the Jesuits
- her proficiency in Greek and Latin and her orations at the University of Padua
- writing The Courtier
Show answer
Answer: C. Cassandra Fedele was proficient in Greek and Latin, was invited to give orations at Padua, and argued that every woman should pursue humanist learning. Isabella d'Este ruled Mantua; Castiglione wrote The Courtier.
-
3. Humanist scholars showed that the 'Donation of Constantine' was:
- a genuine grant by the first Christian emperor
- a printed Bible
- a list of indulgences
- a later forgery
Show answer
Answer: D. The clergy's claim to judicial and fiscal powers rested on the 'Donation of Constantine'; humanist scholars pointed out it was not genuine and had been forged later.
-
4. Read this source, written for this lesson: 'Why pay the priest for a paper that forgives sins? Read the Gospel in our own tongue: nowhere does it sell forgiveness.' Which development does this reflect?
- Criticism of the sale of indulgences, aided by Bibles in local languages
- The founding of the Society of Jesus
- The Copernican revolution
- Machiavelli's theory of self-interest
Show answer
Answer: A. Christian humanists attacked the sale of indulgences, and printed translations of the Bible in local languages made Christians realise their religion did not permit such practices.
-
5. Assertion (A): Protestant reformers had greater popular appeal in towns than in the countryside. Reason (R): Merchants supported the reformers, whereas the Catholic Church kept its hold on the countryside.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is true, but R is false
- A is false, but R is true
Show answer
Answer: A. Both are true. Merchant support strengthened the reformers in towns, while the Catholic Church held on in rural areas. R explains A.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.