• Foundation
  • About 18 min
  • 5 practice questions

Japan: nationalism, westernisation, daily life and recovery

Explain the rise of aggressive nationalism, the debate between westernisation and tradition, changes in daily life, the 'Overcoming Modernity' debate, and Japan's post-war reforms and recovery.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain how the Meiji constitution and military privileges fed aggressive nationalism.
  • Compare the views of Fukuzawa Yukichi, Miyake Setsurei and Ueki Emori, and describe changes in daily life.
  • Describe the reforms of the US-led Occupation and explain why Japan's recovery was more than a 'miracle'.

Japan's modernisation produced both a vibrant modern society and an aggressive nationalism that led to war. This lesson traces that double story to Japan's defeat and its re-emergence as an economic power.

Aggressive nationalism

The Meiji constitution rested on a restricted franchise and created a Diet (a German word for parliament, reflecting German legal influence) with limited powers. The leaders of the restoration kept power and even founded parties. Between 1918 and 1931 popularly elected prime ministers formed cabinets; after that they lost power to national unity cabinets. Because the emperor was supreme commander, from 1890 the army and navy were treated as answerable to no one else; and in 1899 a prime minister ruled that the service ministers had to be active generals and admirals. Behind the military's growing strength and the expanding empire lay a fear that the Western powers could crush Japan, and this fear was used to quieten critics of military expansion and of the taxes that paid for it.

How military power grew in Japan (as the chapter describes)

  1. Meiji constitution Restricted franchise; a Diet with limited powers.
  2. From 1890 Emperor's command read as giving army and navy independent control.
  3. 1899 Only serving generals and admirals may be ministers.
  4. Fear of the West Used to silence critics of expansion and military taxes.
  5. 1930s-1940s Wars in China and Asia; Pacific War after Pearl Harbor.

Westernisation or tradition?

Japanese intellectuals disagreed about relations with other countries. Fukuzawa Yukichi (1835-1901), a leading Meiji intellectual from a poor samurai family, saw the USA and western Europe as the height of civilisation and said Japan must 'expel Asia' - shed its 'Asian' characteristics and become part of the West. He went to the USA as a translator with the first Japanese embassy in 1860, wrote popular books on the West in the spoken style, founded the school that became Keio University, and in The Encouragement to Learning (1872-76) urged not just modern factories but the spirit of civilisation to build a new citizen, holding that heaven did not create some people above others.

The next generation questioned this total acceptance. The philosopher Miyake Setsurei (1860-1945) held that every nation should cultivate its own particular gifts for the benefit of world civilisation - so serving one's country was also serving the world. Many others were drawn to Western liberalism and wanted a Japan based on democracy rather than the military. Ueki Emori (1857-1892), a leader of the Popular Rights Movement, demanded constitutional government, admired the French Revolution's ideas of natural rights and popular sovereignty, and held that freedom was more precious than order; some even advocated votes for women. This pressure led the government to announce a constitution.

Japanese intellectuals on the West

  • Fukuzawa Yukichi
    • Japan must 'expel Asia'
    • Adopt the West's spirit of civilisation
    • Founded the school that became Keio University
  • Miyake Setsurei
    • Build national pride on indigenous values
    • Each nation should develop its own talents for world civilisation
  • Ueki Emori
    • Popular Rights Movement leader
    • Natural rights and popular sovereignty
    • Freedom more precious than order

Daily life

The patriarchal household of many generations under one head gave way, as people became affluent, to the nuclear family - the new 'homu' (from the English 'home') of husband as breadwinner and wife as homemaker - which created demand for new domestic goods, entertainment and housing. In the 1920s construction companies offered cheap housing for a down payment of 200 yen and 12 yen a month for ten years, when a bank employee earned 40 yen a month. The 'moga' ('modern girl') symbolised gender equality, cosmopolitan culture and a developed economy. Cities gained electric trams, public parks (from 1878) and department stores; Tokyo's Ginza became fashionable; radio stations opened in 1925; films were made from 1899; and the actress Matsui Sumako became a star playing Nora in Ibsen's A Doll's House. The book calls this a period of great vitality and questioning of traditional norms.

'Overcoming Modernity' and war

Nationalism centred on the state peaked in the 1930s and 1940s, when Japan fought to enlarge its empire in China and elsewhere in Asia; with the attack on the USA at Pearl Harbor, this became part of the Second World War. Society was controlled more tightly, dissidents were repressed and imprisoned, and patriotic societies, many of them women's organisations, supported the war. A 1943 symposium on 'Overcoming Modernity' debated how to combat the West while being modern. The musician Moroi Saburo asked how music could be restored as an art of the spirit; the philosopher Nishitani Keiji defined 'modern' as the unity of three Western streams - the Renaissance, the Protestant Reformation and the rise of natural sciences - and argued that Japan's 'moral energy' had saved it from colonisation and gave it a duty to build a new order, a Greater East Asia.

After defeat: re-emerging as an economic power

Japan's attempt at empire ended in defeat by the Allied forces. The book notes that some argue the nuclear bombs on Hiroshima and Nagasaki were dropped to shorten the war, while others think the immense destruction and suffering were unnecessary. Under the US-led Occupation (1945-47 in the text; the chapter's timeline gives 1946-52), Japan was demilitarised and given a new constitution with Article 9, the 'no war clause' renouncing war as an instrument of state policy. Agrarian reform, revived trade unions and an attempt to dismantle the zaibatsu followed; parties were revived, and in the first post-war elections in 1946 women voted for the first time.

The rapid rebuilding was called a post-war 'miracle', but the book argues it was rooted in Japan's history: a tradition of popular struggles and debate about political participation, strong social cohesion allowing close cooperation of government, bureaucracy and industry, plus US support and demand from the Korean and Vietnamese wars. The 1964 Tokyo Olympics marked a symbolic coming of age, and the Shinkansen bullet trains, started in 1964, came to represent Japanese technology. The 1960s saw civil society movements against industrialisation pushed without regard for health and environment: cadmium poisoning, mercury poisoning at Minamata in the 1960s and air pollution in the early 1970s led grass-roots groups to demand recognition and compensation; government action and new regulations improved conditions.

Post-war reforms in Japan
Reform under the OccupationWhat it did
DemilitarisationJapan's armed forces dismantled
New constitution, Article 9Renounced war as an instrument of state policy
Agrarian reform and trade unionsLand reform; unions re-established
Attack on the zaibatsuAttempt to dismantle large family-controlled monopolies
1946 electionsPolitical parties revived; women voted for the first time

Worked example 1: the cost of a 1920s home

Question: a 1920s house cost a down payment of 200 yen plus 12 yen a month for ten years. A bank employee earned 40 yen a month. Find the total cost and the share of monthly salary taken by the instalment. Working: instalments = 12 × 12 months × 10 years = 1,440 yen; total = 1,440 + 200 = 1,640 yen. Monthly share = (12 ÷ 40) × 100 = 30 per cent. Answer: 1,640 yen in all, with instalments taking 30 per cent of a bank employee's monthly salary - affordable for the new middle class, which helps explain the spread of the nuclear-family 'homu'.

Worked example 2: why was the recovery more than a 'miracle'?

Question: list the reasons the book gives for Japan's rapid post-war rebuilding. Working: (1) a long tradition of popular struggles and engagement with political participation; (2) social cohesion carried over from before the war, allowing close cooperation of government, bureaucracy and industry; (3) US support; (4) demand created by the Korean and Vietnamese wars. Answer: historical roots plus favourable outside conditions, not a sudden miracle - linking to the Section IV introduction's point that earlier gains, such as universal schooling by 1910, mattered.

Article 9 of Japan's post-war constitution, the 'no war clause', renounced war as an instrument of state policy. The recovery that followed rested on earlier gains, social cohesion, US support and wartime demand.

Key takeaways: a restricted constitution, independent army and navy (from 1890) and serving officers as ministers (1899) let the military dominate, justified by fear of the West. Fukuzawa Yukichi urged Japan to 'expel Asia'; Miyake Setsurei stressed national values; Ueki Emori demanded liberal democracy. Daily life changed with the nuclear family, affordable homes, the 'moga', radio and cinema. The 1943 'Overcoming Modernity' symposium debated being modern while fighting the West. After defeat, the Occupation demilitarised Japan, added Article 9 and gave women the vote (1946); recovery built on earlier foundations, while pollution provoked citizens' movements.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which Meiji intellectual said Japan must 'expel Asia'?

    1. Ueki Emori
    2. Miyake Setsurei
    3. Fukuzawa Yukichi
    4. Nishitani Keiji
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Fukuzawa Yukichi said Japan must 'expel Asia', meaning it should shed its 'Asian' characteristics and become part of the West.

  2. 2. Article 9 of Japan's post-war constitution is known as the:

    1. 'no war clause' renouncing war as an instrument of state policy
    2. clause giving women the vote
    3. clause creating the zaibatsu
    4. clause making the emperor commander of the forces
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Under the US-led Occupation, a new constitution introduced Article 9, the 'no war clause', by which Japan gave up war as a means of state policy.

  3. 3. In 1899, the Japanese prime minister ordered that:

    1. women could vote
    2. the Diet would control the army
    3. the zaibatsu would be dissolved
    4. only serving generals and admirals could become ministers
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The 1899 rule that service ministers must be active generals and admirals gave the military a stronger hold on government.

  4. 4. Read this source, written for this lesson: 'I do not want our nation to copy every Western fashion. Let us grow what is best in our own people, for the world is enriched when each country offers its own gifts.' Whose view does this resemble?

    1. Fukuzawa Yukichi
    2. Miyake Setsurei
    3. Commodore Perry
    4. Tanaka Shozo
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Miyake Setsurei wanted each nation to cultivate its own gifts for the good of world civilisation, and questioned wholesale acceptance of Western ideas.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): Japan's post-war economic recovery was more than a 'miracle'. Reason (R): It was rooted in Japan's history, including traditions of popular struggle, social cohesion and earlier development, and was helped by US support and wartime demand.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    3. A is true, but R is false
    4. A is false, but R is true
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Both are true; these are exactly the reasons the book gives for calling the recovery more than a miracle. R explains A.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery