• Foundation
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

Equal rights: the urban poor, tribal peoples and T. H. Marshall

Examine whether equal citizenship means guaranteed basic rights for rich and poor alike, using the urban poor, the Olga Tellis case and tribal and forest dwellers, and explain T. H. Marshall's theory of citizenship and why equal rights need not mean uniform policies.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Describe the situation and contributions of the urban poor and the steps taken to recognise their rights, including the Olga Tellis judgment.
  • Explain the threats faced by tribal peoples and forest dwellers.
  • Explain T. H. Marshall's three kinds of citizenship rights and why equal rights need not mean uniform policies.

The second question about full and equal membership is whether all citizens, rich or poor, should be guaranteed certain basic rights and a minimum standard of living by the state. The textbook examines this through the urban poor, whose problems it describes as among the most urgent facing government.

The urban poor

Every Indian city has a large population of slum-dwellers and squatters. They do necessary and useful work, often at low wages, yet are often seen as unwelcome visitors, blamed for straining city resources or spreading crime and disease. Conditions in slums can be shocking: many people in small rooms without private toilets, running water or sanitation; life and property insecure.

Yet slum-dwellers make a significant contribution to the economy through their labour: as hawkers, petty traders, scavengers, domestic workers, plumbers or mechanics, and through small businesses such as cane weaving, textile printing or tailoring. The city, the textbook observes, probably spends relatively little on their sanitation or water supply.

Awareness is growing among governments, NGOs and slum-dwellers themselves. The textbook mentions a national policy on urban street vendors framed in January 2004, meant to give vendors recognition and regulation so they could work without harassment as long as they followed government rules, and it asks students to find out about the Street Vendors (Protection of Livelihood and Regulation of Street Vending) Act, 2014. Slum-dwellers are also organising to demand their rights and have sometimes approached the courts. Even the right to vote can be hard for them to use, because inclusion in the voters' list requires a fixed address, which squatters and pavement dwellers may find difficult to provide.

The Olga Tellis case

The textbook describes an important Supreme Court decision on the rights of slum-dwellers in Bombay, in a Public Interest Litigation filed by social activist Olga Tellis against the Bombay Municipal Corporation in 1985. The petition claimed a right to live on pavements or in slums because no alternative accommodation was available near their workplaces, and eviction would also cost them their livelihood. The Court held that Article 21, which guarantees the right to life, includes the right to livelihood; so if pavement dwellers were to be evicted, they should first be provided alternative accommodation under the right to shelter.

The reasoning in the Olga Tellis case (as the chapter reports it)

  1. Claim Pavement and slum dwellers live near work because there is no alternative housing.
  2. Harm of eviction Eviction would destroy their livelihood.
  3. Constitutional link Article 21's right to life includes the right to livelihood.
  4. Outcome Before eviction, alternative accommodation should be provided under the right to shelter.

Tribal peoples and forest dwellers

Other groups becoming marginalised are tribal people and forest dwellers, who depend on access to forests and natural resources for their way of life. They face threats from population pressure and the search for land, from commercial interests wanting to mine resources in forests or coasts, and from the tourist industry. Governments struggle to protect these people and their habitat without endangering the country's development. The textbook stresses that this issue affects all citizens, not just tribal people.

Equal rights need not mean uniform policies

Ensuring equal rights is not simple: different groups have different needs, and the rights of one group may conflict with another's. Equal rights need not mean uniform policies for all. If the aim is to make people more equal, and not merely to apply the same rules to everyone, policies must take account of different needs and claims. Changes in the world, economy and society demand new interpretations of the rights of citizenship; formal laws are only the starting point. Equal citizenship means that providing equal rights and protection to all citizens should be a guiding principle of government policy.

T. H. Marshall on citizenship, equality and rights

The textbook presents the British sociologist T. H. Marshall (1893-1981). In Citizenship and Social Class (1950), he described citizenship, in our words, as a status given to full members of a community, all of whom are equal in the rights and duties that come with it. His key concept is equality, which implies two things: the quality of rights and duties improves, and the number of people who receive them grows.

Marshall's three kinds of citizenship rights

  • Civil rights
    • Protect life, liberty and property
  • Political rights
    • Enable participation in governance
  • Social rights
    • Give access to education and employment

Together these let the citizen live a life of dignity. Marshall saw social class as a 'system of inequality'; citizenship counters the divisive effects of class hierarchy and so helps create a better-integrated, harmonious community.

For T. H. Marshall, citizenship is a status of full membership in which all members are equal in rights and duties; it combines civil, political and social rights and counters the inequality of social class.

— Marshall's idea, in our own words

Worked example 1: equal rights on paper, unequal in practice

A made-up pavement dweller, Ramesh, is a citizen of voting age, but he cannot get on the voters' list. Why? Reasoning: inclusion requires a fixed address, which he lacks. Conclusion: he has the right in law but cannot exercise it; this illustrates the chapter's point that citizens may be granted equal rights but not all can exercise them equally.

Worked example 2: classifying Marshall's rights

Classify by Marshall's scheme: (a) the right not to be imprisoned without trial; (b) the right to stand for election; (c) the right to free schooling. Answers: (a) civil right (protects liberty); (b) political right (participation in governance); (c) social right (access to education).

Key takeaways: the urban poor contribute greatly to city economies but face insecure lives and difficulty even in voting; policies on street vendors and court cases such as Olga Tellis (1985: right to life includes livelihood; alternative accommodation before eviction) recognise their claims. Tribal and forest dwellers face threats from population pressure, mining and tourism. Equal rights need not mean uniform policies. Marshall saw citizenship as equal status combining civil, political and social rights, countering class inequality.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. In the Olga Tellis case (1985), as reported in the chapter, the Supreme Court held that the right to life under Article 21 includes:

    1. the right to property
    2. the right to livelihood
    3. the right to vote
    4. the right to migrate abroad
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The chapter quotes the Court as holding that Article 21's right to life included the right to livelihood, so evicted pavement dwellers should first get alternative accommodation.

  2. 2. Why may pavement dwellers find it difficult to exercise the right to vote, according to the chapter?

    1. They are not citizens
    2. Voting is too expensive
    3. Inclusion in the voters' list requires a fixed address
    4. They are too young
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The chapter says that to be included in the list of voters a fixed address is required, which squatters and pavement dwellers may find difficult to provide.

  3. 3. T. H. Marshall's three kinds of citizenship rights are:

    1. civil, political and social
    2. natural, legal and moral
    3. religious, cultural and economic
    4. local, national and global
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The chapter says Marshall saw citizenship as involving civil rights (life, liberty, property), political rights (participation in governance) and social rights (access to education and employment).

  4. 4. Which of the following is NOT mentioned in the chapter as a threat to tribal peoples and forest dwellers?

    1. Pressure of increasing populations
    2. Commercial interests wanting to mine resources
    3. The tourist industry
    4. Free schooling in their own language
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The chapter lists population pressure, commercial mining interests and the tourist industry as threats. Free schooling in one's language is not named as a threat.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): Equal rights for citizens need not mean uniform policies for all people. Reason (R): Different groups have different needs, and to make people more equal, policies must take these different needs into account.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    3. A is true, but R is false
    4. A is false, but R is true
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The chapter says that since different groups have different needs, policies aiming to make people more equal must account for those needs; hence equal rights need not mean uniform policies. R explains A.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery