• Foundation
  • About 17 min
  • 5 practice questions

Beyond the four varnas, property and the social contract

Explain how texts treated forest peoples and those classed as untouchable, how gender and varna shaped access to property, Buddhist critiques of varna, Tamil ideals of sharing and the social contract.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Describe how Sanskrit texts portrayed groups outside the varna order and the notion of purity and pollution, and how non-Brahmanical texts hint at resistance.
  • Explain gendered and varna-based access to property, including stridhana.
  • Describe the Buddhist critique of varna, the Tamil ideal of sharing wealth and the Buddhist myth of the mahasammata.

Not everyone fitted the Brahmanical framework. Some populations were integrated, some were subordinated, and some challenged the rules. Access to property and wealth also shaped status, sometimes overriding birth. This lesson looks at these situations as the textbook presents them.

Integration of those outside the varnas

Given the subcontinent's diversity, there were always populations whose practices were not shaped by Brahmanical ideas. In Sanskrit texts they are often described as odd, uncivilised or animal-like. They included forest-dwellers who lived by hunting and gathering, such as the nishadas, and nomadic pastoralists who did not fit a framework built around settled farmers. Speakers of non-Sanskritic languages were sometimes called mlechchhas and looked down upon. Yet ideas and beliefs were shared. In the Mahabharata, the Pandava Bhima marries Hidimba, sister of a rakshasa; their son is Ghatotkacha. Some historians suggest the term rakshasa describes people whose practices differed from Brahmanical prescriptions.

Subordination and conflict

Some people were considered outside the system and classed as 'untouchable'. This rested on the idea that certain activities, especially ritual ones, were sacred and so 'pure', while others, such as handling corpses and dead animals, were 'polluting'. Those who did such work, the chandalas, were placed at the bottom of the hierarchy, and those claiming the top regarded their touch, and sometimes even the sight of them, as polluting. The Manusmriti laid down their 'duties': living outside the village, using discarded utensils, wearing clothes of the dead and iron ornaments, not moving in villages and cities at night, disposing of unclaimed bodies and serving as executioners. The Chinese monk Fa Xian (c. fifth century CE) wrote that 'untouchables' had to sound a clapper in the streets, and Xuan Zang (c. seventh century) noted that executioners and scavengers had to live outside the city.

Did chandalas accept this? Historians examine non-Brahmanical texts. Sometimes their depictions match the Brahmanical ones, but occasionally they hint at different social realities. In the Pali Matanga Jataka, the Bodhisattva is born as a chandala's son, Matanga; insulted and beaten, he protests, later gains spiritual powers, and when his own son turns him away as unworthy, he teaches that those proud of birth and ignorant do not deserve gifts, while those free of vices do. The story is told from Matanga's perspective.

Gendered access to property

In the Mahabharata's game of dice, Yudhisthira, deceived by Duryodhana, stakes and loses his wealth, kingdom, brothers, himself and finally their common wife Draupadi. Draupadi asks whether he had lost himself before staking her; two opposite opinions were offered, the matter remained unresolved, and Dhritarashtra restored their freedom. In the smriti tradition, paternal property was divided equally among children (the textbook's wording) after the parents' death, with a special share for the eldest. Women could keep gifts received at marriage as stridhana ('a woman's wealth'), which their children could inherit and over which the husband had no claim. But cumulative evidence suggests that while upper-class women might have resources, land, cattle and money were generally controlled by men, which sharpened social differences between men and women.

Means of acquiring wealth according to the Manusmriti
For men (seven means)For women (six means)
Inheritance, finding, purchaseWhat was given before the marriage fire or in the bridal procession
Conquest, investment, workTokens of affection; gifts from brother, mother or father
Acceptance of gifts from good peopleAny later gift, and whatever an 'affectionate' husband gave

Varna and property; the Buddhist critique

In Brahmanical texts, varna also regulated wealth: the only 'occupation' for Shudras was servitude, so if the rules were followed the wealthiest would be Brahmanas and Kshatriyas. Other traditions partly confirm this: kings are almost always shown as wealthy and priests usually rich, though there are occasional poor Brahmanas. Meanwhile early Buddhism (c. sixth century BCE onwards) developed a critique: Buddhists accepted that society had differences but did not regard them as natural or inflexible, and rejected status claims based on birth. In a Pali dialogue from the Majjhima Nikaya, a king concedes to the Buddha's disciple Kachchana that a wealthy Shudra could have members of any varna as obedient servants, so on this count the varnas are the same.

Sharing wealth and the social contract

In ancient Tamilakam, chiefs around 2,000 years ago were patrons of bards, and poems in the Tamil Sangam anthologies (such as the Puranaruru, c. first century CE) suggest that those who controlled resources were expected to share them: generosity earned respect, miserliness contempt. The Buddhists also offered a myth in the Sutta Pitaka: humans once lived peacefully, taking only what they needed; as greed and deceit grew, they chose one person to keep order and paid him a share of the rice. He was called mahasammata, 'the great elect'.

The Buddhist myth of the mahasammata

  1. An idyllic beginning Beings lived in peace, taking from nature only what each meal needed.
  2. Deterioration People became greedy, vindictive and deceitful.
  3. Choice The whole people chose one being to censure wrongdoers and banish offenders.
  4. Payment In return they gave him a share of the rice: taxes as payment for service.
  5. Implication Kingship rests on human choice, so humans could also change the system.

Worked example 1: stridhana

In a made-up case, Kavya received jewellery from her parents at her wedding and a cow from her brother later. Her husband wants to sell the jewellery. Using the smriti rules: gifts received at marriage are stridhana; her children may inherit them, and the husband has no claim on them. Note the limit the book stresses: even so, land, cattle and money were generally controlled by men.

Worked example 2: comparing views of kingship

Contrast the mahasammata myth with the Brahmanical rule that kings must be Kshatriyas. Working: (1) the Brahmanical view links kingship to varna by birth; (2) the Buddhist myth makes the king a person chosen by the people and paid through a share of produce; (3) so the myth recognises human agency, and implies that what people created they could change.

Mahasammata, 'the great elect': in a Buddhist myth, the ruler chosen by the whole people to maintain order, paid with a share of the produce, so kingship rests on human choice.

— Definition, in our own words

Key takeaways: Sanskrit texts portrayed forest people and nomads as outsiders but ideas were shared. Notions of purity and pollution placed chandalas at the bottom; non-Brahmanical texts like the Matanga Jataka hint at other realities. Stridhana belonged to women, yet men generally controlled land, cattle and money. Buddhists rejected status by birth; Tamil chiefs were expected to share wealth; the mahasammata myth based kingship on human choice.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Stridhana refers to:

    1. a woman's wealth, such as gifts received at marriage
    2. land granted to a Brahmana
    3. a tax paid by peasants
    4. the share of the eldest son
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Stridhana, literally a woman's wealth, included gifts received at marriage; her children could inherit it and her husband had no claim on it.

  2. 2. Which Chinese pilgrim wrote that 'untouchables' had to sound a clapper in the streets?

    1. Xuan Zang
    2. Megasthenes
    3. Fa Xian
    4. Ibn Battuta
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Fa Xian (c. fifth century CE) wrote this. Xuan Zang (c. seventh century) noted that executioners and scavengers lived outside the city.

  3. 3. Read this source (written for this lesson): 'The merchant asked the monk: if a man of the lowest order becomes rich, will not men of every order wait on him? The monk smiled: then birth does not decide rank, does it?' Which tradition's view of varna does this reflect?

    1. The Dharmashastras
    2. The Buddhist critique of varna
    3. The Manusmriti's rules on chandalas
    4. The Satavahana claim of eka bamhana
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Like the Majjhima Nikaya dialogue of Kachchana and Avantiputta, it argues that wealth, not birth, governs how people are treated, the Buddhist rejection of status by birth.

  4. 4. Assertion (A): In the Buddhist myth, the mahasammata was chosen by the people. Reason (R): The myth suggests that kingship rested on human choice, with taxes as payment for the king's services.

    1. A is true, but R is false.
    2. A is false, but R is true.
    3. Both A and R are true, but R does not explain A.
    4. Both A and R are true, and R correctly explains A.
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The myth describes the people choosing the great elect and paying him a share of rice; the book draws from this that kingship rested on human choice. R states the meaning behind A, so it correctly explains it.

  5. 5. According to the Manusmriti, which of these was a means of acquiring wealth for men but NOT listed for women?

    1. Gifts from a brother
    2. Conquest
    3. Gifts at marriage
    4. Tokens of affection
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Men's seven means include inheritance, finding, purchase, conquest, investment, work and gifts from good people. Women's six means are gifts of various kinds, including from family and at marriage; conquest is not among them.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery