• Foundation
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Growth of local government in India before 1992

Trace local self-government in India from ancient sabhas through local boards, the 1919 and 1935 Acts and Gandhi's ideas, explain why the Constitution gave local government limited importance, and describe developments up to the 1989 recommendation for constitutional recognition.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Trace the history of local bodies from village sabhas to the Government of India Act, 1935.
  • Explain Gandhi's view of village self-government and why the Constitution initially gave local government limited importance.
  • Describe the Community Development Programme, the three-tier system and the problems that led to the 1989 recommendation.

Local self-government has deep roots in India, but its constitutional status came only in the 1990s. This lesson traces that journey.

From village sabhas to local boards

Self-governing village communities are believed to have existed in India from the earliest times in the form of sabhas (village assemblies). Over time these took the shape of panchayats, literally an assembly of five persons, which resolved village issues; their roles kept changing. In modern times, elected local bodies were created after 1882, on the initiative of Lord Ripon, then Viceroy; they were called local boards. Progress was slow, and the Indian National Congress urged the government to make local bodies more effective. Following the Government of India Act, 1919, village panchayats were set up in a number of provinces, and this trend continued after the Government of India Act, 1935.

Gandhi and decentralisation

During the freedom movement, Mahatma Gandhi strongly pleaded for decentralisation of economic and political power. He saw strengthening village panchayats as a means of effective decentralisation, holding that development initiatives must involve local people to succeed. In his vision, independence had to begin at the bottom, with every village as a self-sustaining republic, forming ever-widening circles in which the apex is sustained by the base. (This is a summary of his idea, not his exact words.) The national movement was also worried about the enormous concentration of power in the Governor-General at Delhi, so for many leaders independence meant decentralised decision-making.

Local government in the Constitution of 1950

When the Constitution was prepared, local government was assigned to the States as a State subject. It was also mentioned in the Directive Principles as a policy direction, and so, as Chapter 2 showed, it was non-justiciable and mainly advisory. Many feel local government did not receive adequate importance. The chapter gives reasons:

  1. The turmoil of Partition produced a strong unitary inclination in the Constitution; Nehru saw extreme localism as a threat to the nation's unity and integration.
  2. A powerful voice in the Constituent Assembly, led by Dr B.R. Ambedkar, felt that the faction- and caste-ridden nature of rural society would defeat the purpose of rural local government.

Nobody denied the importance of people's participation in development. Many members wanted village panchayats as the basis of democracy but worried about factionalism and other ills in villages; one member argued, in substance, that villages should be trained in self-government and reformed on democratic principles.

After independence: experiments and setbacks

The Community Development Programme of 1952 sought people's participation in local development. Against this background, a three-tier Panchayati Raj system was recommended for rural areas, and some States, such as Gujarat and Maharashtra, adopted elected local bodies around 1960. But many problems remained:

  • local bodies in many States lacked enough powers and functions for local development;
  • they depended on State and central governments for finance;
  • many States did not think elected local bodies necessary at all;
  • local bodies were often dissolved and handed over to government officers;
  • many States held only indirect elections to most local bodies;
  • in many States, elections were postponed repeatedly.

After 1987, a thorough review began. In 1989, the P.K. Thungon Committee recommended constitutional recognition for local government bodies, through an amendment providing for periodic elections and for listing appropriate functions, along with funds, for them.

Milestones in the growth of local government

  1. Ancient times Village sabhas, later panchayats of five persons.
  2. 1882 Elected local boards under Lord Ripon.
  3. 1919 and 1935 Village panchayats set up in many provinces under the Government of India Acts.
  4. 1950 Constitution: a State subject and a Directive Principle.
  5. 1952 and around 1960 Community Development Programme; three-tier system; elected bodies in some States.
  6. 1989 Thungon Committee recommends constitutional recognition.

Before 1992, local government was only a State subject and a non-justiciable Directive Principle; local bodies often lacked powers, funds and regular elections, so in 1989 the Thungon Committee recommended constitutional recognition.

Worked example 1: Nehru and Ambedkar

Both Nehru and Ambedkar were cautious about local bodies. Did they have the same objection? Analysis from the chapter: no. Nehru's worry was about national unity: after Partition he saw extreme localism as a threat to integration. Ambedkar's worry was about village society: he felt factions and caste divisions would defeat the purpose of rural local government. One feared for the nation, the other for the weaker sections within villages.

Worked example 2: why constitutional status?

A made-up State dissolves all its panchayats and appoints officers to run them, and does not hold elections for eight years. Reasoning: before 1992 this was possible, because local government was only a State subject and a Directive Principle. That is exactly why the Thungon Committee recommended constitutional recognition with periodic elections: so that elected local bodies could not simply be wished away.

Worked example 3: is a non-elected panchayat democratic?

A cartoon voice in the chapter suspects that a non-elected village panchayat would be dominated by elders, the rich and upper-caste men. Reasoning: without elections and reservations, the existing power structure decides who sits on the panchayat. This links to Ambedkar's concern and explains why later reforms insisted on direct elections and reservations for women, Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes.

Key takeaways: village sabhas and panchayats are ancient; elected local boards began after 1882 under Lord Ripon and expanded after the 1919 and 1935 Acts. Gandhi championed village self-government. The Constitution made local government a State subject and a non-justiciable Directive Principle, partly because of Nehru's concern for unity and Ambedkar's concern about caste and faction in villages. After the 1952 Community Development Programme and three-tier experiments, local bodies remained weak, leading to the Thungon Committee's 1989 call for constitutional recognition.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Elected local bodies called local boards were created in modern India after 1882 on the initiative of:

    1. Lord Curzon
    2. Lord Dalhousie
    3. Lord Mountbatten
    4. Lord Ripon
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The chapter states that elected local government bodies were created after 1882 on the initiative of Lord Ripon, then Viceroy; they were called local boards.

  2. 2. Where was local government placed when the Constitution was first prepared?

    1. In the Union List and the Fundamental Rights
    2. In the Seventh Schedule's Union List
    3. In the Concurrent List only
    4. As a State subject and in the Directive Principles
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Local government was assigned to the States and mentioned in the Directive Principles, which made the provision non-justiciable and advisory.

  3. 3. Which reason did the voice led by Dr B.R. Ambedkar give for caution about rural local government?

    1. That it would be too expensive
    2. That villages had no need of government
    3. That the faction- and caste-ridden nature of rural society would defeat its purpose
    4. That it would threaten national unity after Partition
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Ambedkar's group felt factions and caste in rural society would defeat local government's purpose. The concern about national unity is associated with Nehru.

  4. 4. Assertion (A): Before 1992, elected local bodies did not exist reliably in many States. Reason (R): Many States held only indirect elections, dissolved local bodies or postponed their elections from time to time.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A.
    3. A is true, but R is false.
    4. A is false, but R is true.
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A: dissolutions, postponements and indirect elections meant elected local bodies were not a reliable reality before the amendments.

  5. 5. Which committee recommended constitutional recognition for local government bodies in 1989?

    1. The Sarkaria Commission
    2. The P.K. Thungon Committee
    3. The Cabinet Mission
    4. The States Reorganisation Commission
    Show answer

    Answer: B. In 1989 the P.K. Thungon Committee recommended constitutional recognition for local bodies, with periodic elections and functions and funds listed for them.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery