• Foundation
  • About 17 min
  • 5 practice questions

The Renaissance idea and the revival of Italian cities

Explain what historians mean by the Renaissance, how Burckhardt's approach differed from Ranke's, and why Italian city-states such as Venice and Florence revived and nurtured a sense of citizenship.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Summarise the cultural changes in Europe from the fourteenth to the seventeenth century and the sources for them.
  • Explain the term Renaissance and Burckhardt's view of a new 'humanist' culture.
  • Explain why Italian towns revived and how city-states such as Venice fostered citizenship.

From the fourteenth to the end of the seventeenth century, towns grew across Europe and a distinct urban culture developed. Townspeople thought themselves more 'civilised' than rural people. Florence, Venice and Rome became centres of art and learning, with artists and writers patronised by the rich. Printing made books available far and wide. A sense of history grew, as people contrasted their 'modern' world with the 'ancient' world of Greece and Rome. Religion came to be seen as an individual's choice, scientists overturned the Church's earth-centred view of the universe, and new geography overturned the idea that the Mediterranean was the centre of the world.

The sources are vast - documents, printed books, paintings, sculptures, buildings and textiles - many preserved in archives, galleries and museums in Europe and America.

The idea of the Renaissance

From the nineteenth century historians used 'Renaissance' (literally, rebirth) for the cultural changes of this period. The scholar who stressed it most was the Swiss historian Jacob Burckhardt (1818-97) of the University of Basle. His teacher, the German historian Leopold von Ranke (1795-1886), held that a historian should write mainly about states and politics, using government files. Burckhardt found this too narrow: for him history was as much about culture as politics. In 1860 he wrote The Civilisation of the Renaissance in Italy, drawing attention to literature, architecture and painting to show how a new 'humanist' culture had flowered in Italian towns from the fourteenth to the seventeenth century. Its central belief was that man, as an individual, could make his own decisions and develop his skills - 'modern' man, in contrast to 'medieval' man whose thinking the Church had controlled.

Two approaches to writing history

  • Ranke
    • States and politics are the historian's main concern
    • Use papers and files of government departments
  • Burckhardt
    • History is as much about culture as politics
    • Used literature, architecture and painting
    • Saw a new humanist culture in Italian towns

Renaissance (rebirth): the term historians use for the cultural changes in Europe from the fourteenth century. Burckhardt saw at its heart a humanist belief in the individual's ability to decide and to develop his own skills.

Why Italian cities revived

After the western Roman Empire fell, many Italian towns decayed. There was no single government for Italy, and the Pope, though ruler of his own state, carried little political weight. Elsewhere, feudal ties and the Latin Church were remaking western Europe, the Byzantine Empire held the east, and Islam was building a shared civilisation; Italy, by contrast, was divided and weak. Yet these very developments helped its revival. Expanding trade between the Byzantine Empire and the Islamic countries revived Italy's ports. From the twelfth century, as the Mongols opened trade with China via the Silk Route and trade with western Europe grew, Italian towns played a central role.

How Italian towns revived

  1. Fragmented Italy No unified government; a weak papacy.
  2. Byzantine-Islamic trade Italian coastal ports revive.
  3. Mongol Silk Route and western trade (from 12th century) Italian towns become central to commerce.
  4. Independent city-states Republics and court-cities run by merchants and princes.
  5. Citizenship and culture Pride in being citizens; patronage of art and learning.

The city-state and citizenship

Italian towns no longer saw themselves as parts of a powerful empire but as independent city-states. Florence and Venice were republics; many others were court-cities ruled by princes. Venice and Genoa were among the most vibrant. They differed from the rest of Europe: the clergy were not politically dominant, and there were no powerful feudal lords. Rich merchants and bankers took part in governing the city, which helped the idea of citizenship take root; even under military despots, townspeople's pride in being citizens did not weaken.

A sixteenth-century Venetian cardinal, Gasparo Contarini, described his city's government: authority lay with a council to which gentlemen over the age of 25 were admitted, while the common people were kept out; membership was decided by noble birth rather than wealth, but was not confined to a small circle of the highest nobility. This 'democratic' republic was thus open to the well-born, not to everyone.

The fourteenth and fifteenth centuries
YearEvent (from the chapter's timeline)
1300Humanism taught at Padua University
1341Petrarch given the title of Poet Laureate in Rome
1349University established in Florence
1453Ottoman Turks defeat the Byzantine ruler of Constantinople
1492Columbus reaches America
1495Leonardo da Vinci paints The Last Supper
1512Michelangelo paints the Sistine Chapel ceiling

Worked example 1: reading a description of government

Question: from Contarini's description of Venice, was Venetian government democratic in the modern sense? Working: (1) power lay in a council - not a single ruler, which looks republican; (2) only gentlemen over 25 were admitted; (3) the common people were deliberately excluded; (4) noble birth, not wealth, decided membership. Answer: no - it was a republic of the well-born, wider than rule by a few nobles but far from rule by all citizens. Calling it 'democratic' reflects the writer's pride rather than modern standards.

Worked example 2: why did citizenship take root in Italy?

Question: give two reasons from the chapter why the idea of citizenship took root in towns like Venice and Genoa. Working: (1) the clergy were not politically dominant and there were no powerful feudal lords, so the 'three orders' did not control the city; (2) rich merchants and bankers actively took part in government, so townspeople had a stake in public affairs. Answer: the absence of clerical and feudal domination, and the participation of merchants and bankers in governing the city.

Key takeaways: from the fourteenth century an urban culture, printing, a sense of history and new science changed European thought. Burckhardt, moving beyond Ranke's focus on politics, called this a Renaissance marked by humanist faith in the individual. Fragmented Italy revived through Byzantine-Islamic trade and the Mongol-opened Silk Route; its city-states, such as the republics of Florence and Venice, were governed by merchants and bankers rather than clergy or feudal lords, fostering pride in citizenship, though Venice's council was open only to the well-born.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Who wrote The Civilisation of the Renaissance in Italy (1860)?

    1. Leopold von Ranke
    2. Jacob Burckhardt
    3. Peter Burke
    4. Francesco Petrarch
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The Swiss historian Jacob Burckhardt wrote it in 1860, drawing attention to literature, architecture and painting to describe a new humanist culture in Italian towns.

  2. 2. Ranke taught that the historian's primary concern should be:

    1. art and literature
    2. the lives of peasants
    3. states and politics, using government papers
    4. science and technology
    Show answer

    Answer: C. For Ranke, a historian's main task was the history of states and politics, written from official government records; Burckhardt thought this far too narrow.

  3. 3. Which two Italian city-states does the chapter describe as republics?

    1. Florence and Venice
    2. Rome and Genoa
    3. Padua and Bologna
    4. Milan and Naples
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Florence and Venice were republics; many other Italian towns were court-cities ruled by princes.

  4. 4. Read this source, written for this lesson: 'In our city no bishop gives orders to the council, and no great lord owns our streets. The spice merchant and the banker sit together on the council, and every craftsman is proud to call himself a citizen.' Which feature of Italian city-states does it illustrate?

    1. Rule by powerful feudal lords
    2. Domination by the clergy
    3. Control by the Byzantine emperor
    4. Merchants and bankers governing, which helped citizenship take root
    Show answer

    Answer: D. In cities such as Venice and Genoa the clergy were not politically dominant and there were no powerful feudal lords; merchants and bankers took part in government, helping the idea of citizenship take root.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): Italian ports revived after a long decline. Reason (R): Trade expanded between the Byzantine Empire and the Islamic countries.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    3. A is true, but R is false
    4. A is false, but R is true
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Both are true. Growing commerce between the Byzantine Empire and the Islamic lands brought Italy's coastal ports back to life, the book explains. R explains A.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery