- Foundation
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
China after 1949, Taiwan, Korea and two roads to modernity
Describe China's changes from the New Democracy to the reforms after 1978, the stories of Taiwan and Korea as the chapter tells them, the book's comparison of the paths of Japan and China, and the book's concluding ideas on world history.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Describe the phases of the People's Republic: New Democracy, the Great Leap Forward, the Cultural Revolution and the reforms from 1978.
- Summarise, as the chapter presents them, the paths of Taiwan and South Korea to development and democracy.
- Compare the Japanese and Chinese paths to modernisation and explain the book's ideas on writing world history.
The last part of the chapter follows China after 1949, adds the stories of Taiwan and Korea, and compares the 'two roads to modernisation'. The book's Conclusion then looks back over all the themes. This lesson keeps to the book's account and attributes its evaluations to it.
The People's Republic, 1949-78
Set up in 1949, the People's Republic of China was founded on the idea of the 'New Democracy' - a coalition of every social class, in contrast to the Soviet Union's claimed 'dictatorship of the proletariat'. Key sectors came under government control, and private enterprise and private land ownership were gradually ended. In 1953 the government announced a programme of socialist transformation. The Great Leap Forward (1958) tried to industrialise the country at speed: people built steel furnaces in their backyards, and villages were merged into people's communes that owned and farmed land together. The book says that in 1958 there were 26,000 communes, taking in 98 per cent of farming families. Mao's ideal was a 'socialist man' devoted to the fatherland, the people, labour, science and public property, and mass organisations enrolled farmers, women and students. Some leaders, including Liu Shaochi and Deng Xiaoping, tried to modify the commune system, which was not working efficiently; the backyard steel was unusable industrially.
The conflict between Maoists, who stressed ideology, and those who stressed expertise culminated in the Great Proletarian Cultural Revolution launched by Mao in 1965. The Red Guards - mainly students, and the army - campaigned against old culture, customs and habits; students and professionals were sent to the countryside; ideology mattered more than professional knowledge, and slogans replaced rational debate. The book says it weakened the Party and severely disrupted the economy and education. From the late 1960s the tide turned, and in 1975 the Party again stressed discipline and building an industrial economy.
Reforms from 1978
Deng Xiaoping combined a firm grip by the Party with a socialist market economy. In 1978 the Party made the Four Modernisations - of science, industry, agriculture and defence - its aim, and permitted debate on condition that the Party itself was not challenged. A wall-poster of 5 December 1978, 'The Fifth Modernisation', argued that without democracy the others would come to nothing; such demands were suppressed. In 1989, on the seventieth anniversary of the May Fourth movement, intellectuals called for greater openness, and the book records that student demonstrators at Tiananmen Square were brutally repressed, which was strongly condemned around the world. The book describes the post-reform debates: the Party's view of strong political control with economic liberalisation and integration into the world market; critics who point to growing inequalities between groups, regions, and men and women; and a revival of 'traditional' ideas such as Confucianism.
| Phase | Years (from the chapter) | Main features |
|---|---|---|
| New Democracy | 1949-53 | Alliance of classes; key sectors under state control |
| Socialist transformation; Great Leap Forward | 1953; 1958 | Backyard furnaces; 26,000 communes covering 98 per cent of farm population |
| Cultural Revolution | From 1965 | Red Guards; ideology over expertise; economy and education disrupted |
| Reforms | From 1978 | Four Modernisations; socialist market economy under Party control |
Taiwan and Korea, as the chapter tells them
Taiwan. Defeated by the CCP, Chiang Kai-shek fled to Taiwan in 1949 and established the Republic of China there. Taiwan had been a Japanese colony after China ceded it following the 1894-95 war. The book says the Guomindang government was repressive - forbidding free speech and opposition and, after massive demonstrations in February 1947, killing many leading figures - but carried out land reforms and modernised the economy, so that by 1973 Taiwan's GNP was second only to Japan's in Asia, while the gap between rich and poor declined. Democratisation began slowly after Chiang's death in 1975 and gathered pace when martial law was lifted in 1987 and opposition parties were permitted. The book notes that most countries keep only trade missions there and that the question of reunification with the mainland remains contentious.
Korea. In the late nineteenth century Korea's Joseon dynasty (1392-1910) attempted modernising reforms amid internal strife and foreign pressure; Japan annexed Korea in 1910. Koreans resisted suppression of their culture, and Japanese rule ended in August 1945 after 35 years. The peninsula was divided along the 38th parallel, and separate governments were set up in 1948. The Korean War (1950-53) ended in an armistice with Korea still divided, and South Korea depended on US aid. After the April Revolution of 1960, a military coup in 1961 brought General Park Chung-hee to power; elected president in 1963, he pursued state-led, export-oriented growth through five-year plans, moving from light industries such as textiles to heavy and chemical industries, and launched the New Village (Saemaul) Movement in 1970 to modernise agriculture. The book credits growth to strong leaders, trained bureaucrats, industrialists and a literate labour force, while noting that under the Yusin Constitution (1972) democracy was suspended. Democracy movements - Gwangju (1980) and the June Democracy Movement (1987) - won direct presidential elections; a civilian president was elected in 1992; South Korea faced a foreign currency crisis in 1997, met with IMF support and citizens' Gold Collection Movement; and the same year saw the first peaceful transfer of power to an opposition leader. The book presents the peaceful candlelight protests of 2016 as a sign of democratic maturity.
South Korea's path, as the chapter outlines it
- 1945-53 Liberation, division at the 38th parallel, Korean War.
- 1961-79 Military-led, export-oriented industrialisation; Saemaul Movement; Yusin Constitution.
- 1980-87 Gwangju and June Democracy Movements; direct elections won.
- 1990s Civilian president (1992); currency crisis and IMF support (1997).
- 1997 onwards Peaceful transfers of power between parties.
Two roads to modernisation
The book concludes that industrial societies, far from becoming alike, found their own paths to being modern. Japan stayed independent and found new uses for old skills and practices; yet, the book argues, change led from the top bred aggressive nationalism, a regime that crushed dissent, and an empire whose memory left bitterness across the region. Change was not just reviving or preserving tradition but creatively using it - the Meiji schools taught new subjects but aimed to make loyal citizens. China's path was very different: foreign imperialism and a hesitant Qing dynasty led to a breakdown of order and immense misery from warlordism, banditry, civil war, the Japanese invasion and natural disasters. The CCP rejected tradition as keeping the masses poor and women subjugated; it built a highly centralised state and, the book says, while its repressive system turned ideals into slogans, it removed old inequalities, spread education and raised consciousness. Market reforms made China economically powerful under tight political control, raising the question of how China can develop while retaining its heritage.
Two roads to modernisation (the book's assessment)
-
Japan
- Kept independence; used tradition creatively
- Elite-driven modernisation
- Aggressive nationalism and empire
- Repression of dissent before 1945
-
China
- Imperialism and a weak Qing caused breakdown
- Rejection of tradition; revolution by the CCP
- Centralised, repressive state, but old inequalities removed
- Market reforms under tight political control
The book's conclusion: how world history is written
The Conclusion recalls the four sections and their 'increasingly foreshortened' periods: I, c. 6 million years ago to 400 BCE; II, 400 BCE to 1300 CE; III, 800 to 1700 CE; IV, 1700 to 2000 CE. It used the case-study method - examining key examples in detail instead of covering everything. It names three ways of writing world history: focusing on contacts between peoples and the interconnectedness of cultures; identifying regions of economic exchange that sustained forms of culture and power; and stressing differences between nations and regions. Differences go hand in hand with similarities, and the interplay of global and local, mainstream and marginal, is part of history's fascination. Historians build history from primary sources, evaluate them critically, and may draw very different arguments from the same material. The book ends with Marc Bloch's reminder of a child asking what history is for.
Three ways of writing world history (from the book's conclusion): through contacts and connections between peoples; through regions of economic exchange that sustain culture and power; and through the differences between nations and regions.
Worked example 1: the communes in numbers
Question: by 1958 there were 26,000 people's communes covering 98 per cent of China's farm population. If (an illustrative assumption) the farm population had been 500 million, roughly how many people would an average commune hold? Working: people in communes = 0.98 × 500,000,000 = 490,000,000; per commune = 490,000,000 ÷ 26,000 ≈ 18,846. Answer: roughly 19,000 people per commune under this assumption - showing how large these collective units were. (The 500 million figure is invented for practice; only the 26,000 and 98 per cent come from the book.)
Worked example 2: did economic growth help democracy in South Korea?
Question: use the chapter to build an answer. Working: (1) growth under Park came with suspended democracy (Yusin Constitution), so growth alone did not bring democracy; (2) but the book says growth led to urbanisation, more education and better media, which raised citizens' awareness of political rights; (3) this awareness fed the 1987 June Democracy Movement, which won direct elections; (4) the book adds that citizens' political awareness, not the economy alone, played the lead role. Answer: growth helped create the conditions, but citizens' own struggles achieved democracy.
Key takeaways: the People's Republic moved from the New Democracy (1949) through the Great Leap Forward (1958) and the Cultural Revolution (from 1965) to Deng Xiaoping's reforms and the Four Modernisations (1978), with demands for democracy suppressed, as in 1989. Taiwan, under Guomindang rule, combined repression with land reform and growth, democratising after 1987. South Korea, divided after 1945, grew fast under military-led export policies and won democracy through citizens' movements. The book sees Japan and China as two distinct roads to modernity, and closes by reflecting on how world history can be written.
Check your understanding
-
1. The Four Modernisations announced by the Chinese Communist Party in 1978 were in:
- science, industry, agriculture and defence
- democracy, science, industry and trade
- education, health, housing and transport
- steel, coal, oil and electricity
Show answer
Answer: A. The Party's 1978 goal, the Four Modernisations, covered science, industry, agriculture and defence. A wall-poster called democracy the 'Fifth Modernisation'.
-
2. What happened to the steel produced in the backyard furnaces of the Great Leap Forward, according to the chapter?
- It was exported to Japan
- It was unusable industrially
- It built the Shinkansen
- It doubled China's output of weapons
Show answer
Answer: B. Liu Shaochi and Deng Xiaoping tried to modify the commune system because it was not working efficiently; the steel produced in backyard furnaces was unusable industrially.
-
3. According to the chapter, which movement was introduced in South Korea in 1970 to mobilise the rural population and modernise agriculture?
- The June Democracy Movement
- The Gold Collection Movement
- The New Village (Saemaul) Movement
- The May Fourth Movement
Show answer
Answer: C. Launched in 1970, the New Village (Saemaul) Movement set out to rouse villagers to improve their own communities and to modernise farming.
-
4. Read this statement, written for this lesson: 'Some historians stress how civilisations touched and borrowed from one another; others trace great zones of trade; still others highlight what made each nation distinct.' Which part of the book does this summarise?
- The Section IV introduction on nationalism
- Naito Konan's view of China
- The Meiji school curriculum
- The Conclusion's three ways of writing world history
Show answer
Answer: D. The book's Conclusion describes three approaches to world history: contacts and interconnections, regions of economic exchange, and differences between nations and regions.
-
5. Assertion (A): The Cultural Revolution severely disrupted China's economy and educational system. Reason (R): During it, ideology was valued more than professional knowledge, and students and professionals were sent to the countryside.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is true, but R is false
- A is false, but R is true
Show answer
Answer: A. Both are true. Placing ideology above expertise and sending students and professionals to the countryside is why, as the book says, the Cultural Revolution disrupted the economy and education. R explains A.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.