• Foundation
  • About 18 min
  • 5 practice questions

Writing and speaking from Indigo: a speech, a debate and a fact-based argument

Write a speech on freedom from fear, argue a debate motion with structure, and follow Gandhi's three steps - facts, arguments, settlement - to present a case.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Write a speech with a greeting, introduction, body and conclusion.
  • Prepare a debate speech for or against a motion.
  • Present an issue through facts, arguments and a suggested settlement.
  • Discuss the qualities of a good leader.

The book asks students to discuss freedom from fear and the qualities of a leader, and to study an issue the way Gandhi did: investigate the facts, present arguments, suggest a settlement.

1. The speech

Format of a speech
PartWhat it does
GreetingAddresses the audience (Respected Principal, teachers and friends)
IntroductionIntroduces yourself and the topic
BodyTwo or three points with examples
ConclusionSums up; ends with a memorable line
ThanksThanks the audience

Worked example 1: a model speech (original)

Good morning, respected Principal, teachers and dear friends. I am Sameer of Class 12, and today I will speak on 'The Courage to Ask'. A century ago, peasants in Champaran lived in such fear that they paid what they did not owe. What changed them was not a court verdict but the discovery that they could stand together and ask. Fear still silences many people today: the student who does not report bullying, the worker who accepts unfair treatment. Freedom from fear begins with knowing our rights and supporting those who speak up. Let us build a school where asking a question is never dangerous. Thank you. (Speaker and details are made up.)

2. The debate

A debate speech

  1. Address the chair and audience
  2. State the motion and your side
  3. Give two or three strong arguments
  4. Rebut the other side
  5. Conclude firmly

Motion (based on the book's discussion topic): For the poor, freedom from fear matters more than winning in court. For: without freedom from fear, the poor cannot even approach a court; fear keeps them silent. Against: freedom from fear lasts only if the law protects people; legal justice makes rights enforceable. A strong debater admits the link between the two and argues which comes first.

Worked example 2: the three-step method

Issue (fictional): a factory in the made-up town of Riverpur has polluted a stream that villagers use. Facts: what is being discharged, who is affected, what the law requires (find out from reliable sources). Arguments: villagers' health and livelihood versus jobs the factory provides. Settlement: the factory installs treatment equipment within a fixed period, the villagers are given clean water meanwhile, and a joint committee monitors the stream. Notice that the settlement, like Gandhi's 25 per cent, aims to establish a principle without destroying the other side.

3. Qualities of a good leader

  • Gathers facts before acting.
  • Puts people's needs before personal gain.
  • Is firm on principle but flexible on details.
  • Stays non-violent and courteous, even to opponents.
  • Builds self-reliance in followers rather than dependence.

Investigate the facts, present the arguments, suggest a settlement.

Key takeaways: a speech has a greeting, body and memorable close; a debate states a side and rebuts; Gandhi's three steps give any argument structure and fairness.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. How should a speech to a school assembly usually begin?

    1. By greeting the audience and introducing the topic
    2. With a long quotation
    3. With the conclusion
    4. With a list of statistics
    Show answer

    Answer: A. A speech opens by greeting the audience, introducing the speaker and stating the topic.

  2. 2. In a debate, what is rebuttal?

    1. Repeating your own points
    2. Thanking the audience
    3. Answering and weakening the other side's arguments
    4. Reading the motion
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Rebuttal means responding to and challenging the opponent's points.

  3. 3. Which is the correct order of Gandhi's method in this lesson?

    1. Settlement, facts, arguments
    2. Facts, arguments, settlement
    3. Arguments, settlement, facts
    4. Facts, settlement, arguments
    Show answer

    Answer: B. First investigate the facts, then present the arguments, then suggest a settlement.

  4. 4. Which quality of a leader does refusing C. F. Andrews's help show?

    1. Greed
    2. Indifference
    3. Fear
    4. Building self-reliance in followers
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Gandhi wanted his followers to rely on themselves - self-reliance.

  5. 5. What makes a settlement fair, as in the model?

    1. One side gets everything
    2. It delays action forever
    3. It ignores facts
    4. It establishes the principle while giving both sides a workable path
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Like the 25 per cent refund, a fair settlement secures the principle without destroying either side.

Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.

Next lesson → Final self-assessment: Indigo

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery