- Foundation
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
Writing and speaking from Indigo: a speech, a debate and a fact-based argument
Write a speech on freedom from fear, argue a debate motion with structure, and follow Gandhi's three steps - facts, arguments, settlement - to present a case.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Write a speech with a greeting, introduction, body and conclusion.
- Prepare a debate speech for or against a motion.
- Present an issue through facts, arguments and a suggested settlement.
- Discuss the qualities of a good leader.
The book asks students to discuss freedom from fear and the qualities of a leader, and to study an issue the way Gandhi did: investigate the facts, present arguments, suggest a settlement.
1. The speech
| Part | What it does |
|---|---|
| Greeting | Addresses the audience (Respected Principal, teachers and friends) |
| Introduction | Introduces yourself and the topic |
| Body | Two or three points with examples |
| Conclusion | Sums up; ends with a memorable line |
| Thanks | Thanks the audience |
Worked example 1: a model speech (original)
Good morning, respected Principal, teachers and dear friends. I am Sameer of Class 12, and today I will speak on 'The Courage to Ask'. A century ago, peasants in Champaran lived in such fear that they paid what they did not owe. What changed them was not a court verdict but the discovery that they could stand together and ask. Fear still silences many people today: the student who does not report bullying, the worker who accepts unfair treatment. Freedom from fear begins with knowing our rights and supporting those who speak up. Let us build a school where asking a question is never dangerous. Thank you. (Speaker and details are made up.)
2. The debate
A debate speech
- Address the chair and audience
- State the motion and your side
- Give two or three strong arguments
- Rebut the other side
- Conclude firmly
Motion (based on the book's discussion topic): For the poor, freedom from fear matters more than winning in court. For: without freedom from fear, the poor cannot even approach a court; fear keeps them silent. Against: freedom from fear lasts only if the law protects people; legal justice makes rights enforceable. A strong debater admits the link between the two and argues which comes first.
Worked example 2: the three-step method
Issue (fictional): a factory in the made-up town of Riverpur has polluted a stream that villagers use. Facts: what is being discharged, who is affected, what the law requires (find out from reliable sources). Arguments: villagers' health and livelihood versus jobs the factory provides. Settlement: the factory installs treatment equipment within a fixed period, the villagers are given clean water meanwhile, and a joint committee monitors the stream. Notice that the settlement, like Gandhi's 25 per cent, aims to establish a principle without destroying the other side.
3. Qualities of a good leader
- Gathers facts before acting.
- Puts people's needs before personal gain.
- Is firm on principle but flexible on details.
- Stays non-violent and courteous, even to opponents.
- Builds self-reliance in followers rather than dependence.
Investigate the facts, present the arguments, suggest a settlement.
Key takeaways: a speech has a greeting, body and memorable close; a debate states a side and rebuts; Gandhi's three steps give any argument structure and fairness.
Check your understanding
-
1. How should a speech to a school assembly usually begin?
- By greeting the audience and introducing the topic
- With a long quotation
- With the conclusion
- With a list of statistics
Show answer
Answer: A. A speech opens by greeting the audience, introducing the speaker and stating the topic.
-
2. In a debate, what is rebuttal?
- Repeating your own points
- Thanking the audience
- Answering and weakening the other side's arguments
- Reading the motion
Show answer
Answer: C. Rebuttal means responding to and challenging the opponent's points.
-
3. Which is the correct order of Gandhi's method in this lesson?
- Settlement, facts, arguments
- Facts, arguments, settlement
- Arguments, settlement, facts
- Facts, settlement, arguments
Show answer
Answer: B. First investigate the facts, then present the arguments, then suggest a settlement.
-
4. Which quality of a leader does refusing C. F. Andrews's help show?
- Greed
- Indifference
- Fear
- Building self-reliance in followers
Show answer
Answer: D. Gandhi wanted his followers to rely on themselves - self-reliance.
-
5. What makes a settlement fair, as in the model?
- One side gets everything
- It delays action forever
- It ignores facts
- It establishes the principle while giving both sides a workable path
Show answer
Answer: D. Like the 25 per cent refund, a fair settlement secures the principle without destroying either side.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.