- Foundation
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Putting political theory to practice: many meanings of equality
Explain why political concepts have many definitions, how Socrates used reason to test a definition of justice, and how reflecting on everyday experience reveals the layers of meaning in equality.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain why concepts like equality have many definitions while a triangle has one.
- Describe how Socrates, in Plato's Republic, used reason to expose the weaknesses of a view of justice.
- Show how the meaning of equality depends on context, using everyday situations.
This section of the chapter moves from describing political theory to doing it. The textbook confines itself to one part of political theory: the origins, meaning and significance of familiar political ideas such as freedom, equality, citizenship, justice, development, nationalism and secularism. When we begin any debate we ask two questions: what does it mean? and how does it matter? This lesson shows those questions at work.
Why there are many definitions
In mathematics there is one definition of a triangle or a square. In political theory we meet many definitions of equality, freedom or justice. The textbook explains why: such terms concern our relationships with other human beings, not with things. Human beings, unlike things, have opinions on issues like equality, and these many opinions must be understood and harmonised.
A mathematical concept and a political concept
-
Triangle (mathematics)
- Concerns things (shapes)
- One agreed definition
- Settled by proof
-
Equality (political theory)
- Concerns relations among people
- Many definitions
- People hold opinions that must be understood and harmonised
Socrates and the method of reason
The chapter tells the story of Socrates of ancient Athens, described as the wisest man, who questioned popular beliefs about society, religion and politics and was condemned to death by the rulers of Athens for it. His student Plato wrote about his life and ideas. In the book The Republic, Plato made Socrates a character and through him examined the question: what is justice? The book opens with a dialogue between Socrates and Cephalus, in which Cephalus and his friends come to see that their understanding of justice cannot be sustained.
In our own words, the argument runs like this. One proposed view is that justice means telling the truth and paying back what you owe. Socrates offers a counter-case: if a friend left weapons with you while sane and asks for them back after losing his mind, returning them seems wrong, so the definition has exceptions. The discussion then moves (with Polemarchus continuing it) to the view that justice is doing good to friends and harm to enemies. Socrates argues that harming a person makes that person worse in human excellence, that is, less just; and a just person, using justice, cannot make others unjust, any more than a musician by music can make people unmusical. So harming anyone cannot be just, and that definition also fails.
How Socrates tests a definition (our summary)
- State a definition Justice = speaking the truth and repaying debts.
- Find a counter-case Returning weapons to a friend who has lost his reason.
- Revise the definition Justice = helping friends, harming enemies.
- Test by reason again Harming makes people worse, so the just cannot harm anyone.
- Admit the limits The speakers agree their view cannot be sustained.
The important point, the textbook stresses, is that Socrates uses reason to reveal the limitations and inconsistencies in a point of view, until his opponents admit that views they had lived by cannot be sustained.
Layers of meaning in equality
The textbook then works through equality starting from everyday experience:
| Everyday experience | What we learn about equality |
|---|---|
| Someone jumps the queue at a shop or office and we feel cheated | Equality means equal opportunity for all |
| Separate counters exist for the old and the disabled | Special treatment may be justified |
| Poor labourers cannot pay for goods or a doctor | Equality must involve fairness so people are not unduly exploited by economic factors |
| Children must work, and girls are kept home to look after siblings, though primary education is a constitutional right | A right can remain formal; people must be enabled through proactive measures and fair distribution of resources |
The last row leads to a key conclusion: when people cannot meet basic needs, equal opportunity is not enough. They must be enabled, through proactive measures such as a fair distribution of resources (jobs, decent wages, subsidised hospitals), and this requires that some agency be made responsible for ensuring fairness. So the meaning of equality is dependent on context. We began with what it meant for ourselves, moved to others such as the poor and senior citizens, and found many layers of meaning. As the textbook puts it, we were doing political theory without realising it.
Political concepts have many definitions because they concern relations among people who hold opinions. Political theorists clarify them by studying how they are used in ordinary language and then examining the different meanings systematically.
Political theorists then ask practical questions: When is equality of opportunity enough? When do people need special treatment? How far and how long should it be given? Should poor children be given midday meals to encourage them to stay in school? Such questions provide guidelines for public policy on education and employment.
Worked example 1: testing a definition the Socratic way
A made-up student, Riya, proposes: 'Equality means treating everyone in exactly the same way.' Test with a counter-case: a wheelchair user and a runner are both told to use the same staircase. Treating them identically leaves the wheelchair user unable to enter. Revise: 'Equality means equal opportunity, with special provisions where people are disadvantaged.' This is the method of the textbook's Socrates story: state, test against a case, revise.
Worked example 2: placing a policy on the layers
Where does a scheme of free midday meals for school children fit? Reasoning: it is not about who goes first in a queue (equal opportunity) nor about a special counter (special treatment for a group with a disability). It helps children who could not otherwise stay in school, so it belongs to the layer of enabling people through proactive measures, with an agency taking responsibility. The textbook lists this very question among those political theorists address.
Key takeaways: political concepts have many definitions because they concern people, who hold opinions. Socrates, in Plato's Republic, used reason to expose the weaknesses of views of justice. Reflecting on experience shows that equality can mean equal opportunity, justified special treatment, fairness against economic exploitation, and enabling people through proactive measures; its meaning depends on context. Political theory turns these reflections into guidelines for policy.
Check your understanding
-
1. Why, according to the chapter, do we meet many definitions of equality but one definition of a triangle?
- Equality has never been defined by anyone
- Mathematicians are more careful than political theorists
- Triangles exist only in India
- Equality concerns relations with other human beings, who hold opinions on it
Show answer
Answer: D. The chapter explains that terms like equality concern our relationships with human beings rather than things, and human beings have opinions that must be understood and harmonised.
-
2. In Plato's The Republic, the dialogue at the start is between Socrates and:
- Aristotle
- Cephalus
- Rousseau
- Kautilya
Show answer
Answer: B. The chapter says The Republic opens with a dialogue between Socrates and Cephalus, whose friends later continue the discussion.
-
3. The main lesson the textbook draws from the Socrates story is that:
- reason can reveal the limitations and inconsistencies of a view until it is given up
- justice cannot be discussed at all
- old men always hold wrong opinions
- rulers should never be questioned
Show answer
Answer: A. The chapter stresses that Socrates used reason to reveal limitations and inconsistencies in a point of view, until his adversaries admitted their views could not be sustained.
-
4. Case: A village has a government school, but many girls are kept at home to care for younger siblings while parents work. Applying the chapter's reasoning, what does this show?
- Equality has been fully achieved because a school exists
- Girls do not want to study
- A right to education can remain formal unless people are enabled to use it
- Special counters should be built at the school
Show answer
Answer: C. The chapter notes that although the Constitution guarantees primary education, the right remains formal for such children; they need proactive measures and some agency must ensure fairness.
-
5. Assertion (A): The meaning of equality depends on the context. Reason (R): In a queue we want equal opportunity, but those who cannot afford basic needs require more than equal opportunity.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is true, but R is false
- A is false, but R is true
Show answer
Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A: equality means different things in different situations, from equal opportunity in a queue to enabling the poor through fair distribution, so its meaning depends on context.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.