Revision notes

Chapter 6 Citizenship: Foundation

The key points, rules to remember, tables and diagrams from all 5 lessons, on one page for quick revision. To keep a copy, use your browser's Print and choose "Save as PDF".

Lesson 1

Citizenship as full and equal membership

Citizenship is full and equal membership of a political community: it gives a shared political identity, rights that are equal for all members, and obligations to the state and to fellow citizens.

— Key definition, in our own words
Rights citizens commonly enjoy in democracies (as listed in the chapter)
Kind of rightExamples
Political rightsThe right to vote
Civil rightsFreedom of speech or belief
Socio-economic rightsThe right to a minimum wage, the right to education

Struggles for citizenship rights (as the chapter describes)

  1. Against powerful monarchies Many European struggles, some violent, such as the French Revolution of 1789.
  2. Against colonial rule In Asia and Africa, demands for equal citizenship were part of independence struggles.
  3. Against racial rule in South Africa The black African population struggled against the ruling white minority until the early 1990s.
  4. Continuing movements In India, the women's movement and the dalit movement seek equal rights and opportunities.

Dimensions of citizenship

  • Citizen and state
    • Collective political identity
    • Rights: political, civil, socio-economic
    • Help and protection abroad
  • Citizen and citizen
    • Legal obligations
    • Moral obligation to contribute to shared life
  • Citizen and country's heritage
    • Trustees of culture
    • Trustees of natural resources

Key takeaways: citizenship is full and equal membership of a political community, giving a collective political identity, rights (political, civil, socio-economic) and protection. Refugees and illegal migrants show how much this membership matters. Citizens' rights were won through struggles against monarchies, colonial rule and racial domination, and struggles continue. Citizenship also involves legal and moral obligations to fellow citizens and makes citizens trustees of culture and natural resources.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 2

Freedom of movement, migrants and settling disputes

Martin Luther King Jr.'s arguments against segregation (as the chapter presents them)

  • Equal dignity
    • In self-worth and dignity every person is equal, whatever their race or colour
  • Social leprosy
    • Segregation inflicts deep psychological wounds on those who suffer it
    • It also lowers the quality of life of the white community, e.g. parks closed rather than opened to black people
  • Artificial boundaries
    • Segregation divides people and prevents cooperation for the country's overall benefit
  • Method
    • Peaceful, non-violent resistance; creative protest must not become physical violence

In a democracy, disputes over citizens' rights are to be settled by negotiation and discussion, not force, guided by the principle of full and equal membership for all citizens.

— Key idea, in our own words

Key takeaways: when resources are scarce, people divide into insiders and outsiders, even among fellow citizens. Freedom of movement matters to workers, but migrants can face local resistance, raising the questions of whether citizens may live and work anywhere, and whether poor migrants have the same right as skilled ones. Martin Luther King Jr. opposed segregation on grounds of equal dignity, its harm to all, and its artificial divisions, using non-violence. Democracies settle such disputes by negotiation, not force.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 3

Equal rights: the urban poor, tribal peoples and T. H. Marshall

The reasoning in the Olga Tellis case (as the chapter reports it)

  1. Claim Pavement and slum dwellers live near work because there is no alternative housing.
  2. Harm of eviction Eviction would destroy their livelihood.
  3. Constitutional link Article 21's right to life includes the right to livelihood.
  4. Outcome Before eviction, alternative accommodation should be provided under the right to shelter.

Marshall's three kinds of citizenship rights

  • Civil rights
    • Protect life, liberty and property
  • Political rights
    • Enable participation in governance
  • Social rights
    • Give access to education and employment

For T. H. Marshall, citizenship is a status of full membership in which all members are equal in rights and duties; it combines civil, political and social rights and counters the inequality of social class.

— Marshall's idea, in our own words

Key takeaways: the urban poor contribute greatly to city economies but face insecure lives and difficulty even in voting; policies on street vendors and court cases such as Olga Tellis (1985: right to life includes livelihood; alternative accommodation before eviction) recognise their claims. Tribal and forest dwellers face threats from population pressure, mining and tourism. Equal rights need not mean uniform policies. Marshall saw citizenship as equal status combining civil, political and social rights, countering class inequality.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 4

Citizen and nation: identity, criteria and the Indian Constitution

Citizenship in the Indian Constitution (as the chapter describes)
FeatureWhat the chapter says
Where the provisions arePart Two of the Constitution and later laws passed by Parliament
NatureAn essentially democratic and inclusive notion of citizenship
Ways to acquire citizenshipBirth, descent, registration, naturalisation, or inclusion of territory
Non-discriminationThe state should not discriminate on grounds only of religion, race, caste, sex, place of birth, or any of them
MinoritiesRights of religious and linguistic minorities are protected

Ways of acquiring Indian citizenship

  • Birth
  • Descent
  • Registration
  • Naturalisation
  • Inclusion of territory

Democratic citizenship is not a finished achievement but a project: an ideal to work towards, as new groups raise new demands that a democracy must negotiate.

— Key idea, in our own words

Key takeaways: nation states, first asserted in France in 1789, claim a territory, culture and history, expressed in symbols. Democracies try to define national identity inclusively, but in practice it is easier for some groups to identify with it, and citizenship criteria vary across countries. India chose a secular, democratic and inclusive citizenship: acquired by birth, descent, registration, naturalisation or inclusion of territory, with non-discrimination and minority rights. Democratic citizenship remains a project.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 5

Universal citizenship, refugees and global citizenship

How people become stateless (as the chapter describes)

  1. Displacement War, persecution, famine or redrawn borders force people to leave.
  2. Cannot return Home is unsafe or no longer recognises them.
  3. No state accepts them States apply criteria and keep unwanted entrants out.
  4. Stateless or refugee Camps or illegal status; often cannot work, educate children or own property.

National and global citizenship, as the textbook weighs them

  • Case for global citizenship
    • People already feel linked across borders
    • Worldwide help after disasters suggests an emerging global society
    • States face problems they cannot solve alone
    • Could help secure basic rights for migrants and stateless people wherever they live
  • Why national citizenship still matters
    • A world community does not yet exist
    • Inequalities within a country can only be solved by its own government and people
    • Full and equal membership of a state remains important

National citizenship remains essential, because each society must solve its own inequalities; global citizenship adds the awareness that we live in an interconnected world and must cooperate across borders.

— The textbook's conclusion, in our own words

Key takeaways: many states support universal citizenship but fix criteria and keep unwanted entrants out, so people displaced by war, persecution or famine can become stateless, often unable to work, study or own property; the UN has a High Commissioner for Refugees. India gave refuge to the Dalai Lama and his followers in 1959, yet many people remain stateless. Global citizenship responds to an interconnected world, but the textbook concludes that national citizenship remains important and should be supplemented, not replaced.

Read the full lesson

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery