- Foundation
- About 17 min
- 5 practice questions
Darwin's theory and the evidences for evolution
Contrast special creation with Darwin's theory of natural selection, and evaluate the evidences for evolution from fossils, embryology, comparative anatomy, biochemistry, breeding and industrial melanism.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- State the three ideas of the theory of special creation and why they were challenged.
- Explain Darwin's ideas of natural selection and reproductive fitness.
- Describe paleontological and embryological evidence, including von Baer's objection to Haeckel.
- Distinguish homologous and analogous organs, with plant and animal examples.
- Explain industrial melanism and resistance to pesticides and antibiotics as evolution in action.
How did the first simple cells give rise to the enormous diversity of life today? Before the nineteenth century most people accepted religious accounts of creation. Careful observation of living things, fossils and rocks led to a very different explanation.
Special creation and Darwin's challenge
The theory of special creation had three connotations: (1) all living organisms were created as they are today; (2) diversity has always been the same since creation and will remain so; (3) the earth is about 4000 years old. These ideas were strongly challenged in the nineteenth century.
On a voyage round the world on the sailing ship H.M.S. Beagle, Charles Darwin concluded that existing living forms share similarities, to varying degrees, with each other and with life forms that existed millions of years ago, many of which are now extinct. New forms arose at different periods, and life forms evolved gradually. Any population has built-in variation; individuals whose characteristics help them survive better in natural conditions outbreed the others. Darwin called this natural selection. Fitness, for Darwin, means ultimately and only reproductive fitness: the fitter leave more progeny. Alfred Wallace, working in the Malay Archipelago, reached similar conclusions at about the same time. Since the geological history of the earth matches its biological history, the earth must be billions, not thousands, of years old.
Evidences for evolution
Evidences for evolution
-
Paleontological
- Fossils in rock layers of different ages
- Extinct forms such as dinosaurs
- Life forms restricted to certain time spans
-
Embryological
- Haeckel: vestigial gill slits in all vertebrate embryos
- Disapproved by von Baer
-
Comparative anatomy
- Homologous organs - divergent evolution
- Analogous organs - convergent evolution
-
Biochemical
- Similar proteins and genes for a given function
-
Evolution by human action
- Artificial selection of breeds
- Industrial melanism
- Resistance to herbicides, pesticides, antibiotics
Paleontological evidence
Fossils are remains of hard parts of life forms found in rocks. Sedimentary rocks lie layer over layer, and layers of different ages contain fossils of different life forms that probably died while that layer formed. Some resemble modern organisms; some, like dinosaurs, are extinct. Fossil study shows life forms varied over time and certain forms are restricted to certain geological time spans, so new forms arose at different times. The ages of fossils are found by radioactive dating.
Embryological evidence - and its limits
Ernst Haeckel proposed embryological support for evolution: for example, the embryos of all vertebrates, including humans, develop a row of vestigial gill slits behind the head, though these are functional only in fish. However, this proposal was disapproved after careful study by Karl Ernst von Baer, who noted that embryos never pass through the adult stages of other animals.
Comparative anatomy: homology and analogy
Homologous and analogous organs
-
Homologous organs
- Same basic structure and origin, different functions
- Result of divergent evolution; show common ancestry
- Forelimbs of whale, bat, cheetah, human: humerus, radius, ulna, carpals, metacarpals, phalanges
- Vertebrate hearts and brains
- Thorn of Bougainvillea and tendril of Cucurbita
-
Analogous organs
- Different structure, similar function
- Result of convergent evolution in similar habitats
- Wings of butterfly and bird
- Eye of octopus and of mammals
- Flippers of penguin and dolphin
- Sweet potato (root) and potato (stem)
Similarly, similarities in proteins and genes that perform a given function in diverse organisms point to shared ancestry, just as structural similarities do.
Worked example 1: homologous or analogous?
Question: Classify (a) the thorn of Bougainvillea and the tendril of Cucurbita, (b) the sweet potato and the potato. Reasoning: (a) Both are modified stems (same origin) but serve different functions - protection and climbing. Same structure, different function = homologous (divergent evolution). (b) Sweet potato is a modified root and potato a modified stem (different origin), but both store food. Different structure, same function = analogous (convergent evolution). Tip: ask first 'same origin?' - yes means homologous, whatever the function.
Artificial selection
Humans have bred plants and animals for agriculture, horticulture, sport and security, creating breeds (for example of dogs) that differ greatly yet belong to the same group. If people could create new breeds within hundreds of years, nature could do the same over millions of years.
Industrial melanism
In England, moth collections from the 1850s, before industrialisation, had more white-winged moths on trees than dark-winged (melanised) ones. Collections from the same area in 1920, after industrialisation, showed the reverse. Before industrialisation, tree trunks were covered by almost white lichens; white moths were camouflaged and dark moths were picked off by predators. Industrial smoke and soot darkened the trunks (and lichens, which do not grow in polluted areas, disappeared), so dark moths were now camouflaged. In rural areas without industry, melanic moths stayed few. Note that no variant was completely wiped out; their proportions changed.
Worked example 2: explaining antibiotic resistance
Question: Explain the rise of antibiotic-resistant bacteria using Darwin's theory. Reasoning: (1) A large bacterial population has built-in variation; a few cells happen to resist the antibiotic. (2) The antibiotic kills the sensitive cells - this is selection. (3) Resistant cells survive and multiply; resistance is heritable, so their offspring are resistant. (4) Bacteria divide fast, so within months or years the population becomes mostly resistant. Conclusion: the antibiotic did not create resistance; it selected the resistant variants that already existed. Excess use of herbicides and pesticides selects resistant weeds and pests in the same way. These are examples of evolution by anthropogenic action, and they show evolution is not directed: it is a stochastic process based on chance events and chance mutation.
Homology = same origin, different function (divergent evolution, common ancestry). Analogy = different origin, same function (convergent evolution).
Key takeaways
- Darwin and Wallace proposed natural selection; fitness means reproductive fitness.
- Fossils in rock layers show life forms changed over time.
- Haeckel's embryological argument was disapproved by von Baer.
- Homologous organs show divergent evolution; analogous organs show convergent evolution.
- Industrial melanism and resistance to pesticides and antibiotics show natural selection acting on existing variation.
Check your understanding
-
1. The forelimbs of a whale, a bat and a cheetah are:
- Analogous organs showing convergent evolution
- Vestigial organs
- Homologous organs showing divergent evolution
- Unrelated structures
Show answer
Answer: C. All have the same bones (humerus, radius, ulna, carpals, metacarpals, phalanges) but perform different functions. Same structure, different function means homologous organs from divergent evolution.
-
2. Which pair is an example of analogous organs?
- Wings of a butterfly and of a bird
- Thorn of Bougainvillea and tendril of Cucurbita
- Forelimbs of human and bat
- Hearts of different vertebrates
Show answer
Answer: A. Butterfly and bird wings perform the same function (flight) but are not anatomically similar, so they are analogous. The other pairs share a common structure and are homologous.
-
3. Who disapproved Haeckel's embryological evidence by noting that embryos never pass through the adult stages of other animals?
- Charles Darwin
- Alfred Wallace
- Hugo de Vries
- Karl Ernst von Baer
Show answer
Answer: D. Karl Ernst von Baer's careful study showed that embryos do not pass through the adult stages of other animals, so Haeckel's proposal was disapproved.
-
4. In industrial areas of England after 1920, dark-winged moths became more common because:
- Soot caused white moths to turn dark
- Dark moths were better camouflaged on soot-darkened trunks and escaped predators
- White moths migrated to rural areas
- Lichens fed only on white moths
Show answer
Answer: B. Soot darkened tree trunks and lichens disappeared. Dark moths were camouflaged, so predators picked off more white moths. Selection changed the proportions; the moths' colour itself did not change.
-
5. Assertion (A): Darwin's fitness refers ultimately to reproductive fitness. Reason (R): Individuals better suited to their environment leave more progeny than others.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is true but R is false
- A is false but R is true
Show answer
Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A. For Darwin, being 'fit' means leaving more offspring in a given environment; those who are better fit leave more progeny and are thus selected by nature.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.