• Foundation
  • About 18 min
  • 5 practice questions

Writing from The Enemy: a debate on humanity and patriotism, and long answers

Write a debate speech on whether humanity comes before national loyalty, using a worked model, and plan long answers on Sadao's choices and the General's attitude.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Write a debate speech with a clear stand, reasons, examples and rebuttal.
  • Use evidence from the story to support an argument.
  • Plan long answers on the story's characters and ending.
  • Write a balanced evaluation.

The Enemy raises a question that people still argue about: when humanity and loyalty to the nation conflict, which should come first? This makes it ideal for a debate. This lesson gives a model and guidance for long answers.

Debate format

  • Greeting: address the chairperson, judges, teachers and friends.
  • State the motion and your stand clearly (for or against).
  • Give two or three arguments, each with a reason and an example.
  • Rebut the expected arguments of the other side.
  • Conclude with a strong summary and thank the audience.

Model debate speech (original)

Respected chairperson, honourable judges, teachers and my dear friends, I am Sana Qureshi (a made-up student), and I speak for the motion: Humanity must come before national loyalty.

First, a nation exists to protect human life; a loyalty that demands cruelty to a helpless person betrays the very purpose of the nation. In The Enemy, Dr Sadao serves Japan faithfully, yet he will not let a wounded young man bleed to death. His country does not lose a battle because of his kindness; it gains a doctor whose oath means something.

Second, professions such as medicine depend on treating every patient equally. A doctor who chooses whom to save by nationality, religion or caste is no longer a healer but a judge - and history shows how dangerous that is.

My opponents will say that in war, helping the enemy weakens the nation. But saving an unarmed, wounded prisoner is not helping an army; it is refusing to become cruel. Humanity and patriotism are not enemies: the best patriots make their country proud by their decency.

Friends, borders change and wars end, but the way we treat the helpless defines who we are. Let humanity come first. Thank you.

Building the debate

  1. State the stand For the motion.
  2. Argument 1 A nation exists to protect life.
  3. Argument 2 Professional ethics demand equal treatment.
  4. Rebuttal Saving a wounded prisoner is not aiding an army.
  5. Conclusion Decency is the best patriotism.

Long answers

Worked example 1: 'What explains the General's attitude?'

Model answer: The General's attitude is best explained by self-absorption. He does not report Sadao because he depends on him for a life-saving operation and trusts no other surgeon. He offers his assassins to remove the problem quietly, then forgets his promise because he is in pain and thinks only of himself, as he admits. He is anxious only that his lapse should not look like disloyalty. It is not human consideration or real patriotism, but self-interest.

Worked example 2: why does Sadao think 'I wonder why I could not kill him'?

Model answer: Sadao still sees Americans as enemies and recalls the prejudice he suffered in America. Yet he saved the young man twice - once on the operating table and once by arranging his escape. He cannot explain this rationally because it comes from something deeper than reason: his training as a healer and his basic humanity. The question shows that his compassion was stronger than his prejudice, even if he does not admit it.

Debate: a clear stand, reasons with examples, a rebuttal, and a memorable close.

Key takeaways: a debate speech takes a clear stand, argues with reasons and examples, rebuts the other side and ends strongly. Long answers on the story should judge characters with evidence - the General's self-absorption, Sadao's humanity beneath prejudice.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. What must a debater do at the very start, after greeting?

    1. Thank the audience
    2. State the motion and their stand clearly
    3. Give the conclusion
    4. Describe the weather
    Show answer

    Answer: B. A debate speech states the motion and whether the speaker is for or against it at the start.

  2. 2. Which is a rebuttal in the model speech?

    1. I am Sana Qureshi.
    2. Thank you.
    3. Saving an unarmed, wounded prisoner is not helping an army.
    4. Respected chairperson...
    Show answer

    Answer: C. It answers the opponents' expected argument that helping the enemy weakens the nation.

  3. 3. Which evidence best supports the claim that the General is self-absorbed?

    1. He admits he forgot his promise because he thought only of himself.
    2. He studied at Princeton.
    3. He has a long pale face.
    4. He is a General.
    Show answer

    Answer: A. His own admission shows that his pain and needs pushed everything else from his mind.

  4. 4. Why can Sadao not explain why he did not kill the prisoner?

    1. He forgot about him.
    2. The General ordered him not to.
    3. He wanted a reward.
    4. His humanity and training as a healer worked below conscious reason.
    Show answer

    Answer: D. His compassion was deeper than his stated prejudice, so he cannot account for it rationally.

  5. 5. Which closing line suits a speech for the motion?

    1. Let humanity come first. Thank you.
    2. War is good.
    3. The end.
    4. Doctors are expensive.
    Show answer

    Answer: A. It restates the stand clearly and thanks the audience.

Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.

Next lesson → Final self-assessment: The Enemy

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery