• Foundation
  • About 18 min
  • 5 practice questions

East Asia: sources, geography and Tokugawa Japan

Contrast the paths of China and Japan in outline, describe the historical traditions and sources for East Asia, the geography of the two countries, and the political system, economy and culture of Tokugawa Japan.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Outline the contrasting paths of China and Japan in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries and the sources historians use for them.
  • Describe the physical and social contrasts between China and Japan.
  • Explain how Tokugawa Japan was governed and why its towns, commerce and culture grew.

At the start of the nineteenth century East Asia was dominated by China, ruled by the Qing dynasty, while Japan seemed locked in isolation. Within a few decades China was in turmoil, unable to meet the colonial challenge; its government lost control and civil war followed. Japan, on the other hand, built a modern nation-state, an industrial economy and even a colonial empire, taking Taiwan (1895) and Korea (1910); it defeated China in 1894 and Russia in 1905. China, after long struggles, found in revolution a way to remove inequalities and rebuild; the Chinese Communist Party won the civil war in 1949, and from the end of the 1970s its leaders introduced market reforms while keeping political control. Japan's drive for empire ended in defeat; under the US Occupation it became more democratic and by the 1970s was a major economic power.

Two paths in outline (as the chapter introduces them)

  • Japan
    • Built a modern nation-state and industrial economy
    • Took Taiwan (1895) and Korea (1910)
    • Defeated China (1894) and Russia (1905)
    • Defeat in war; rebuilt as an economic power
  • China
    • Qing dynasty unable to meet the colonial challenge
    • Turmoil and civil war
    • Revolution: CCP victorious in 1949
    • Market reforms from the late 1970s under Party control

Writing the history of China and Japan

History-writing has deep roots in both countries. The past was a guide for rulers and the yardstick by which they would be measured, so governments kept official record offices and compiled histories of each dynasty. Early China's finest historian is held to be Sima Qian (145-90 BCE). Japan, influenced by China, valued history just as highly: in 1869, almost as soon as it took power, the Meiji government created an office to gather records and produce what was really the winners' account of the Restoration. Respect for the written word means a wide range of materials survives - official histories, scholarship, popular literature, religious tracts - and printing and publishing were important pre-modern industries.

Modern scholarship builds on Chinese and Japanese intellectuals such as Liang Qichao and Kume Kunitake (1839-1931), a pioneer of modern history in Japan; on European travellers such as Marco Polo (in China from 1274 to 1290) and the Jesuits Matteo Ricci in China and Luis Frois in Japan; and on nineteenth-century missionaries. English scholarship includes Joseph Needham's work on science in Chinese civilisation and George Sansom's on Japan, and many Chinese and Japanese scholars' writings are now translated. The Japanese scholar Naito Konan (1866-1934), who helped set up the Department of Oriental Studies at Kyoto University in 1907, argued that republican government could end the aristocratic, centralised power that had existed in China since the Sung dynasty, but the book notes he underestimated Chinese nationalism.

Two contrasting lands

China is a vast continental country spanning many climatic zones, its core dominated by three river systems: the Yellow River (Huang He), the Yangtse (Chang Jiang) and the Pearl River; much of it is mountainous. The dominant ethnic group is the Han, and the main language is Chinese (Putonghua), but there are other nationalities such as the Uighur, Hui, Manchu and Tibetan, dialects such as Cantonese and Shanghainese, and other minority languages. Its food shows regional variety - Cantonese cuisine in the south, wheat in the north, fiery Szechuan food, rice and wheat in the east. Japan is a chain of islands; Honshu, Kyushu, Shikoku and Hokkaido are the biggest. More than half of the main islands' land is mountainous and Japan lies in a very active earthquake zone, which has influenced its architecture. The population is largely Japanese, with a small Ainu minority and Koreans brought as forced labour during colonial rule. Rearing animals has never been a Japanese tradition: the Japanese live mainly on rice, with fish as their chief source of protein.

Tokugawa Japan: the political system

An emperor ruled from Kyoto, but by the twelfth century the court had lost power to shoguns, who ruled in the emperor's name. From 1603 to 1867 members of the Tokugawa family were shoguns. The country was divided into over 250 domains under lords called daimyo. To keep the daimyo from becoming dangerous, the shogun required them to spend long periods in his capital, Edo (today's Tokyo); he also kept the main cities and mines in his own hands. The samurai warriors formed the governing elite, in the service of the shogun and the daimyo.

Power in Tokugawa Japan

  • Emperor (Kyoto) Formally the ruler, but with little political power.
  • Shogun (Tokugawa family, 1603-1867) Ruled in the emperor's name; controlled the daimyo, major cities and mines.
  • Daimyo Lords of over 250 domains, made to stay in Edo for long periods.
  • Samurai The warrior class and ruling elite, serving shogun and daimyo.

Three changes in the late sixteenth century laid the pattern for later development. First, the peasantry was disarmed: only samurai could carry swords, ending the frequent wars of the previous century. Second, each daimyo had to reside in his own domain's capital, where he enjoyed wide freedom of action. Third, land surveys identified owners and taxpayers and graded productivity to secure a stable revenue base.

Towns, commerce and culture

These domain capitals expanded. By the middle of the seventeenth century Edo had become the world's most populous city; Osaka and Kyoto were also large, and six or more castle-towns had over 50,000 inhabitants. A typical European country then had just one big city. A commercial economy grew, with financial and credit systems; merit began to count for more than status. Merchants paid for theatre and art; reading became so common that talented authors could support themselves by their pens; and in Edo borrowing a book cost about as much as a bowl of noodles (books were printed from wood blocks). Japan imported luxuries such as silk from China and textiles from India; paying in gold and silver strained the economy, so the Tokugawa restricted exports of precious metals and developed the silk industry at Nishijin in Kyoto, whose silk became known as the best in the world. Money use grew, and a stock market in rice was created. The study of ancient Japanese literature led people to look for the essence of being Japanese before contact with China, in classics such as the Tale of the Genji, written by Murasaki Shikibu in the Japanese script, and in myths that the emperor descended from the Sun Goddess.

Worked example 1: why disarm the peasants?

Question: explain how the three late-sixteenth-century changes helped later development. Working: (1) disarming peasants and restricting swords to samurai ended frequent wars and gave peace and order; (2) placing daimyo in their domain capitals made those capitals grow into towns, encouraging commerce; (3) land surveys created a stable revenue base for government. Answer: peace, urban growth and secure revenue - conditions that later helped Japan modernise rapidly.

Worked example 2: comparing urbanisation

Question: what does the book's comparison of Japanese and European cities in the mid-seventeenth century suggest? Working: Japan had Edo (the world's most populated city), Osaka, Kyoto and at least six castle-towns over 50,000 - at least nine large urban centres - while most European countries had only one large city. Many towns mean many markets, merchants, credit systems and readers. Answer: Japan was already highly urbanised and commercial before Western contact, which challenges the idea of a 'backward' Japan waiting to be modernised.

Tokugawa Japan (1603-1867): shogun over more than 250 daimyo domains, samurai as the elite, disarmed peasants, land surveys, and large cities - Edo, Osaka, Kyoto - that fostered commerce, credit, printing and the arts.

Key takeaways: China, dominant in 1800, fell into turmoil, while Japan built a modern state, industry and an empire; China later chose revolution (1949) and then market reform. Both countries have rich historical traditions, from Sima Qian to the Meiji history bureau, and wide sources. China is a vast continental land of great rivers and many peoples; Japan is a mountainous, earthquake-prone chain of islands. Under the Tokugawa shoguns (1603-1867), disarmament, daimyo capitals and land surveys brought peace and revenue; big cities, commerce, printing, Nishijin silk and a rice stock market show a developing economy.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which family held the position of shogun in Japan from 1603 to 1867?

    1. Meiji
    2. Tokugawa
    3. Qing
    4. Sung
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The Tokugawa family supplied every shogun between 1603 and 1867; Qing and Sung were dynasties of China.

  2. 2. Who is considered the greatest historian of early China?

    1. Sima Qian
    2. Liang Qichao
    3. Naito Konan
    4. Kume Kunitake
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Sima Qian (145-90 BCE) is regarded as early China's finest historian; Kume Kunitake helped found modern historical writing in Japan.

  3. 3. By the mid-seventeenth century, which city was the most populated in the world, according to the chapter?

    1. Kyoto
    2. Osaka
    3. Beijing
    4. Edo
    Show answer

    Answer: D. As the daimyo's capitals grew, Japan had by the mid-seventeenth century the most populated city in the world, Edo, besides Osaka and Kyoto.

  4. 4. Read this source, written for this lesson: 'Our silk weavers' quarter now supplies the finest cloth in the land, and the merchants no longer need to send our gold and silver abroad to buy Chinese silk.' Which Tokugawa policy does it reflect?

    1. Disarming the peasantry
    2. Ordering daimyo to stay in Edo
    3. Developing the silk industry at Nishijin to reduce imports paid for in precious metals
    4. Inviting Commodore Perry
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Paying for imported luxuries with gold and silver strained the economy, so the Tokugawa restricted exports of precious metals and developed the silk industry in Nishijin, whose silk came to be known as the best in the world.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): The shogun ordered the daimyo to stay at the capital, Edo, for long periods. Reason (R): The shogun wanted to make sure the domainal lords would not pose a threat to him.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    3. A is true, but R is false
    4. A is false, but R is true
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Both are true. Keeping the daimyo in Edo for long periods let the shogun watch them, so they would not threaten his power. R explains A.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery