- Foundation
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Origin of life: from the Big Bang to the first cells
Place the origin of life in the history of the universe and the earth, compare panspermia, spontaneous generation and chemical evolution, and explain what Pasteur's and Miller's experiments showed.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Outline the Big Bang theory and the conditions on the early earth.
- Explain panspermia and the theory of spontaneous generation, and how Pasteur disproved the latter.
- State the Oparin-Haldane hypothesis of chemical evolution.
- Describe Miller's experiment and what it showed.
- Give the order of events from chemical evolution to the first cells.
Evolutionary biology is the study of the history of life forms on earth. To understand how plants and animals have changed over millions of years, we must first ask how life began, and that question sits inside the story of the earth and of the universe itself. When you look at a star, you see light that left it long ago, so you are looking into the past. Biologists try to look into the past of life in a similar way - by reading evidence left behind.
The universe and the early earth
The universe is almost 13.8 billion years old and is made of huge clusters of galaxies. The Big Bang theory explains its origin as a single huge explosion. The universe expanded and cooled, hydrogen and helium formed, and the gases condensed under gravity into galaxies. In the solar system of the Milky Way galaxy, the earth formed about 4.5 billion years ago.
- At first there was no atmosphere. Water vapour, methane, carbon dioxide and ammonia released from the molten mass covered the surface.
- UV rays from the sun split water into hydrogen and oxygen; the light H₂ escaped.
- Oxygen combined with ammonia and methane to form water, CO₂ and other compounds; the ozone layer formed.
- As the earth cooled, water vapour fell as rain and filled depressions to form oceans.
- Life appeared about 500 million years after the earth formed, that is, almost four billion years ago.
Ideas about where life came from
- Panspermia: early Greek thinkers proposed that units of life called spores were transferred to different planets, including the earth. Some astronomers still favour this idea.
- Spontaneous generation: for a long time people believed life arose from decaying and rotting matter such as straw and mud.
- Chemical evolution (Oparin-Haldane): Oparin of Russia and Haldane of England proposed that the first life came from pre-existing non-living organic molecules (such as RNA and protein), and that it was preceded by chemical evolution - the formation of diverse organic molecules from inorganic constituents.
Pasteur ends spontaneous generation
Louis Pasteur showed by careful experiments that life comes only from pre-existing life. In pre-sterilised flasks, no life arose from killed yeast, while in a flask open to air, new organisms arose from the 'killed yeast'. Spontaneous generation was dismissed once and for all. But this did not explain how the very first life form appeared.
Worked example 1: reading Pasteur's experiment
Question: What is the one difference between Pasteur's two flasks, and why does it matter? Reasoning: (1) Both flasks contained the same killed yeast broth. (2) One was sealed after sterilisation; the other was open to air. (3) Organisms appeared only where air - carrying microbes - could reach the broth. (4) If life could arise from the broth itself, both flasks would show growth. Conclusion: the new organisms came from pre-existing microbes in the air, not from non-living matter. Keeping everything the same except one factor is what makes the experiment convincing.
Miller's experiment (1953)
Conditions on the early earth are thought to have included high temperature, volcanic storms and a reducing atmosphere containing CH₄, NH₃ and other gases. In 1953 S. L. Miller, an American scientist, recreated such conditions on a laboratory scale. In a closed flask containing CH₄, H₂, NH₃ and water vapour, he passed an electric discharge (standing in for lightning) and observed the formation of amino acids. Others, in similar experiments, observed sugars, nitrogen bases, pigments and fats. Meteorites were also found to contain similar compounds, suggesting such processes happen elsewhere in space.
Miller's experiment
- Gas mixture CH₄, H₂, NH₃ and water vapour, like the early reducing atmosphere.
- Energy Electric discharge, standing in for lightning.
- Cooling Products condense and collect, like rain into oceans.
- Result Amino acids form from simple inorganic molecules.
Worked example 2: what Miller did and did not prove
Question: Did Miller's experiment create life? Reasoning: (1) He obtained amino acids, which are building blocks of proteins. (2) Building blocks are not a living, self-replicating cell. (3) What the experiment shows is that organic molecules can form from inorganic ones under conditions thought to resemble the early earth. Answer: No. It supported the first part of the story - chemical evolution - which, with this limited evidence, came to be more or less accepted. How the first self-replicating, metabolic 'capsule' of life arose is still not known.
From molecules to cells
The conjectured sequence of the origin of life
- Chemical evolution Inorganic molecules form organic molecules (amino acids, sugars, bases).
- Non-cellular life Giant molecules such as RNA, protein and polysaccharides, perhaps about 3 billion years ago, that may have reproduced themselves.
- First cells Probably single cells, not until about 2000 million years ago, all in water.
- Biological evolution Cellular life diversifies by natural selection.
This view - that the first life arose slowly through evolutionary forces from non-living molecules (abiogenesis) - is accepted by most scientists. How these first cells evolved into today's biodiversity is the subject of the rest of the chapter.
Life comes only from pre-existing life (Pasteur) - but the very first life arose from non-living molecules by chemical evolution (Oparin-Haldane; supported by Miller).
Key takeaways
- The universe is about 13.8 billion years old; the earth formed about 4.5 billion years ago; life appeared about 4 billion years ago.
- Panspermia says life came from space; spontaneous generation says life arises from decaying matter - Pasteur disproved it.
- Oparin and Haldane proposed chemical evolution before the origin of life.
- Miller (1953) made amino acids from CH₄, H₂, NH₃ and water vapour with an electric discharge.
- Non-cellular forms may have arisen about 3 billion years ago; the first cells about 2000 million years ago.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which gases did S. L. Miller use in his experiment to simulate the early atmosphere?
- O₂, N₂, CO₂ and water vapour
- CH₄, H₂, NH₃ and water vapour
- O₃, CO and H₂
- Only CO₂ and water vapour
Show answer
Answer: B. Miller's flask contained methane, hydrogen, ammonia and water vapour - a reducing mixture like the early atmosphere - and an electric discharge produced amino acids. Free oxygen was absent.
-
2. Louis Pasteur's experiments with killed yeast disproved the theory of:
- Chemical evolution
- Natural selection
- Spontaneous generation
- Panspermia
Show answer
Answer: C. Pasteur showed that no life arose in pre-sterilised flasks while it did in flasks open to air. So life comes only from pre-existing life, and spontaneous generation was dismissed.
-
3. The idea that units of life called spores were transferred to different planets, including the earth, is called:
- Panspermia
- Special creation
- Abiogenesis
- Saltation
Show answer
Answer: A. Panspermia proposes that life (as spores) came to earth from elsewhere in space. It is still favoured by some astronomers.
-
4. According to the textbook, life appeared on earth about:
- 4.5 billion years ago, at the moment the earth formed
- 13.8 billion years ago
- 10,000 years ago
- 500 million years after the formation of the earth, almost four billion years ago
Show answer
Answer: D. The earth formed about 4.5 billion years ago and life appeared about 500 million years later, almost four billion years ago. 13.8 billion years is the age of the universe.
-
5. Assertion (A): Miller's experiment supports the idea of chemical evolution. Reason (R): Miller obtained living cells from a mixture of gases.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is true but R is false
- A is false but R is true
Show answer
Answer: C. A is true: forming amino acids from inorganic gases supports chemical evolution. R is false: Miller obtained amino acids, not living cells. How the first cell arose is still unknown.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.