• Foundation
  • About 17 min
  • 5 practice questions

The Scientific Revolution and rethinking the Renaissance

Explain the Copernican revolution and the Scientific Revolution, how scientific societies spread a new culture, and how historians such as Peter Burke have questioned the idea of a sharp Renaissance break.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain the ideas of Copernicus, Kepler, Galileo and Newton and why they challenged Christian beliefs.
  • Explain what historians call the Scientific Revolution and how scientific societies spread it.
  • Evaluate the concept of the Renaissance, including Asian debts, the private and public spheres, and language-based identities.

The Christian idea of man as a sinner was questioned from another angle - by scientists. This lesson follows the change from an earth-centred to a sun-centred universe and then asks whether the 'Renaissance' was really the sharp break Burckhardt described.

The Copernican revolution

European science reached its turning point with Copernicus (1473-1543), who lived at the same time as Martin Luther. Christian teaching had pictured the earth as a place of sin, held motionless by sin's weight, at the centre of the universe, with the heavenly (celestial) bodies circling it. Copernicus argued instead that the earth and the other planets go round the sun. Being devout, he dreaded the response of conservative churchmen and kept his manuscript, De revolutionibus (The Rotation), from the printers; only when dying did he hand it to his disciple Joachim Rheticus.

Acceptance took time - more than half a century. The gap between 'heaven' and earth was bridged by astronomers such as Johannes Kepler (1571-1630) and Galileo Galilei (1564-1642). Kepler's Cosmographical Mystery popularised the sun-centred system and showed that planets move around the sun in ellipses, not circles. Galileo confirmed the idea of a dynamic world in The Motion. The revolution reached its climax with Isaac Newton's theory of gravitation.

Two pictures of the universe

  • Earlier Christian view
    • Earth at the centre of the universe
    • Earth immobile, weighed down by sin
    • Heavenly bodies move around the earth
  • Copernicus and his successors
    • Planets, including the earth, move around the sun
    • Orbits are ellipses (Kepler)
    • A dynamic world (Galileo); gravitation (Newton)

Steps of the Copernican revolution

  1. Copernicus Planets, including earth, rotate around the sun; De revolutionibus.
  2. Kepler Cosmographical Mystery: planets move in ellipses.
  3. Galileo The Motion: confirms a dynamic world.
  4. Newton Theory of gravitation: the climax of the revolution.

Reading the universe: the Scientific Revolution

Galileo remarked, in effect, that the Bible shows the way to heaven but says little about how the heavens work. These thinkers showed that knowledge, as distinct from belief, rests on observation and experiment. Research in the fields later named physics, chemistry and biology grew fast, and historians gave this new way of knowing the name Scientific Revolution. For sceptics and non-believers, Nature began to replace God as the source of creation; even believers spoke of a distant God who does not directly regulate life in the material world. Such ideas spread through scientific societies that created a public scientific culture: the Royal Society in London (formed in 1662) and the Paris Academy held lectures and conducted experiments for public viewing.

Scientific Revolution: the new approach to knowledge of man and nature based on observation and experiment rather than belief, which expanded physics, chemistry and biology.

The sixteenth and seventeenth centuries
YearEvent (from the chapter's timeline)
1516Thomas More's Utopia published
1517Martin Luther writes the Ninety-Five Theses
1543Andreas Vesalius writes On Anatomy
1569Gerhardus Mercator prepares a cylindrical map of the earth
1582Gregorian calendar introduced by Pope Gregory XIII
1628William Harvey links the heart with blood circulation
1687Isaac Newton's Principia Mathematica published

Was there a European 'Renaissance'?

The chapter asks us to reconsider the concept. Was this period a sharp break, a rebirth of Greek and Roman ideas? Were the twelfth and thirteenth centuries dark? Recent writers such as Peter Burke of England suggest that Burckhardt exaggerated the difference from the preceding period. The term implies that Greek and Roman civilisations were reborn and that scholars replaced the Christian world-view with a pre-Christian one - both claims were exaggerated: earlier scholars knew Greek and Roman cultures, and religion remained very important. Contrasting a dynamic Renaissance with a gloomy Middle Ages is an over-simplification; many 'Renaissance' elements can be traced to the twelfth and thirteenth centuries, and some historians see a similar blossoming in ninth-century France.

Nor were the changes shaped only by classical Greece and Rome. Asian techniques and skills had by then gone well beyond anything the Greeks and Romans had known. The expansion of Islam and the Mongol conquests linked Asia and North Africa with Europe through trade and learning. Europeans learnt from India, Arabia, Iran, Central Asia and China - debts long unacknowledged because the period's history was first written from a Europe-centred viewpoint.

Two important changes did occur. First, the 'private' and 'public' spheres began to separate: public meant government and formal religion; private meant family and personal religion. The individual was no longer just a member of one of the three orders but a person in his own right; an artist was known for himself, not just as a guild member. A century or so later, in the eighteenth century, this idea of the individual turned political: every person, it was argued, had equal political rights. Second, Europe's regions began to define themselves by language. A continent once held together partly by Rome, and later by Latin and Christianity, was breaking into states each bound by its own language.

Rethinking the Renaissance (as the chapter presents it)

  • Exaggerations corrected
    • Greek and Roman learning was known earlier
    • Religion stayed central to life
    • Many elements date from the 12th-13th centuries
  • Wider sources
    • Learning from India, Arabia, Iran, Central Asia, China
    • Links created by Islam and the Mongols
  • Real changes
    • Separation of private and public spheres
    • The individual as a person in his own right
    • Identities based on language

Worked example 1: why did Copernicus hesitate?

Question: explain why Copernicus did not want his manuscript printed in his lifetime. Working: (1) Christians believed the earth was sinful, immobile and at the centre of the universe; (2) his claim that the earth moved around the sun contradicted this teaching; (3) as a devout Christian he feared the reaction of traditionalist clergymen; (4) so he handed the manuscript to Rheticus only on his deathbed. Answer: his theory clashed with religious belief, and he feared the Church's response.

Worked example 2: how long did acceptance take?

Question: Copernicus died in 1543 and Newton's Principia was published in 1687. How long did it take from Copernicus's work to the climax of the revolution? Working: 1687 − 1543 = 144 years. Answer: about a century and a half - in line with the book's point that the sun-centred idea took a long time to be accepted, with Kepler and Galileo bridging heaven and earth more than half a century after Copernicus.

Key takeaways: Copernicus placed the sun at the centre, challenging the belief in a sinful, immobile, central earth; Kepler (ellipses), Galileo (a dynamic world) and Newton (gravitation) completed the revolution. Knowledge came to rest on observation and experiment - the Scientific Revolution - spread by societies such as the Royal Society (1662). Historians such as Peter Burke argue that Burckhardt exaggerated the Renaissance break; much began earlier, and Europe learnt from Asia too. Real changes included the separation of private and public spheres, the rise of the individual and language-based identities.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Who showed that planets move around the sun in ellipses rather than circles?

    1. Copernicus
    2. Galileo
    3. Johannes Kepler
    4. Isaac Newton
    Show answer

    Answer: C. In his Cosmographical Mystery, Kepler showed that planetary paths round the sun are ellipses, not circles.

  2. 2. Why did Copernicus not want De revolutionibus printed during his life?

    1. He was not sure of his calculations
    2. As a devout Christian he feared the reaction of traditionalist clergymen
    3. Printing had not yet been invented
    4. The Pope had already banned it
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Copernicus, a devout Christian, feared the possible reaction to his theory by traditionalist clergymen, so he gave the manuscript to Rheticus on his deathbed.

  3. 3. Which historian suggested that Burckhardt exaggerated the difference between the Renaissance and the preceding period?

    1. Peter Burke
    2. Leopold von Ranke
    3. Marc Bloch
    4. Erasmus
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Recent writers such as Peter Burke of England have suggested that Burckhardt exaggerated the sharp difference between this period and the one before it.

  4. 4. Read this source, written for this lesson: 'Do not tell me what the old books say about falling bodies. Bring two balls to the tower, drop them, and let us watch.' Which idea of the Scientific Revolution does this express?

    1. Knowledge comes from the authority of ancient texts
    2. The earth is the centre of the universe
    3. Nature should not be studied
    4. Knowledge, as distinct from belief, rests on observation and experiment
    Show answer

    Answer: D. These scientists showed that knowledge, unlike belief, must rest on observing and experimenting - the change historians call the Scientific Revolution.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): The debt of Renaissance Europe to Asia was not acknowledged for a long time. Reason (R): When the history of this period began to be written, historians saw it from a Europe-centred viewpoint.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    3. A is true, but R is false
    4. A is false, but R is true
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Both are true. Europeans learnt from India, Arabia, Iran, Central Asia and China, but historians writing from a Europe-centred viewpoint long ignored these debts. R explains A.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery