• Foundation
  • About 17 min
  • 5 practice questions

Themes and leadership: freedom from fear, satyagraha and self-reliance

Explain the chapter's themes - Gandhi's leadership through argument and negotiation, freedom from fear and the role of ordinary Indians - and link his actions to satyagraha and self-reliance.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • State the theme and sub-theme of the chapter.
  • Explain why Champaran was a turning point for Gandhi.
  • Link Gandhi's actions to satyagraha and non-violence.
  • Explain why he accepted only a 25 per cent refund and refused C. F. Andrews's help.

Indigo is about a method as much as an event. Every step Gandhi takes shows how a leader can win justice without violence.

Theme and sub-theme

The theme is Gandhi's leadership in winning justice for the oppressed through persuasive argument and negotiation. The sub-theme is the contribution of ordinary, unnamed Indians to the freedom movement: Rajkumar Shukla's persistence, the thousands of peasants at Motihari, Professor Malkani's shelter, the lawyers, the teachers and volunteers.

Freedom from fear

Gandhi told the Muzaffarpur lawyers to stop taking peasants' cases to court for big fees: where people are crushed by fear, courts give little relief; their real need is to be free from fear. The spontaneous gathering at Motihari was the start of that freedom - peasants saw that British power, until then unquestioned, could be challenged. The 25 per cent refund taught the same lesson: the planters had to give up money and prestige, and the peasant learned he had rights and defenders.

Why Champaran was a turning point

  • It was the first victory of civil disobedience in modern India.
  • Gandhi declared, in effect, that the British could not order him about in his own country.
  • It showed that politics must start with the daily problems of real people.
  • It led him, as he told Fischer, towards urging the British to leave India.

Gandhi's method in Champaran

  • Truth first
    • Gathered facts before acting
    • Recorded about 10,000 peasants' statements
  • Non-violent defiance
    • Disobeyed the order to leave
    • Pleaded guilty and accepted the penalty
  • Cooperation and courtesy
    • Helped officials control the crowd
    • Polite and friendly throughout
  • Negotiation
    • Four interviews with the Lieutenant-Governor
    • Accepted 25 per cent to end the deadlock
  • Constructive work
    • Schools in six villages
    • Health care and sanitation
  • Self-reliance
    • Refused to lean on C. F. Andrews
    • Asked Indians to win their own battle

Influencing the lawyers

Gandhi scolded the lawyers for high fees. When they said they would go home if he were jailed, he asked about the injustice to the peasants. Ashamed that a stranger would go to prison while they, the neighbours, would desert, they agreed to court arrest. Gandhi immediately exclaimed that the battle was won and organised them in pairs to court arrest one after another.

Self-reliance: the Andrews episode

The lawyers wanted the English pacifist Charles Freer Andrews to stay and help, thinking an Englishman on their side would strengthen them. Gandhi refused: leaning on Andrews because he was English showed weakness; the cause was just, and they must rely on themselves. Rajendra Prasad later admitted that Gandhi had read their minds. For Gandhi, helping the sharecroppers, learning self-reliance and winning independence were one and the same struggle.

Worked example 1: linking to satyagraha

Question: how do the events illustrate satyagraha and non-violence? Model answer: Gandhi disobeyed an unjust order openly but peacefully, signed for the notice, pleaded guilty and asked for the penalty - insisting on truth and conscience rather than force. He even helped officials control the crowd. He relied on facts, mass but peaceful support and negotiation, which are the essence of satyagraha.

Worked example 2: the 25 per cent question

Question: why was Gandhi content with a refund of only 25 per cent? Model answer: for Gandhi the amount mattered less than the principle. By paying anything, the planters admitted wrongdoing and lost prestige; they could no longer act as lords above the law. The peasants learned they had rights and defenders and gained courage, which was the real victory. Events proved him right: within a few years the planters left.

For the poor, the first freedom is freedom from fear.

Key takeaways: theme - leadership through argument and negotiation; sub-theme - ordinary Indians' role. Freedom from fear, satyagraha, constructive work and self-reliance are the key ideas.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. What is the sub-theme of 'Indigo'?

    1. Synthetic dyes
    2. The contribution of ordinary, unnamed Indians to the freedom movement
    3. Life in Sevagram
    4. The history of Germany
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Many unnamed people - peasants, a teacher, volunteers - played vital parts in Champaran.

  2. 2. Why did Gandhi tell the lawyers to stop taking peasants to court?

    1. Courts were closed
    2. The peasants were so fearful that courts did little good; freedom from fear was the real relief
    3. He disliked lawyers
    4. Courts were too far
    Show answer

    Answer: B. He said courts were useless for crushed, fear-stricken peasants; they needed to be freed from fear.

  3. 3. Why did Gandhi refuse C. F. Andrews's help?

    1. He disliked Andrews
    2. Andrews was a lawyer
    3. Andrews was ill
    4. Leaning on an Englishman showed weakness; Indians must rely on themselves
    Show answer

    Answer: D. He wanted the lawyers to be self-reliant and not seek a prop in Andrews because he was English.

  4. 4. What made the lawyers agree to follow Gandhi to jail?

    1. Shame that a stranger would go to jail for the peasants while they, as neighbours, deserted
    2. Money
    3. An order from the court
    4. Fear of Gandhi
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Rajendra Prasad records that they felt it would be shameful desertion to go home.

  5. 5. Which action shows Gandhi's non-violent cooperation?

    1. He hired guards
    2. He escaped from Champaran
    3. He helped the officials regulate the crowd at Motihari
    4. He refused to talk to officials
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Even while defying the order, he politely helped officials control the crowd.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery