• Foundation
  • About 18 min
  • 5 practice questions

Beyond the HDI: the human poverty index, Gross National Happiness and international comparisons

Learn how the human poverty index measures shortfall, why Bhutan uses Gross National Happiness, how countries are grouped by human development, and why the book rejects cultural explanations in favour of social spending, political stability and freedom.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Describe the human poverty index and why the HDI and HPI are used together.
  • Explain Gross National Happiness and other new ways of measuring development.
  • Describe the four groups of countries and the book's explanation of differences in human development.

A single score can hide as much as it shows. This lesson follows the book from the HDI to a companion index that measures what is missing, to a country that measures happiness instead of output, and finally to what comparisons between countries really tell us.

The human poverty index

The human poverty index is related to the HDI but measures the shortfall in human development. It is a non-income measure. The probability of not surviving till the age of 40, the adult illiteracy rate, the number of people without access to clean water, and the number of small children who are underweight are all taken into account. Often the human poverty index is more revealing than the HDI, and looking at both together gives an accurate picture of a country's human development.

The book notes that since 1990 the UNDP has published the Human Development Report every year, giving a rank-wise list of member countries by level of human development, and that the HDI and the human poverty index are the two important indices the UNDP uses.

Two companion indices

  • Human Development Index
    • Measures attainment
    • Health, education, resources
    • Score 0 to 1, higher is better
    • Silent on distribution
  • Human poverty index
    • Measures shortfall
    • Non-income measure
    • Survival to 40, illiteracy, no clean water, underweight children

New ways of measuring

Ways of measuring human development are constantly being refined. The book mentions that researchers have found links between corruption or political freedom in a region and its human development, and that a political freedom index and a listing of the most corrupt countries are being discussed.

Bhutan is the only country in the world to officially proclaim Gross National Happiness (GNH) as the measure of its progress. Material progress and technological development are approached more cautiously, considering the harm they might do to the environment or to the cultural and spiritual life of the people: material progress cannot come at the cost of happiness. GNH encourages us to think of the spiritual, non-material and qualitative aspects of development.

The HDI measures what has been achieved, the human poverty index measures what is still missing, and Gross National Happiness reminds us that development also has spiritual, non-material and qualitative sides.

International comparisons

Size of territory and per capita income are not directly related to human development. Often smaller countries have done better than larger ones, and relatively poorer nations have been ranked higher than richer neighbours. The textbook's examples: Sri Lanka and Trinidad and Tobago rank higher than India despite smaller economies, and within India, Kerala does much better than Punjab and Gujarat despite a lower per capita income. Rankings change from report to report, so treat these as the book's illustrations.

Countries are classified into four groups by their HDI scores. The score bands are those used in the Human Development Report; the number of countries in each group is given only according to the textbook, which cites the Human Development Report 2025, and it changes with every report.

Human development categories as given in the textbook
Level of human developmentHDI scoreNumber of countries (according to the textbook, HDR 2025)
Very highAbove 0.80074
High0.700 up to 0.79950
Medium0.550 up to 0.69953
LowBelow 0.55026
  • Very high and high: education and healthcare are government priorities; much investment in the social sector; higher investment in people and good governance. The book adds that many were former imperial powers, social diversity is not very high, and many lie in Europe and the industrialised West, though striking numbers of non-European countries are also included.
  • Medium: according to the textbook the largest group. Most emerged after the Second World War, some as former colonies and many after the break-up of the erstwhile Soviet Union in 1990. Many are improving fast through more people-oriented policies and less social discrimination; most have much higher social diversity, and many have faced political instability and social uprisings.
  • Low: a large proportion are small countries going through political turmoil and social instability, such as civil war, famine or a high incidence of diseases; the book calls for well-thought-out policies to meet their needs.

Explaining the differences

People often blame low human development on a people's culture, saying a country lags because of its religion or community. The book calls such statements misleading. Instead, look at the pattern of government expenditure on the social sector, the political environment and the amount of freedom people have. Countries with high human development invest more in the social sectors, are generally free from political turmoil, and distribute resources far more equitably. Places with low human development tend to spend more on defence than on social sectors, lie in areas of political instability, and have not been able to initiate accelerated economic development.

Worked example 1: placing scores in categories

Three made-up countries score Alpha 0.912, Beta 0.604 and Gamma 0.382. Place each in the textbook's four groups.

Compare with the bands: 0.912 is above 0.800, so Alpha is very high; 0.604 lies between 0.550 and 0.699, so Beta is medium; 0.382 is below 0.550, so Gamma is low. The scores show attainment only; they do not show distribution or explain the differences.

Worked example 2: testing two explanations

Made-up Country K has low human development. Commentator 1 says, 'Its people's religion holds it back.' Commentator 2 says, 'It spends more on its army than on schools and clinics, and it has had years of civil conflict.' Which explanation follows the book?

Commentator 1 uses a cultural explanation, which the book calls misleading. Commentator 2 looks at the pattern of government spending (defence over social sectors) and the political environment (instability), which are exactly the factors the book tells us to examine. Answer: Commentator 2.

Key takeaways: the human poverty index is a non-income measure of shortfall (survival to 40, adult illiteracy, lack of clean water, underweight children); the UNDP uses it with the HDI. Measures are being refined, for example by linking corruption and political freedom to human development. Bhutan alone officially uses Gross National Happiness. Size and per capita income are not directly related to human development. Countries fall into very high, high, medium and low groups. Differences are explained by social-sector spending, political stability, freedom and equitable distribution, not by culture.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Why does the chapter say the HDI is not the most reliable measure?

    1. It does not say anything about distribution.
    2. It ignores health.
    3. It uses only income.
    4. Its scores are above 1.
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The HDI measures attainment but is silent on how the attainments are distributed among people.

  2. 2. Assertion (A): The human poverty index measures the shortfall in human development.
    Reason (R): The human poverty index is based only on per capita income.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A.
    3. A is true but R is false.
    4. A is false but R is true.
    Show answer

    Answer: C. A is true. R is false: the human poverty index is a non-income measure using survival to age 40, adult illiteracy, lack of clean water and underweight children.

  3. 3. Source: 'This country is the only one in the world to officially measure its progress by Gross National Happiness, so material progress may not come at the cost of happiness.' The country is:

    1. Sri Lanka
    2. Norway
    3. Iceland
    4. Bhutan
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The chapter states that Bhutan is the only country to officially proclaim Gross National Happiness as the measure of its progress.

  4. 4. A made-up country has an HDI score of 0.735. In which group does it fall?

    1. Very high
    2. High
    3. Medium
    4. Low
    Show answer

    Answer: B. 0.735 lies in the band 0.700 up to 0.799, which is the high group; very high is above 0.800 and medium is 0.550 up to 0.699.

  5. 5. According to the chapter, which factor helps explain why a region has low human development?

    1. The religion its people follow
    2. The community its people belong to
    3. Spending more on defence than on social sectors, amid political instability
    4. Its large territory
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The book calls culture-based explanations misleading and points to government spending on social sectors, the political environment and freedom; low-HD places tend to spend more on defence and lie in areas of political instability.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery