- Foundation
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Themes of The Enemy: humanity, duty and loyalty in wartime
Discuss the story's themes - the conflict between professional duty and national loyalty, humanity above prejudice, fear and racism - judge Sadao's final solution, and write structured long answers.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain the conflict between private conscience and national loyalty.
- Discuss how a person rises above narrow prejudice.
- Evaluate whether Sadao's solution was the best possible.
- Compare the story briefly with another story of medical duty.
The questions on The Enemy are rarely about events alone; they ask what the story says about being human in a time of hatred. This lesson sets out its themes and practises the long answers they lead to.
Theme 1: duty to humanity versus duty to the nation
Sadao is a patriot, but he is also a doctor who has learnt that a surgeon must never let a man die if he can help it. The story shows that roles can clash: as a citizen he should hand the man over; as a doctor and a human being he must save him. Buck does not make the choice easy: helping the enemy endangers Sadao's family, career and life.
Theme 2: humanity above prejudice
Both Sadao and Hana carry prejudice - Sadao remembers bitter racism he suffered in America and feels repulsion for white faces - yet they act humanely. What lifts them above narrow hatred? Professional ethics, basic compassion for the helpless, education and exposure to other people, and their own decency. The prisoner's words that if all Japanese were like Sadao there would be no war capture the story's message: individual humanity can cross the lines drawn by nations.
Theme 3: fear and conformity
The servants represent ordinary people under a wartime state: patriotic, superstitious and afraid. Their logic is simple and harsh - the enemy should die. The General represents power that is self-serving. Buck shows how war breeds fear, suspicion and cruelty, and how hard it is to act on conscience when everyone around you sees only an enemy.
Theme 4: racism on both sides
The story shows prejudice in both directions: Sadao faced difficulty finding a room in America because he was Japanese; his father would accept only a 'pure' Japanese bride; the servants refuse to touch a white man. Buck presents racism as a widespread human failing that war makes worse.
Themes of The Enemy
-
Conflicting duties
- Doctor's oath
- Citizen's loyalty
-
Humanity
- Compassion for the helpless
- Rising above prejudice
-
Fear in wartime
- Servants' conformity
- Threat of being called a traitor
-
Power
- The General's self-interest
- Secret assassins in an absolute state
Was Sadao's final solution the best?
Sadao's options were to hand the man over (certain death), let him be killed secretly (murder by proxy), keep hiding him (danger to family) or help him escape. The escape plan saved the prisoner's life, protected Sadao's family and kept the matter quiet, and it gave the young man a real chance through the Korean fishing boats. Most readers find it the most humane and practical solution in the circumstances, though it carried risk: the man could have been caught on the island or at sea.
| Option | Result for the prisoner | Result for Sadao's family |
|---|---|---|
| Hand him over | Almost certain death | Safe, but a life lost |
| Secret assassins | Killed | Safe, but Sadao shares the guilt |
| Keep hiding him | Safe for a while | Constant danger of arrest |
| Help him escape | A real chance to live | Danger ends quietly |
A comparison with another story
The textbook asks whether the story reminds you of Birth by A. J. Cronin (Snapshots, Class XI). In that story a young doctor, Andrew Manson, refuses to give up on a newborn baby thought to be dead and revives it. Both stories show doctors whose commitment to saving life overrides other considerations - in Cronin's story exhaustion and hopelessness, in Buck's story national hatred. Compare from your own reading of both.
Worked example 1: private individual or loyal citizen? (120-150 words)
Model answer: *The Enemy shows how hard it is to choose between our roles. Dr Sadao is a loyal Japanese who calls Americans his enemies, yet as a surgeon he is trained never to let a man die if he can help it. When a wounded American prisoner lands at his door, he cannot hand him over or throw him back. He operates, shelters him and finally helps him escape, risking arrest as a traitor. Hana, too, overcomes fear to nurse the man, while the servants, guided only by national hatred, leave. Buck suggests that when national loyalty demands cruelty to a helpless person, the deeper duty is to humanity.*
Worked example 2: what makes a person rise above prejudice?
Model answer: Prejudice weakens when we meet the other as an individual in need. Sadao's medical ethics, Hana's compassion and their education abroad allowed them to see a suffering young man rather than an 'enemy'. Empathy, professional values and personal experience help people rise above narrow hatred.
Nations make enemies; a doctor's hands and a kind heart make exceptions.
Key takeaways: the story explores the clash between professional duty and national loyalty, the victory of humanity over prejudice, and the fear and self-interest that war produces. Sadao's escape plan is generally seen as the most humane workable solution.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which conflict lies at the heart of the story?
- Love versus money
- Duty to save life versus loyalty to the nation
- City versus village
- Science versus religion
Show answer
Answer: B. Sadao must choose between his duty as a doctor and his duty as a patriotic Japanese citizen.
-
2. Which line of thought best explains why the servants want the man to die?
- They are cruel by nature.
- They hate the doctor.
- They are paid by the General.
- Patriotism, superstition and fear of being called traitors
Show answer
Answer: D. They believe the enemy should die, fear revenge from the sea and gun, and fear punishment as traitors.
-
3. What does the prisoner's remark that there would be no war if all Japanese were like Sadao suggest?
- Individual humanity can cross the lines nations draw.
- Wars are caused by doctors.
- The Japanese all love Americans.
- Sadao wants to end the war personally.
Show answer
Answer: A. It shows that one person's humane act can break through national hatred.
-
4. Why is helping the prisoner escape considered the best solution?
- It earned Sadao a reward.
- It made the servants happy.
- It saved the man's life and quietly ended the danger to Sadao's family.
- It pleased the General.
Show answer
Answer: C. Unlike handing him over or having him killed, the escape preserved life and removed the risk to the family.
-
5. What does the story show about racism?
- It exists only among Americans.
- It exists only among Japanese.
- It does not appear in the story.
- It exists on both sides and war makes it worse.
Show answer
Answer: D. Sadao faced prejudice in America, and Japanese characters show prejudice too; war intensifies it.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.