- Foundation
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Adaptive radiation, natural selection and the mechanism of evolution
Explain adaptive radiation with Darwin's finches and Australian marsupials, the essence of Darwinian natural selection, Lamarck's rejected idea, de Vries' mutation theory, and the three types of natural selection.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Define adaptive radiation and give two examples.
- Explain convergent evolution between Australian marsupials and placental mammals.
- State the observations and the insight behind Darwin's natural selection.
- Compare the views of Lamarck, Darwin and de Vries.
- Distinguish stabilising, directional and disruptive selection.
Darwin saw evolution as a branching tree: one ancestor gives rise to many descendants, each fitted to a different way of life. This lesson looks at that branching, at how natural selection drives it, and at the early debate over where new variation comes from.
Adaptive radiation
Adaptive radiation is the evolution of different species in a given geographical area starting from a point and literally radiating to other habitats. On the Galapagos Islands, Darwin found many varieties of small black birds, later called Darwin's finches, on the same island. From an original seed-eating form, varieties with altered beaks arose, enabling some to become insectivorous and others vegetarian. Another example is the Australian marsupials: many different marsupials evolved from an ancestral stock within the island continent.
Adaptive radiation of Darwin's finches
-
Seed-eating finches
- Original beak type
- Crack seeds
-
Insectivorous finches
- Beaks altered to catch insects
-
Vegetarian finches
- Beaks altered to feed on plant parts
When more than one adaptive radiation occurs in an isolated geographical area, representing different habitats, we can call it convergent evolution. Placental mammals in Australia also show adaptive radiation into varieties, each of which appears 'similar' to a corresponding marsupial - for example, the placental wolf and the Tasmanian wolf (a marsupial).
Biological evolution by natural selection
Evolution by natural selection would truly have started when cellular life forms with differences in metabolic capability appeared. The rate at which new forms appear is linked to life span. Imagine a bacterial colony (call it A) with built-in variation in the ability to use a food component. Change the medium, and only the part of the population (call it B) that can live in the new conditions survives; it outgrows the rest and appears as a new form - within days. The same change in a fish or a bird would take millions of years. We say B is fitter than A in the new conditions. Fitness is based on inherited characteristics, so there must be a genetic basis for being selected. Adaptive ability is inherited, and fitness is the end result of the ability to adapt and be selected by nature.
Branching descent and natural selection are the two key concepts of Darwin's theory.
Darwin's reasoning
- Observation: natural resources are limited.
- Observation: population sizes are stable except for seasonal fluctuations.
- Observation: if every individual reproduced maximally, populations would grow exponentially (as seen in a growing bacterial culture).
- Inference: so there must be competition for resources; only some survive.
- Observation: members of a population vary (no two are alike), and most variations are inherited.
- Darwin's insight: heritable variations that make resource use better for a few let only those reproduce and leave more progeny; over many generations the population's characteristics change and new forms appear.
The work of Thomas Malthus on populations may have influenced Darwin.
Lamarck, Darwin and de Vries
Three views of how evolution happens
-
Lamarck
- Evolution driven by use and disuse of organs
- Acquired characters are inherited
- Giraffe stretched its neck to reach leaves
- No longer accepted
-
Darwin
- Natural selection of small heritable variations
- Variations are small and directional
- Evolution is gradual
- Branching descent
-
de Vries
- Worked on evening primrose
- Mutations: large differences arising suddenly
- Mutations are random and directionless
- Saltation: single-step large mutation causes speciation
Darwin either ignored Mendel's 'factors' or kept silent about them. In the first decade of the twentieth century Hugo de Vries proposed that mutation causes evolution, not the minor heritable variations Darwin talked about. Later studies in population genetics brought some clarity to the debate.
Worked example 1: why Lamarck's giraffe fails
Question: Lamarck said giraffes got long necks by stretching to reach leaves and passing on the stretched neck. What is wrong with this? Reasoning: (1) A neck lengthened by stretching is an acquired character - a change in body cells during one lifetime. (2) Only characters carried in the genetic material of reproductive cells are inherited. (3) So the stretched neck would not be passed on. Darwinian explanation: giraffes already varied in neck length; those with longer necks (a heritable variation) reached more food, survived better and left more offspring, so long necks became common over generations.
Three types of natural selection
Picture a trait, such as body size, forming a bell-shaped curve in a population. Natural selection can act on it in three ways:
| Type | What happens | Effect on the curve |
|---|---|---|
| Stabilising | More individuals acquire the mean character value | Peak gets taller and narrower at the same mean |
| Directional | More individuals acquire a value other than the mean | Peak shifts towards one end |
| Disruptive | More individuals acquire peripheral values at both ends | Two peaks form at the extremes |
Worked example 2: naming the type of selection
Question: Name the type of selection in each made-up case. (a) In a bird species, both very small and very large eggs fail more often, so medium eggs become more common. (b) After a pesticide is used for years, the average resistance of an insect population rises steadily. (c) On an island with only very small and very large seeds, finches with medium beaks starve, while small-beaked and large-beaked birds thrive. Answers: (a) stabilising - the mean is favoured; (b) directional - the population shifts towards one end; (c) disruptive - both extremes are favoured.
Adaptive radiation = one ancestor, many forms for many habitats. Natural selection acts on heritable variation; acquired characters are not inherited.
Key takeaways
- Darwin's finches and Australian marsupials are classic examples of adaptive radiation.
- Australian placental mammals and marsupials (e.g. placental wolf and Tasmanian wolf) show convergent evolution.
- Natural selection needs heritable variation; organisms with short life spans evolve faster.
- Lamarck's use-and-disuse idea is rejected; de Vries proposed mutation and saltation.
- Selection can be stabilising, directional or disruptive.
Check your understanding
-
1. Darwin's finches of the Galapagos Islands are a classic example of:
- Industrial melanism
- Adaptive radiation
- Saltation
- Genetic drift only
Show answer
Answer: B. From an original seed-eating form, many finches with different beaks evolved on the islands to use different foods. Evolution of many forms radiating into different habitats from one point is adaptive radiation.
-
2. The resemblance between the placental wolf and the Tasmanian wolf (a marsupial) is an example of:
- Homology
- Divergent evolution
- Convergent evolution
- Lamarckism
Show answer
Answer: C. The two are not closely related (placental and marsupial) but evolved similar forms for similar ways of life. That is convergent evolution.
-
3. Hugo de Vries proposed that new species arise by:
- Use and disuse of organs
- Small, directional variations accumulating gradually
- Inheritance of acquired characters
- Single-step large mutations (saltation)
Show answer
Answer: D. Working on evening primrose, de Vries proposed that large mutations arising suddenly cause evolution and speciation, which he called saltation. Gradual small variations were Darwin's idea; use and disuse was Lamarck's.
-
4. When natural selection favours individuals at both extremes of a trait's distribution, it is called:
- Disruptive selection
- Stabilising selection
- Directional selection
- Artificial selection
Show answer
Answer: A. In disruptive selection more individuals acquire peripheral values at both ends, so the curve can split into two peaks. Stabilising favours the mean; directional favours one end.
-
5. Assertion (A): A new bacterial variant can become dominant in a population within days, while a similar change in fish would take millions of years. Reason (R): The rate of appearance of new forms is linked to the life cycle or life span.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is true but R is false
- A is false but R is true
Show answer
Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A. Bacteria divide within hours, so selection acts over many generations in days; fish live for years, so the same number of generations takes vastly longer.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.