- Foundation
- About 17 min
- 5 practice questions
Growth, development and the idea of human development
Distinguish growth from development, see why measuring development by economic growth alone was not enough, and understand human development as enlarging people's choices, as set out by Mahbub-ul-Haq and Amartya Sen.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Distinguish growth (quantitative, value neutral) from development (qualitative, value positive).
- Explain why economic growth alone is a poor measure of development.
- State the ideas of Mahbub-ul-Haq and Amartya Sen on human development.
A city doubles its population, its roads fill with traffic, and its factories produce more goods. Has it grown? Certainly. Has it developed? Not necessarily. This chapter begins by separating two words that we often use as if they meant the same thing, and then builds the idea that development must be measured by the lives people are able to lead.
The book opens by noting that almost everything around us grows and develops: plants, cities, ideas, nations, relationships, even ourselves. It then asks two questions worth keeping in mind through this lesson: do growth and development mean the same thing, and do they always accompany each other? The chapter discusses human development as it applies to nations and communities.
Growth and development
Growth and development both refer to changes over a period of time. Growth is quantitative and value neutral: it simply records a change in amount, which may be positive or negative. A city can grow, and it can also shrink, for instance after a disaster or when people leave.
Development means a qualitative change that is always value positive: it is an improvement. Development cannot take place without some addition to existing conditions, so development usually happens when there is positive growth. Yet positive growth does not always lead to development. Development occurs when there is a positive change in quality. The book's example, in our words: if a city's population rises from one lakh to two lakh over some years, the city has grown; but if housing, basic services and its other characteristics stay the same, this growth has not been accompanied by development.
Growth versus development
-
Growth
- Quantitative: a change in amount
- Value neutral
- Can be positive or negative
- Example: a city's population rises
-
Development
- Qualitative: a change in quality
- Always value positive
- Needs positive growth, but growth alone is not enough
- Example: better housing, services and lives
From economic growth to human development
For many decades a country's development was measured only in terms of its economic growth: the bigger the economy, the more developed the country was thought to be, even if most people's lives changed very little. The idea that the quality of life people enjoy, their opportunities and their freedoms are important parts of development is not new, but the book says these ideas were clearly spelt out for the first time in the late 1980s and early 1990s, through the work of two South Asian economists, Mahbub-ul-Haq and Amartya Sen.
Dr Mahbub-ul-Haq, a Pakistani economist, introduced the concept of human development and created the Human Development Index in 1990. He described human development as development that enlarges people's choices and improves their lives. Under this concept people are central to all development. Choices are not fixed; they keep changing. The United Nations Development Programme (UNDP) has used his concept to publish the Human Development Report every year since 1990.
Prof Amartya Sen, a Nobel Laureate, saw an increase in freedom, or a decrease in unfreedom, as the main objective of development. Increasing freedoms is also one of the most effective ways of bringing development about. His work explores the role of social and political institutions and processes in increasing freedom. The book notes that the two were close friends and worked together, under Dr Haq's leadership, on the early Human Development Reports, and that their path-breaking work brought people to the centre of discussions on development.
| Economist | Main idea | Contribution named in the chapter |
|---|---|---|
| Mahbub-ul-Haq | Development enlarges people's choices and improves their lives; people are central | Introduced human development; created the Human Development Index in 1990 |
| Amartya Sen | Development means increasing freedom (decreasing unfreedom) | Explored how social and political institutions increase freedom; linked to the capability approach |
Human development is development that enlarges people's choices so that they can lead long, healthy and meaningful lives with dignity. People, not output, are at its centre.
A meaningful life
The basic goal of development is to create conditions in which people can live meaningful lives. A meaningful life is not just a long one; it must have purpose. People must be healthy, able to develop their talents, able to take part in society and free to achieve their goals.
Worked example 1: growth or development?
A made-up town: (i) its population rises from 50,000 to 80,000 while the number of schools and clinics stays the same; (ii) later, with no rise in population, it builds safe drinking water supply, a new school and a health centre.
Case (i) is a quantitative change with no improvement in quality: growth without development. Case (ii) is a qualitative improvement in people's lives: development. Note that growth can even be negative, as when a town loses people after a disaster, while development is always an improvement.
Worked example 2: which view of development?
Two made-up officials: Official A says, 'Our state's output doubled, so we are developed.' Official B says, 'Our output doubled, but most children still cannot reach a school or a doctor.' Whose view matches the human development idea?
Official A uses the old measure of economic growth alone. Official B asks whether people's choices and quality of life have improved. Answer: Official B, because human development puts people, their choices and freedoms, at the centre.
Key takeaways: growth is quantitative and value neutral (positive or negative); development is qualitative and always value positive, and growth does not always bring development. Development was long measured by economic growth alone. Mahbub-ul-Haq defined human development as enlarging people's choices and created the HDI in 1990; the UNDP has published the Human Development Report annually since 1990. Amartya Sen saw increasing freedom as the main objective of development. The goal is a meaningful life, not just a long one.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which statement about growth is correct?
- It is always value positive.
- It is quantitative and value neutral, and can be positive or negative.
- It always leads to development.
- It refers only to improvements in quality of life.
Show answer
Answer: B. Growth records a change in amount without judging it, so it is value neutral and may be positive or negative. Development is the value-positive, qualitative change.
-
2. Who created the Human Development Index in 1990?
- Amartya Sen
- Thomas Malthus
- Mahbub-ul-Haq
- The International Labour Organisation
Show answer
Answer: C. The chapter states that the Pakistani economist Dr Mahbub-ul-Haq introduced human development and created the Human Development Index in 1990.
-
3. For Amartya Sen, the main objective of development is:
- an increase in freedom, or a decrease in unfreedom
- an increase in national output
- a rise in population
- higher government spending
Show answer
Answer: A. Sen saw increasing freedom as the main objective of development and also as one of the most effective ways of achieving it.
-
4. Source: 'A city's population doubled over twenty years, but its housing, water supply and basic services remained exactly as before.' What does this source show?
- Development without growth
- Neither growth nor development
- Negative growth
- Growth without development
Show answer
Answer: D. The population rose, which is growth, but the quality of life did not improve, so there was no development.
-
5. Assertion (A): Under the human development concept, people are central to all development.
Reason (R): Human development is about enlarging people's choices and improving their lives.- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A.
- A is true but R is false.
- A is false but R is true.
Show answer
Answer: A. Because human development is defined in terms of people's choices and lives, people are necessarily at its centre; R explains A.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.