- Foundation
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
Approaches to human development and the Human Development Index
Compare the income, welfare, basic needs and capability approaches to human development, then learn how the Human Development Index measures health, education and access to resources on a score from 0 to 1, and what it cannot show.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Describe the income, welfare, basic needs (ILO) and capability (Amartya Sen) approaches.
- Name the indicators and weights of the Human Development Index and interpret its score.
- Explain why the HDI measures attainment but is not the most reliable measure.
There are many ways to look at the problem of human development. The chapter first lists four important approaches, which differ in what they treat as the heart of development and in whether people are passive recipients or active agents. It then explains how human development is measured with an index.
Four approaches
The income approach is one of the oldest. Human development is seen as linked to income: the level of income reflects the level of freedom an individual enjoys, so the higher the income, the higher the level of human development.
The welfare approach sees human beings as beneficiaries or targets of development. It argues for higher government expenditure on education, health, social security and amenities. People are passive recipients, not participants, and the government is responsible for raising human development by maximising welfare expenditure.
The basic needs approach was initially proposed by the International Labour Organisation (ILO). It identified six basic needs: health, education, food, water supply, sanitation and housing. The question of human choices is ignored; the emphasis is on providing basic needs to defined sections of people.
The capability approach is associated with Prof Amartya Sen. Building human capabilities in health, education and access to resources is the key to increasing human development; capability is what turns formal freedom into real choice.
| Approach | Core idea | View of people | Associated with |
|---|---|---|---|
| Income | Higher income means more freedom and higher human development | Individuals whose income sets their freedom | One of the oldest approaches |
| Welfare | Government maximises spending on education, health, social security and amenities | Passive recipients, targets of development | Government responsibility |
| Basic needs | Provide six needs: health, education, food, water supply, sanitation, housing | Defined sections whose needs are met; choices ignored | Initially proposed by the ILO |
| Capability | Build capabilities in health, education and access to resources | Active agents whose choices grow | Prof Amartya Sen |
Income approach: income is freedom. Welfare approach: the state spends, people receive. Basic needs approach (ILO): meet six needs, ignore choices. Capability approach (Amartya Sen): build health, education and access to resources so people can choose.
Worked example 1: classifying policies by approach
Classify each made-up policy statement: (i) 'Raise every family's income and development will follow.' (ii) 'The state will build and run hospitals, schools and pension schemes; citizens need only use them.' (iii) 'Every household in the target group will get a toilet, piped water and a house.' (iv) 'We will train people, keep them healthy and help them gain resources so they can choose their own path.'
(i) Income approach: income is taken as the measure of freedom. (ii) Welfare approach: government expenditure with people as passive recipients. (iii) Basic needs approach: sanitation, water supply and housing for a defined section, with no mention of choice. (iv) Capability approach: building capabilities in health, education and access to resources to enlarge choices.
The Human Development Index (HDI)
The HDI ranks countries on their performance in the key areas of health, education and access to resources, using a score between 0 and 1 that a country earns from its record in these areas.
| Dimension | Indicator in the chapter | What it shows |
|---|---|---|
| Health | Life expectancy at birth | A higher value means a greater chance of a long and healthy life |
| Education (access to knowledge) | Adult literacy rate and gross enrolment ratio | How many adults can read and write and how many children are enrolled in school |
| Access to resources | Purchasing power (in US dollars) | The means to a decent standard of living |
Each dimension is given a weightage of 1/3, and the HDI is the sum of the weighted dimensions. The closer a score is to one, the greater the level of human development. The book illustrates this with two scores: 0.983 would be considered very high, while 0.268 would mean a very low level of human development.
How the HDI is put together
- Measure health Life expectancy at birth.
- Measure education Adult literacy and gross enrolment ratio.
- Measure resources Purchasing power in US dollars.
- Weight each by 1/3 Each dimension counts equally.
- Add up A score between 0 and 1; nearer 1 is better.
HDI = one-third health + one-third education + one-third access to resources, giving a score from 0 to 1. Nearer to 1 means higher human development. It measures attainment, not distribution.
The HDI measures attainments: what has been achieved in the key areas. Yet it is not the most reliable measure, because it does not say anything about distribution. Two countries with the same score may differ greatly in how evenly health, education and income are shared. The next lesson looks at a companion index that fills part of this gap.
Worked example 2: computing a simple equal-weight index
In an illustrative exercise, made-up Country Delta scores 0.75 on health, 0.60 on education and 0.45 on resources (each on a 0 to 1 scale). Using equal weights of 1/3, find its index.
Index = (1/3 x 0.75) + (1/3 x 0.60) + (1/3 x 0.45) = 0.25 + 0.20 + 0.15 = 0.60. Answer: 0.60. This only shows the idea of equal weights; the official method used in Human Development Reports is more detailed.
Key takeaways: the income approach, one of the oldest, links human development to income; the welfare approach treats people as passive recipients of government expenditure; the basic needs approach (ILO) identified six needs but ignores choices; the capability approach (Amartya Sen) builds capabilities in health, education and access to resources. The HDI scores countries from 0 to 1 using life expectancy at birth, adult literacy and gross enrolment ratio, and purchasing power in US dollars, each weighted 1/3. It measures attainment but says nothing about distribution.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which approach to human development was initially proposed by the International Labour Organisation?
- Income approach
- Welfare approach
- Capability approach
- Basic needs approach
Show answer
Answer: D. The chapter states that the basic needs approach was initially proposed by the ILO.
-
2. Which of the following is NOT one of the six basic needs identified under the basic needs approach?
- Food
- Sanitation
- Transport
- Housing
Show answer
Answer: C. The six basic needs are health, education, food, water supply, sanitation and housing. Transport is not among them.
-
3. The capability approach is associated with:
- Prof Amartya Sen
- Thomas Malthus
- Griffith Taylor
- Ellen C. Semple
Show answer
Answer: A. The chapter associates the capability approach with Prof Amartya Sen.
-
4. Which indicator does the chapter use to assess health in the HDI?
- Infant mortality rate
- Life expectancy at birth
- Number of hospitals
- Crude death rate
Show answer
Answer: B. The chapter states that the indicator chosen to assess health is life expectancy at birth.
-
5. Assertion (A): Each dimension of the HDI has a weightage of 1/3.
Reason (R): The HDI is the sum of the weights assigned to health, education and access to resources, which count equally.- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A.
- A is true but R is false.
- A is false but R is true.
Show answer
Answer: A. Three equally weighted dimensions give 1/3 each, and the HDI adds them up; R explains A.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.