- Foundation
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
State Election Commissions, State Finance Commissions and the 74th Amendment
Explain the roles of the State Election Commissioner and the State Finance Commission, define an urban area as the Census does, and describe how the 74th Amendment extends the 73rd Amendment's provisions to Nagarpalikas with the Twelfth Schedule.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain the role and independence of the State Election Commissioner.
- Explain the purpose of the State Finance Commission.
- Define an urban area using the Census criteria and summarise the 74th Amendment.
Elections and money are the two lifelines of any government. The 73rd Amendment created two State-level institutions to protect them for local bodies, and the 74th Amendment applied the same design to towns and cities.
State Election Commissioner
Each State government must appoint a State Election Commissioner, responsible for conducting elections to Panchayati Raj institutions. Earlier this was done by the State administration, under the State government's control. Now the office is autonomous, like the Election Commission of India. However, the State Election Commissioner is an independent officer, not linked to or controlled by the Election Commission of India.
State Finance Commission
The State government must also appoint a State Finance Commission once every five years. It examines the financial position of local governments in the State and reviews the distribution of revenues between the State and local governments, and between rural and urban local governments. The chapter says this innovation ensures that allocating funds to rural local governments will not be a political matter. (A cartoon voice asks a fair question: States are themselves short of money and seek funds from the centre, so how much can they give local bodies?)
Two State-level institutions for local bodies
-
State Election Commissioner
- Appointed by the State government
- Conducts panchayat and municipal elections
- Autonomous; independent of the Election Commission of India
-
State Finance Commission
- Appointed once every five years
- Examines local bodies' finances
- Reviews revenue sharing: State and local; rural and urban
What is an urban area?
It is easy to call Mumbai or Kolkata urban, but harder for small places between village and town. The Census of India defines an urban area as having:
- a minimum population of 5,000;
- at least 75 per cent of the male working population in non-agricultural occupations; and
- a population density of at least 400 persons per sq. km.
According to the textbook, about 31 per cent of India's population lived in urban areas as per the 2011 Census.
The 74th Amendment
In many ways the 74th Amendment repeats the 73rd for urban areas. All the provisions on direct elections, reservations, transfer of subjects, the State Election Commission and the State Finance Commission apply to Nagarpalikas (urban local bodies). The Constitution also mandated the transfer of a list of functions from the State government to urban local bodies, listed in the Twelfth Schedule.
| Feature | 73rd Amendment | 74th Amendment |
|---|---|---|
| Applies to | Rural areas (Panchayati Raj institutions) | Urban areas (Nagarpalikas) |
| Elections | Direct; State Election Commissioner | Direct; State Election Commissioner |
| Reservations | Women, SC and ST; optional OBC | Same provisions |
| Finance | State Finance Commission | State Finance Commission |
| List of functions | Eleventh Schedule (29 subjects) | Twelfth Schedule |
Case box: Brazil
The chapter notes that Brazil's Constitution created States, Federal Districts and Municipal Councils, each with independent powers. Just as the Republic cannot interfere in the States' affairs except on constitutional grounds, the States are prohibited from interfering in municipal councils' affairs. This directly protects the powers of local government, a contrast with India, where the transfer of functions depends on State legislation.
The State Election Commissioner runs local elections independently of the Election Commission of India; the State Finance Commission, appointed every five years, reviews how revenue is shared with local bodies. The 74th Amendment applies the 73rd's design to towns and cities, with functions in the Twelfth Schedule.
Worked example 1: is it urban?
Apply the Census test to two made-up places. Place P: population 7,200; 80 per cent of working men in non-farm jobs; density 520 per sq. km. Place Q: population 9,000; 60 per cent of working men in non-farm jobs; density 610 per sq. km. Working: P meets all three conditions (7,200 is at least 5,000; 80 is at least 75; 520 is at least 400), so P is urban. Q fails the second condition (60 is less than 75), so Q is not urban by this definition, even though it is larger.
Worked example 2: who conducts this election?
(a) Elections to a town's municipal council. (b) Elections to a zilla panchayat. (c) Elections to the State Legislative Assembly. Answers: (a) and (b) are conducted by the State Election Commissioner; (c) by the Election Commission of India. The two bodies are independent of each other.
Worked example 3: why a Finance Commission?
In a made-up State, rural local bodies receive large grants in years when the ruling party is popular in villages and very little otherwise. Reasoning: the State Finance Commission, reviewing revenue sharing every five years on the basis of local bodies' finances, is meant to prevent exactly this, so that allocation of funds is not a political matter.
Key takeaways: each State appoints an autonomous State Election Commissioner, independent of the Election Commission of India, to conduct local elections, and a State Finance Commission every five years to review local finances and revenue sharing. The Census defines an urban area by population (at least 5,000), occupation (at least 75 per cent of working men in non-farm work) and density (at least 400 per sq. km). The 74th Amendment extends the 73rd's provisions to Nagarpalikas, with their functions in the Twelfth Schedule.
Check your understanding
-
1. Who conducts elections to Panchayati Raj institutions after the 73rd Amendment?
- The Election Commission of India
- The State Election Commissioner
- The District Collector
- The Gram Sabha
Show answer
Answer: B. Each State appoints a State Election Commissioner to conduct elections to Panchayati Raj institutions; the office is autonomous and independent of the Election Commission of India.
-
2. How often must a State Finance Commission be appointed?
- Every year
- Only when the centre directs
- Once in ten years
- Once in five years
Show answer
Answer: D. The State government must appoint a State Finance Commission once in five years to examine local finances and revenue sharing.
-
3. Which of the following is one of the Census criteria for an urban area?
- A minimum population of 1,000
- At least 50 per cent of women working in factories
- A population density of at least 400 persons per sq. km
- A municipal corporation building
Show answer
Answer: C. The Census criteria are a minimum population of 5,000, at least 75 per cent of the male working population in non-agricultural work, and a density of at least 400 persons per sq. km.
-
4. Assertion (A): The State Election Commissioner is under the control of the Election Commission of India. Reason (R): The office of the State Election Commissioner is autonomous like the Election Commission of India.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A.
- A is true, but R is false.
- A is false, but R is true.
Show answer
Answer: D. The assertion is false: the State Election Commissioner is independent and not under the control of the Election Commission of India. The reason is true.
-
5. In which Schedule are the functions to be transferred to urban local bodies listed?
- Eleventh Schedule
- Seventh Schedule
- First Schedule
- Twelfth Schedule
Show answer
Answer: D. Functions of urban local bodies under the 74th Amendment are listed in the Twelfth Schedule; the Eleventh Schedule lists the 29 subjects for panchayats.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.