• Foundation
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

How the amendments have worked: achievements and limits

Assess the implementation of the 73rd and 74th Amendments: regular elections, the presence of women and of Scheduled Castes and Tribes, tensions over power, and the limits caused by poor transfer of subjects and dependence on funds.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Describe the achievements of the amendments: uniform structures, regular elections and many more elected representatives.
  • Explain how reservations changed the social profile of local bodies and why this caused tensions.
  • Explain why local bodies still enjoy limited autonomy, with reference to subjects and finances.

Laws create possibilities; practice decides what they mean. The chapter ends by assessing how the 73rd and 74th Amendments have worked.

Achievements

All States passed laws to implement the amendments. According to the textbook, in the ten years after the amendments came into force (1994-2004), most States held at least two rounds of local elections, and some held three. The amendments created uniformity in the structure of Panchayati Raj and Nagarpalika institutions across the country. The very presence of these institutions is a significant achievement, creating a platform for people's participation in government.

The number of elected representatives has grown enormously. The textbook gives figures of hundreds of zilla panchayats, thousands of intermediate panchayats and lakhs of gram panchayats, with more than 32 lakh members elected every five years, of whom at least 13 lakh are women, compared with fewer than 5,000 elected representatives in all State Assemblies and Parliament together. (These are the textbook's figures and change over time.)

Women in local bodies

Because reservation also covers the posts of Sarpanch and Adhyaksha, a large number of women occupy leadership positions in panchayats and municipalities. The chapter says women have gained power and confidence by asserting control over resources, gained a better understanding of politics, and often brought a new perspective and greater sensitivity to discussions. In some cases women were unable to assert themselves or acted as proxies for male relatives who sponsored their election, but such instances are becoming fewer.

A changed social profile, and tension

Reservation for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes is mandatory, and most States also reserve seats for backward castes. As a result, a large number of elected members come from these communities, which has significantly altered the social profile of local bodies and made them more representative of social reality. This sometimes leads to tension: dominant groups that earlier controlled the village do not wish to give up power, so struggles for power intensify. The chapter's view: tension and struggle are not always bad; whenever democracy is made more meaningful by giving power to those who lacked it, some conflict is bound to arise.

Limits: autonomy, subjects and funds

Experience shows that local governments enjoy limited autonomy:

  • Many States have not transferred most of the 29 subjects, so local bodies cannot function effectively, and electing so many representatives becomes somewhat symbolic.
  • Critics say the reforms have not changed how decisions are taken at the State and central levels; people locally have little power to choose welfare programmes or allocate resources.
  • Local bodies have very little money of their own. According to the textbook, rural local bodies raise a tiny share of total government revenue (0.24 per cent) but account for a much larger share of expenditure (4 per cent), so they depend on grants from those who fund them.

The 73rd and 74th Amendments in practice

  • Achievements
    • Uniform structures across States
    • Regular elections
    • Many more elected representatives
    • Women and SC/ST in leadership
    • More representative local bodies
  • Limitations
    • Many subjects not transferred
    • Little money of their own
    • Dependence on State and central grants
    • Often only agencies implementing others' schemes
    • Some proxy representation

Case box: Bolivia

According to the textbook, Bolivia is often cited as a successful case of democratic decentralisation in Latin America. A Popular Participation Law of 1994 created municipalities with popularly elected mayors and councils and set up automatic fiscal transfers to them; a fixed share of national tax collections is distributed among municipalities per head of population, and they are responsible for local health and education facilities. The contrast with India lies in automatic funding for local bodies.

Conclusion of the chapter

Local governments often remain agencies implementing the welfare and development schemes of the centre and the States. Giving them more power means being prepared for real decentralisation, so that people in villages and towns can decide which policies and programmes they want. The laws are an important step towards democratisation, but the true test of democracy lies not merely in legal provisions but in their practice.

The amendments created uniform, regularly elected local bodies with many women and SC/ST representatives, but local autonomy remains limited because many States have not transferred subjects and local bodies have few funds of their own.

Worked example 1: earning versus spending

Using the textbook's figures: rural local bodies raise 0.24 per cent of total revenue but account for 4 per cent of total government expenditure. Working: 4 ÷ 0.24 ≈ 16.7, so they spend roughly 17 times as much as they raise, as a share of the total. The gap must be filled by grants from State and central governments, which explains the chapter's point that local bodies depend on those who give them grants.

Worked example 2: does it strengthen self-government?

Judge each made-up situation. (a) A gram sabha resolves that villagers must be consulted before a large industry is set up nearby. (b) A panchayat's request for a school building is rejected because funds are tied to other schemes. (c) Village youth, mobilised by the panchayat, revive old ponds. (d) The government abolishes a village on paper by splitting it between two others without consultation. Answers: (a) and (c) strengthen self-government through participation; (b) weakens it, because the panchayat cannot spend on its own priorities; (d) weakens it, because decisions are imposed from above.

Worked example 3: is tension a failure?

In a made-up village, upper-caste landowners refuse to cooperate with a newly elected Dalit woman Sarpanch. Evaluation: the conflict reflects a shift of power to those who lacked it. The chapter argues that such tension is not always bad: making democracy meaningful for the excluded is bound to provoke resistance. The aim should be to protect the elected leader and her authority, not to undo the reservation.

Key takeaways: the amendments brought uniform local bodies, regular elections and a vast increase in elected representatives, including many women and SC/ST members, making local bodies more representative though sometimes causing power struggles. But autonomy remains limited: many subjects have not been transferred and local bodies depend on grants. Real decentralisation requires putting the provisions into practice.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. What has the reservation of chairpersons' posts for women led to, according to the chapter?

    1. No change at all
    2. A large number of women occupying the positions of Sarpanch and Adhyaksha
    3. The abolition of gram sabhas
    4. Fewer elections
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Because reservation applies to the posts of Sarpanch and Adhyaksha, a large number of women have come to occupy these positions.

  2. 2. What does the chapter say about the tensions caused by the changed social profile of local bodies?

    1. They are not always bad; giving power to those who lacked it is bound to cause some conflict
    2. They show the reforms have failed
    3. They can be solved only by abolishing reservations
    4. They occur only in cities
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The chapter says tension and struggle are not always bad: when democracy is made more meaningful by giving power to the excluded, some conflict is bound to arise.

  3. 3. Why does the chapter say electing so many local representatives becomes 'somewhat symbolic'?

    1. Because local elections are not held
    2. Because representatives are not paid
    3. Because many States have not transferred most of the subjects to local bodies
    4. Because the gram sabha elects them indirectly
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Without the transfer of most of the 29 subjects, local bodies cannot function effectively, making their elections somewhat symbolic.

  4. 4. Assertion (A): Local bodies depend heavily on State and central governments. Reason (R): Local bodies have very little money of their own and earn much less than they spend.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A.
    3. A is true, but R is false.
    4. A is false, but R is true.
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A: because local bodies raise little revenue of their own compared with what they spend, they depend on grants from the State and central governments.

  5. 5. According to the chapter's conclusion, what is the true test of democracy in local government?

    1. The number of laws passed
    2. The size of the gram sabha
    3. The number of districts
    4. The practice of the legal provisions, not merely the provisions themselves
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The chapter concludes that the laws are an important step, but the true test of democracy lies in the practice of those provisions.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery