- Foundation
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Why we should study political theory
Give the textbook's four reasons for studying political theory, including the concert-audience comparison for citizens, and explain how it helps us examine our own prejudices and argue in an informed way.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- State the four reasons the textbook gives for studying political theory.
- Explain the comparisons with mathematics and with a music audience.
- Show how political theory helps us examine our own ideas and debate reasonably.
Is political theory only for politicians, bureaucrats who make policies, teachers of the subject, lawyers and judges who interpret the Constitution, or activists and journalists who expose exploitation and demand new rights? What does a school student gain from knowing the meaning of freedom or equality? The chapter closes by answering these questions with four reasons.
Reason 1: relevant to many careers, and to life in general
Political theory is relevant to all those groups just listed, and students may join one of these professions in future, so it is indirectly relevant to them now. The textbook compares it to mathematics: we all learn mathematics even though few of us will become mathematicians or engineers, because basic arithmetic is useful in life generally. In the same way, a basic grasp of political ideas is useful to everyone.
Reason 2: we are all citizens
We are all going to be citizens entitled to vote and to decide other issues. To act responsibly, it helps to know the political ideas and institutions that shape our world. In the information society, we need to be reasonable and informed to take part in gram sabhas or to give our views on websites and polls. Simply expressing arbitrary preferences is not effective; thoughtful, mature citizens can use new media to discuss and express common interests.
The textbook offers a memorable comparison. Citizens are like the audience at a music concert. The audience are not the main performers who interpret the song and melody. But they set the agenda, appreciate the output and put in new requests. Musicians perform better before a knowledgeable, appreciative audience. Similarly, an educated and vigilant citizenry makes those who practise politics more public-spirited.
The concert comparison
-
Concert
- Musicians perform
- Audience sets the agenda and requests songs
- Knowledgeable audience, better performance
-
Democracy
- Politicians govern
- Citizens set the agenda and make demands
- Vigilant citizens, more public-spirited politics
Reason 3: examining our own ideas and feelings
Freedom, equality and secularism are not abstract issues. The textbook notes that we meet discrimination of various sorts in families, schools, colleges and shopping malls, and that we ourselves may hold prejudices against people of a different caste, religion, gender or class. If we feel oppressed we want it redressed, and if redress is delayed we may even feel violent revolution is justified. If we are privileged we may deny that oppression exists, even while those who work for us struggle for dignity. Political theory encourages us to examine our ideas and feelings about political matters, and by looking at them more carefully we become moderate in our ideas and feelings.
Reason 4: debating with reasons
Students enjoy debates and elocution. We have opinions on what is right or wrong, just or unjust, but we may not know whether they are reasonable. Only when we argue with others do we feel the need to defend our views with reasons and arguments. Political theory exposes us to systematic thinking on justice or equality, so we can polish our opinions and argue in an informed manner, for the sake of common interests. The textbook adds that such skills of debating rationally and communicating effectively are likely to be great assets in the global informational order.
Why study political theory
-
Useful to all
- Many professions need it
- Like arithmetic, useful in life
-
Responsible citizenship
- Voting and gram sabhas
- Informed views, not arbitrary preferences
-
Self-examination
- Notice our own prejudices
- Become moderate
-
Reasoned debate
- Polish opinions
- Argue for common interests
An educated and vigilant citizenry, like a knowledgeable audience at a concert, sets the agenda and makes those who practise politics more public-spirited.
Worked example 1: arbitrary preference or informed view?
At a made-up gram sabha meeting in Rampur, two residents speak about where to dig a new well. Resident A says, 'Dig it near my house; I just want it there.' Resident B says, 'Dig it near the school, because the most families and the children can reach it, and the land there is common land.' Reasoning: A expresses an arbitrary preference; B gives reasons linked to a common interest. The textbook's second and fourth reasons say political theory trains us to speak like B, which is more effective in collective decision making.
Worked example 2: is studying political theory like studying mathematics?
This is one of the chapter's own discussion questions. Similarity: both are studied by everyone because their basics are useful in ordinary life, not only by specialists. Difference: in mathematics a concept such as a triangle has one definition, while political concepts such as equality have many definitions that depend on context and on people's opinions (lesson 4). A balanced answer gives both points.
Key takeaways: political theory is relevant to politicians, officials, lawyers, judges, activists and journalists, and, like arithmetic, to everyone. It prepares us to be responsible, informed citizens; like a knowledgeable concert audience, vigilant citizens make politics more public-spirited. It helps us examine our own prejudices and become moderate, and it trains us to argue with reasons for common interests.
Check your understanding
-
1. In the chapter's comparison, citizens in a democracy are like:
- the composers of a song
- the stage lights at a concert
- the audience at a music concert
- the ticket sellers
Show answer
Answer: C. The chapter compares citizens to a concert audience: not the main performers, but they set the agenda, appreciate the output and make new requests, and a knowledgeable audience improves the performance.
-
2. The textbook compares studying political theory to studying mathematics because:
- both have only one definition for every concept
- basic knowledge of both is useful in life even for those who will not become specialists
- both are needed only by engineers
- both avoid any discussion of values
Show answer
Answer: B. The chapter asks whether we learn mathematics only to become mathematicians, and answers that basic arithmetic is useful in life generally; political theory is useful in the same way.
-
3. According to the chapter, by examining our ideas and feelings about political things more carefully, we become:
- moderate in our ideas and feelings
- more prejudiced
- uninterested in politics
- certain that violent revolution is justified
Show answer
Answer: A. The chapter says political theory encourages us to examine our ideas and feelings, and just by looking at them more carefully we become moderate.
-
4. Assertion (A): Vigilant citizens help democracy work well. Reason (R): An educated and vigilant citizenry makes those who practise politics more public-spirited.
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is true, but R is false
- A is false, but R is true
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
Show answer
Answer: D. Both are true. R gives the reason the chapter offers through the concert comparison: vigilant citizens push politicians to be more public-spirited, which is why they help democracy work.
-
5. Which of the following best describes what the textbook says about simply expressing arbitrary preferences in gram sabhas or online polls?
- It is the best way to participate
- It is not very effective; thoughtful, informed views work better
- It is required by law
- It is the same as reasoned argument
Show answer
Answer: B. The chapter says that if we merely express arbitrary preferences we will not be very effective, but if we are thoughtful and mature we can use new media to discuss common interests.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.