- Foundation
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Citizen and nation: identity, criteria and the Indian Constitution
Explain how nation states define national identity, why some citizens find it easier to identify with it than others, how criteria for citizenship vary, and how the Indian Constitution adopted an inclusive, democratic notion of citizenship.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain what nation states claim and how national identity is expressed.
- Explain why even inclusive democracies may make it easier for some citizens than others to identify with the nation.
- Describe how citizenship can be acquired in India and the Constitution's inclusive approach, and explain why democratic citizenship is called a project.
Citizens belong to a state, but most states also see themselves as nations. This lesson looks at how the two ideas connect, and at the choices states make about who can become a citizen.
The nation state and national identity
The nation state developed in the modern period. One of the earliest assertions of the sovereignty of the nation state and the democratic rights of citizens was made by the revolutionaries in France in 1789. Nation states claim that their boundaries define not only a territory but also a unique culture and shared history. National identity may be expressed through symbols like a flag, national anthem, national language or ceremonial practices.
Most modern states include people of different religions, languages and cultures. The national identity of a democratic state is supposed to give citizens a political identity shared by all, and democracies usually try to define it as inclusively as possible. But in practice, the textbook says, most countries define their identity in ways that make it easier for some citizens to identify with the state than others, and easier to extend citizenship to some people than to others. This, it adds, is true even of countries that pride themselves on being inclusive or on being countries of immigrants.
The textbook's illustration is a country that claims to be secular and inclusive and expects all citizens to assimilate into a common culture and language in public life, while keeping personal beliefs in private life. This may seem reasonable, but drawing the line between public and private is not simple. Where some schools disallowed religious symbols such as a turban or a head scarf with the school uniform, students whose religions did not require such practices faced no problem. The textbook's conclusion is that assimilation into a national culture can be easier for some groups than for others.
Criteria for citizenship vary
The criteria for granting citizenship to new applicants vary from country to country. The textbook notes that in some countries factors like religion or ethnic origin may be given priority, and that children of migrant workers born and brought up in a country do not always automatically become its citizens, which can lead to long debates. These are examples of restrictions that may exist even in democracies that consider themselves inclusive.
India: an inclusive experiment
India defines itself as a secular, democratic nation state. The independence movement was broad-based and deliberately tried to unite people of different religions, regions and cultures. The textbook notes that Partition took place in 1947 when differences with the Muslim League could not be resolved, but that this strengthened the resolve of national leaders to keep the Indian nation state secular and inclusive, a resolve embodied in the Constitution.
The Constitution tried to give full and equal citizenship to very different groups: Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes, women who had not previously enjoyed equal rights, remote communities in the Andaman and Nicobar Islands with little contact with modern civilisation, and many others. It sought a place for different languages, religions and practices, giving equal rights without forcing people to give up their beliefs, languages or cultural practices. The textbook calls this a unique experiment, symbolised by the Republic Day parade in Delhi, which tries to include people of different regions, cultures and religions.
| Feature | What the chapter says |
|---|---|
| Where the provisions are | Part Two of the Constitution and later laws passed by Parliament |
| Nature | An essentially democratic and inclusive notion of citizenship |
| Ways to acquire citizenship | Birth, descent, registration, naturalisation, or inclusion of territory |
| Non-discrimination | The state should not discriminate on grounds only of religion, race, caste, sex, place of birth, or any of them |
| Minorities | Rights of religious and linguistic minorities are protected |
Ways of acquiring Indian citizenship
- Birth
- Descent
- Registration
- Naturalisation
- Inclusion of territory
Citizenship as a project
Even such inclusive provisions have led to struggles. The women's movement, the dalit movement, and struggles of people displaced by development projects are among those waged by people who feel denied full citizenship rights. The textbook concludes that India's experience shows democratic citizenship is a project, an ideal to work towards. New issues arise as societies change, and groups who feel marginalised make new demands, which in a democracy must be negotiated.
Democratic citizenship is not a finished achievement but a project: an ideal to work towards, as new groups raise new demands that a democracy must negotiate.
Worked example 1: inclusive or not?
A made-up country, Freedonia, requires every citizen to speak only the national language in all public offices, including when seeking help at a hospital. Analyse using the chapter. Reasoning: a single public language may be meant to build a shared identity, but it makes it easier for native speakers to identify with the state than for others, and may block some citizens' access to services. The chapter's point is that national identities, even when meant to be inclusive, can be easier for some groups to accept than others.
Worked example 2: matching the mode of citizenship
Which mode applies? (a) A child born in India; (b) a person who lives in India for many years and applies for citizenship under the law; (c) people living in a territory that becomes part of India. Answers: (a) birth; (b) naturalisation (or registration, depending on the law's conditions); (c) inclusion of territory. The exact conditions are set by laws passed by Parliament.
Key takeaways: nation states, first asserted in France in 1789, claim a territory, culture and history, expressed in symbols. Democracies try to define national identity inclusively, but in practice it is easier for some groups to identify with it, and citizenship criteria vary across countries. India chose a secular, democratic and inclusive citizenship: acquired by birth, descent, registration, naturalisation or inclusion of territory, with non-discrimination and minority rights. Democratic citizenship remains a project.
Check your understanding
-
1. According to the chapter, one of the earliest assertions of the sovereignty of the nation state and democratic rights of citizens was made:
- in India in 1947
- by the revolutionaries in France in 1789
- in South Africa in 1994
- by the United Nations in 1948
Show answer
Answer: B. The chapter says one of the earliest such assertions was made by the revolutionaries in France in 1789.
-
2. Which of the following is NOT listed in the chapter as a way of acquiring Indian citizenship?
- Birth
- Naturalisation
- Inclusion of territory
- Owning property in India
Show answer
Answer: D. The chapter says citizenship in India can be acquired by birth, descent, registration, naturalisation or inclusion of territory. Owning property is not one of them.
-
3. The chapter's discussion of school rules on religious symbols in a country that expects public assimilation shows that:
- assimilation into a national culture can be easier for some groups than for others
- all groups find assimilation equally easy
- religion has no place in private life
- uniforms are always unconstitutional
Show answer
Answer: A. The chapter notes that those whose religions did not require such practices faced no problem, so assimilation into the national culture was easier for some groups than others.
-
4. Why does the chapter call democratic citizenship 'a project'?
- Because it was completed in 1950
- Because it is a school assignment
- Because new issues keep arising and marginalised groups make new demands that must be negotiated
- Because only some people are citizens
Show answer
Answer: C. The chapter says India's experience shows democratic citizenship is a project, an ideal to work towards, since new issues arise and marginalised groups raise demands that a democracy must negotiate.
-
5. Assertion (A): The Indian Constitution tried to give equal rights to all without forcing people to give up their personal beliefs, languages or cultural practices. Reason (R): After Partition, national leaders became more resolved to keep the Indian nation state secular and inclusive.
- A is false, but R is true
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- A is true, but R is false
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
Show answer
Answer: B. The chapter says Partition strengthened the leaders' resolve to keep India secular and inclusive, a resolve embodied in the Constitution, which accommodated diversity. R explains A.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.