• Foundation
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

What is politics? Conflicting images and a broader view

Compare the negative and positive images of politics, explain why the textbook calls politics an integral part of every society, and show that politics goes beyond the affairs of government.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Describe the different, often conflicting, ideas people hold about politics.
  • Explain why the textbook regards politics as an integral part of any society.
  • Define politics in the broad sense used by the textbook, at both the level of government and the level of people.

Ask ten people what politics is and you may get ten different answers. Some will speak of public service, others of trickery, others will simply point to politicians. Before we can study political theory, we need to be clear about what politics itself is. The textbook takes the common, gloomy picture seriously, and then argues for a broader and more useful view.

Conflicting images of politics

The chapter notes several ideas of politics that people commonly hold:

  • Politics as public service: the view often put forward by political leaders and by those who contest elections and hold office.
  • Politics as manipulation and intrigue: activity used to pursue ambitions and satisfy wants.
  • Politics as what politicians do: and if people see politicians changing parties, making false promises, manipulating groups or chasing personal interests, they come to link politics with scams.
  • Playing politics in daily life: the phrase is used whenever someone pushes their own interest by any means, for example a player scheming to stay in a team or a colleague who always agrees with the boss.

Disappointed by such behaviour, many people say they are not interested in politics and want to keep away from it. The textbook observes that this attitude is found not only among ordinary people but also among business people and film stars, even though, as it points out, some of them fund parties or join politics themselves. So we face two opposed pictures: is politics an undesirable activity to be avoided, or a worthwhile one that we must engage with to make a better world?

Two pictures of politics

  • Politics as something to avoid
    • Self-interest pursued by any method
    • Manipulation, false promises, scams
    • 'I want to stay away from politics'
  • Politics as integral and worthwhile
    • Every society needs collective decisions
    • Governments shape our daily lives
    • People engage to build a better world

Why politics cannot be avoided

The textbook regrets that politics has come to mean the pursuit of self-interest by any method, and insists that politics is an important and integral part of any society. It recalls a remark of Mahatma Gandhi: politics surrounds us like the coils of a snake, and there is no way out except to wrestle with it. The reasoning is straightforward. No society can exist without some political organisation and collective decision making. A society that wants to last must take account of the many needs and interests of its members.

Human beings have created many social institutions for this purpose: the family, tribes and economic institutions help people meet their needs and recognise their obligations to each other. Among these, governments play an important part, so how governments are formed and how they function is a major focus of politics.

Politics is more than government

What governments do matters because it touches people's lives. Governments make economic, foreign and educational policy. Good policies can raise literacy and employment and open the way to a good school and a decent job. An inefficient or corrupt government can endanger people's lives and security: if conflicts are allowed to turn violent, markets and schools close, the sick cannot reach hospitals and studies are disrupted.

Because government affects us so deeply, people respond. They form associations, organise campaigns to voice demands, negotiate with others to shape the goals governments pursue, protest and demonstrate to persuade the government to change laws, and debate the actions of their representatives. In all this, people are looking for the reasons behind disorder and trying to create a better world.

Politics arises because people have different ideas of what is just and desirable. It is the process of negotiation through which a society reaches collective decisions: it covers both what governments do and how people struggle to influence those decisions.

— Key definition, in our own words
The two levels of politics in the textbook's summary
LevelWhat it involvesExample (made up)
GovernmentWhat governments do and how this relates to people's hopesA state government plans a new policy on school admissions
PeopleHow people struggle and influence decision makingParents form an association and petition for changes to the policy

The textbook concludes that people engage in political activity whenever they negotiate with each other and take part in collective activities meant to promote social development and solve common problems.

Worked example 1: is this politics?

Residents of a made-up housing colony, Shanti Nagar, disagree about whether to spend common funds on a park or on street lights. They hold meetings, argue, and finally agree to do the street lights first and the park next year. Is this politics? Reasoning: the residents have different visions of what is desirable; they negotiate; they reach a collective decision about a common problem. No government is involved, but by the textbook's broad definition this is political activity. Answer: yes.

Worked example 2: tracing a policy into daily life

Suppose (as an illustration) a government decides to build more schools and train more teachers in a district. Trace the effect. Step 1: policy is made by government (level of government). Step 2: more children can attend school nearby. Step 3: with education, more young people can find decent jobs. Step 4: if the policy is poorly carried out, parents may campaign or protest (level of people). This shows the textbook's point that government action reaches into every life, which is why people take a lively interest in it.

Key takeaways: people hold conflicting images of politics, from public service to scams. The textbook argues that politics is integral to every society because collective decisions are unavoidable; Gandhi compared it to coils of a snake one must wrestle with. Politics includes the formation and functioning of government, but also people's negotiations, campaigns and protests. People act politically whenever they negotiate and act together on common problems.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. The remark that politics envelops us like the coils of a snake, so that we must wrestle with it, is attributed in the chapter to:

    1. Karl Marx
    2. Aristotle
    3. Mahatma Gandhi
    4. Jean Jacques Rousseau
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The chapter recalls Mahatma Gandhi's observation that politics surrounds us like a snake's coils and the only way out is to wrestle with it.

  2. 2. Which of the following is listed in the chapter as a social institution that helps people meet their needs?

    1. The family
    2. The weather
    3. The stock of natural minerals
    4. A cricket score
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The chapter names the family, tribes and economic institutions as social institutions that help people live together and meet their needs; government is another important one.

  3. 3. Read the case: Farmers in a district form a union, meet officials and hold a peaceful march to ask for better irrigation. According to the textbook's view, this is:

    1. not politics, because no farmer holds office
    2. politics only if a party organises it
    3. an economic activity with no political side
    4. political activity, because people are negotiating and acting together to influence decisions
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The textbook says politics involves how people struggle and influence decision making, not only what governments do. Forming associations, negotiating and protesting are its own examples.

  4. 4. Assertion (A): No society can exist without some form of political organisation. Reason (R): A society that wants to sustain itself must take account of the many needs and interests of its members and make collective decisions.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    3. A is true, but R is false
    4. A is false, but R is true
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Both are stated in the chapter, and R explains A: because members have many needs and interests, collective decisions are required, and that requires political organisation.

  5. 5. According to the textbook, politics arises from the fact that:

    1. governments exist
    2. people have different visions of what is just and desirable for themselves and their society
    3. elections are held regularly
    4. some people are more intelligent than others
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The chapter's summary says politics arises because we have different visions of what is just and desirable, and involves the negotiations through which collective decisions are made.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery