- Foundation
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Reading and language practice: a passage on a doctor's duty, and modals of obligation
Read an original passage about a doctor treating a patient from a rival village and answer questions on it, use modal verbs of obligation and advice (must, should, ought to, have to), and build vocabulary of conflict and compassion.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Answer factual, inference and vocabulary questions on an unseen passage.
- Use must, have to, should and ought to correctly.
- Use modals of deduction about the past (must have, could have).
- Use vocabulary of conflict and compassion precisely.
The characters in The Enemy argue constantly about what they ought to do. That makes the chapter an ideal place to practise modal verbs of obligation and deduction, along with an unseen passage on the same theme.
Passage: The Night of the Flood
(1) The two villages on either side of the river had not spoken to each other for twenty years. A quarrel over a field had grown into a feud; weddings were not attended, and children were told not to cross the bridge. Dr Farida Khan (a made-up character) ran the only clinic, on the eastern bank.
(2) One monsoon night, the river burst its banks. At midnight a man from the western village was carried into the clinic, his leg badly cut by floating debris. Behind him came his relatives, wet and silent, unsure whether the doctor would even let them in. Some of her own neighbours gathered at the door and muttered that 'those people' should go elsewhere.
(3) Dr Khan did not argue. She cleaned the wound, stitched it under a flickering lamp and kept the man overnight. In the morning, one of her neighbours brought tea - and, after a pause, a second cup for the patient's brother.
(4) The feud did not end that day. But a few weeks later, when the eastern village repaired its section of the embankment, men from the western bank turned up with spades. Nobody made a speech. Sometimes, the doctor thought, a single act of care says what years of argument cannot.
(Original passage written for practice; the people and places are invented.)
Worked example: questions on the passage
- Factual: what caused the man's injury? - Floating debris in the flood cut his leg.
- Inference: why did the relatives come 'wet and silent'? - They were afraid they would be refused because of the feud.
- Vocabulary: 'feud' means - a long, bitter quarrel between two groups.
- Link to the story: like Sadao, Dr Khan treats a patient from the 'other side' despite hostility around her, and her act slowly softens it.
Modals of obligation and advice
| Modal | Use | Our own example |
|---|---|---|
| must | strong obligation, often from the speaker | I must finish this report tonight. |
| have to | obligation from outside (rules, circumstances) | Doctors have to keep records. |
| should / ought to | advice or what is morally right | You ought to apologise. We should help the injured. |
| mustn't | prohibition | You mustn't enter the operating theatre. |
| don't have to | no obligation | You don't have to come if you are tired. |
The story is full of these modals: the servants say what the master ought to do; Hana asks why they cannot see what they ought to do; Sadao says he must get rid of the man. Notice how ought to expresses a moral judgement, while must expresses urgency.
Modals of deduction about the past
To guess what probably happened, use must have + past participle (very likely), might / could have (possible) and can't have (very unlikely). Sadao reasons in this way: the man must have been shot some days ago; he must have escaped. The scars on his neck could have come from torture.
Mustn't or don't have to?
-
mustn't
- It is forbidden
- You mustn't smoke in a hospital
- Do not do it
-
don't have to
- It is not necessary
- You don't have to pay at a government clinic
- You may if you like
Vocabulary of conflict and compassion
| Word | Meaning |
|---|---|
| feud | a long, bitter quarrel |
| hostility | unfriendly, aggressive feeling |
| traitor | someone who betrays their country or group |
| compassion | sympathy with a wish to help |
| humane | kind, showing concern for suffering |
| reconciliation | restoring friendly relations |
Ought to judges right and wrong; must presses with urgency; must have guesses about the past.
Key takeaways: the passage shows how one act of care can soften hostility. Use must / have to for obligation, should / ought to for advice and moral duty, mustn't for prohibition, don't have to for no necessity, and must have / could have for deductions.
Check your understanding
-
1. In the passage, what did the neighbour's second cup of tea show?
- She was very thirsty.
- The beginning of a change in attitude towards the other village
- She disliked the patient.
- The clinic was a tea shop.
Show answer
Answer: B. Bringing tea for the patient's brother, after a pause, shows hostility beginning to soften.
-
2. Choose the correct modal: 'You ______ park here; it is a hospital entrance.'
- don't have to
- ought
- mustn't
- needn't to
Show answer
Answer: C. A prohibition needs mustn't.
-
3. Which sentence expresses a strong deduction about the past?
- The prisoner must have escaped from a camp.
- The prisoner must escape.
- The prisoner should escape.
- The prisoner has to escape.
Show answer
Answer: A. Must have + past participle expresses a confident guess about what happened.
-
4. 'Feud' means
- a feast
- a flood
- a fee
- a long, bitter quarrel
Show answer
Answer: D. A feud is a long-lasting, bitter quarrel, like the one between the two villages.
-
5. Which sentence uses 'don't have to' correctly?
- You don't have to touch the wire; it is live.
- You don't have to bring lunch; it will be provided.
- You don't have to steal.
- You don't have to drive on the wrong side.
Show answer
Answer: B. Don't have to means it is not necessary. For forbidden actions (touching a live wire, stealing) we use mustn't.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.