• Foundation
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Universal citizenship, refugees and global citizenship

Explain the problem of refugees and stateless people as a challenge to universal citizenship, and weigh the case for global citizenship against the continuing importance of national citizenship, as the textbook presents them.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain why refugees and stateless people challenge the promise of universal citizenship.
  • Describe the difficulties states face in deciding whom to admit, with the textbook's Indian example.
  • Explain the arguments for global citizenship and why the textbook says national citizenship remains important.

Theories of democratic citizenship say citizenship should be universal: everyone should be a full member of some state. Yet the world has many stateless people. This lesson examines the gap, and asks whether a global citizenship could fill it.

Refugees and stateless people

The textbook describes images we may have of refugees and illegal migrants: people who pay agents to be smuggled into Europe or America despite great risks, or people displaced by war or famine, forced to become refugees in their own or neighbouring countries.

We often assume full membership should be open to those who live and work in a country and to those who apply. But although many states support universal and inclusive citizenship, each also fixes criteria for granting it, usually in its constitution and laws, and uses its power to keep unwanted visitors out. Despite restrictions, even walls and fences, considerable migration still occurs. People displaced by war, persecution, famine or other reasons who cannot return home and whom no state will accept become stateless people or refugees. They may live in camps or as illegal migrants, often unable to work legally, educate their children or own property. The problem is so large that the UN has appointed a High Commissioner for Refugees to help them.

How people become stateless (as the chapter describes)

  1. Displacement War, persecution, famine or redrawn borders force people to leave.
  2. Cannot return Home is unsafe or no longer recognises them.
  3. No state accepts them States apply criteria and keep unwanted entrants out.
  4. Stateless or refugee Camps or illegal status; often cannot work, educate children or own property.

A hard choice for states

Deciding how many people can be absorbed as citizens is a difficult humanitarian and political problem. Many countries accept those fleeing persecution or war, but may not want unmanageable numbers or security risks. The textbook notes that India prides itself on providing refuge to persecuted peoples, as it did with the Dalai Lama and his followers in 1959. People from neighbouring countries have entered along all of India's borders; many remain stateless for years or generations, and relatively few are eventually granted citizenship. Such problems, the textbook says, challenge the promise of democratic citizenship that rights and identity would be available to all; for those who cannot become citizens of a state of their choice, no alternative identity exists.

Global citizenship

The textbook asks what is common to events such as worldwide help for the victims of the 2004 tsunami in South Asia, international networks of terrorists, and the UN working with states to prevent the spread of diseases like bird flu. The answer: we live in an interconnected world. New means of communication such as the internet, television and mobile phones put us in immediate contact with events across the globe, helping develop shared sympathies among people of different countries.

National and global citizenship, as the textbook weighs them

  • Case for global citizenship
    • People already feel linked across borders
    • Worldwide help after disasters suggests an emerging global society
    • States face problems they cannot solve alone
    • Could help secure basic rights for migrants and stateless people wherever they live
  • Why national citizenship still matters
    • A world community does not yet exist
    • Inequalities within a country can only be solved by its own government and people
    • Full and equal membership of a state remains important

Supporters of global citizenship argue that although a world community does not yet exist, people already feel linked across national boundaries, and this feeling should be strengthened. National citizenship assumes the state can give us the protection and rights we need, but states face many problems they cannot tackle alone. Global citizenship might make it easier to deal with problems that cross national boundaries and need cooperation, such as migrants and stateless people, or at least to ensure them basic rights and protection wherever they live.

The textbook's balanced conclusion: threats to equal citizenship within a country, such as socio-economic inequalities, can ultimately be solved only by that society's government and people, so full and equal membership of a state remains important. But global citizenship reminds us that national citizenship may need to be supplemented by an awareness that we live in an interconnected world, and by readiness to work with people and governments across borders.

National citizenship remains essential, because each society must solve its own inequalities; global citizenship adds the awareness that we live in an interconnected world and must cooperate across borders.

— The textbook's conclusion, in our own words

Worked example 1: what does a stateless person lack?

A made-up family has lived in a border camp for twenty years; neither their old country nor their present one recognises them. List what they lack, using the chapter. Answer: no state guarantees their rights; they often cannot legally work, educate their children or own property; and they have no alternative political identity. This is why the textbook calls statelessness a challenge to the promise of universal democratic citizenship.

Worked example 2: which problem needs cross-border cooperation?

Which of these most clearly needs cooperation across national boundaries? (a) Repairing a village road; (b) stopping a disease spreading through several countries; (c) choosing a town's mayor. Answer: (b). A disease crosses borders, so no single state can handle it alone, which is the textbook's argument for strengthening links captured by the idea of global citizenship. (a) and (c) are matters for local and national citizens.

Key takeaways: many states support universal citizenship but fix criteria and keep unwanted entrants out, so people displaced by war, persecution or famine can become stateless, often unable to work, study or own property; the UN has a High Commissioner for Refugees. India gave refuge to the Dalai Lama and his followers in 1959, yet many people remain stateless. Global citizenship responds to an interconnected world, but the textbook concludes that national citizenship remains important and should be supplemented, not replaced.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. According to the chapter, the UN has appointed which office to help refugees?

    1. A Secretary for Tourism
    2. A High Commissioner for Refugees
    3. A World Citizenship Council
    4. A Global Election Commission
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The chapter says the problem of refugees is so great that the UN has appointed a High Commissioner for Refugees to try to help them.

  2. 2. Which example does the chapter give of India providing refuge to persecuted people?

    1. The Dalai Lama and his followers in 1959
    2. French revolutionaries in 1789
    3. South African workers in 1994
    4. Migrants to Germany
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The chapter says India prides itself on providing refuge to persecuted peoples, as it did with the Dalai Lama and his followers in 1959.

  3. 3. Worldwide help for the victims of the 2004 tsunami is used in the chapter as a sign of:

    1. the end of national citizenship
    2. the failure of the UN
    3. the emergence of a global society, according to supporters of global citizenship
    4. a new kind of tax
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The chapter says supporters of global citizenship see the outpouring of help after the Asian tsunami as a sign of an emerging global society.

  4. 4. According to the chapter's conclusion, why does full and equal membership of a state remain important?

    1. Because global citizenship already exists fully
    2. Because refugees prefer camps
    3. Because states face no cross-border problems
    4. Because problems like socio-economic inequality within a country can ultimately be solved only by that society's government and people
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The chapter says such problems can ultimately only be solved by the governments and people of that society, so national membership remains important, though it may be supplemented by global awareness.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): Statelessness poses a challenge to the promise of democratic citizenship. Reason (R): Democratic citizenship promises that the rights and identity of a citizen would be available to all people, yet stateless people have no alternative identity.

    1. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    2. A is true, but R is false
    3. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    4. A is false, but R is true
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The chapter says the promise of democratic citizenship is that rights and identity would be available to all; stateless people, who have no alternative identity, show that the promise is not yet met. R explains A.

Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.

Next lesson → Final self-assessment: Citizenship

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery