- Foundation
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Handling texts: historians and the Mahabharata
Analyse the Mahabharata's language and content, its authors and phases of composition, the search for convergence with archaeology at Hastinapura, Draupadi's marriage, and the epic as a dynamic text.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Distinguish the narrative and didactic sections of the Mahabharata and explain the term itihasa.
- Describe the phases of the Mahabharata's composition and its authorship.
- Evaluate the evidence from Hastinapura and the explanations for Draupadi's marriage, and explain why the epic is called dynamic.
Historians first assess a text's language, kind, author(s), audience, date and place; only then do they draw on its content. This is especially hard for a text as complex as the Mahabharata.
Language and content
The version studied is in Sanskrit, though other-language versions exist. Its Sanskrit is far simpler than that of the Vedas or the prashastis, so it was probably widely understood. Historians divide its contents into the narrative (stories) and the didactic (prescriptions about social norms; didactic means meant for instruction). The division is not watertight, since didactic sections contain stories and the narrative carries social messages, but historians generally agree that the epic was meant as a dramatic, moving story and that the didactic portions were probably added later. Perhaps the most important didactic section is the Bhagavad Gita, Krishna's advice to Arjuna.
Early Sanskrit tradition calls the text an itihasa, literally 'thus it was', generally translated as 'history'. Was a real war remembered? We are not sure: some historians think the memory of a conflict among kin was preserved; others note there is no corroborative evidence of the battle.
Authors and dates
Phases in the making of the Mahabharata, as the textbook describes them
- Oral compositions by sutas Charioteer-bards who accompanied Kshatriya warriors composed poems on their deeds; these circulated orally.
- From the fifth century BCE Brahmanas took over the story and began writing it down, as Kuru and Panchala chiefdoms became kingdoms.
- About 200 BCE-200 CE Worship of Vishnu grew, and Krishna came to be identified with Vishnu.
- About 200-400 CE Large didactic sections resembling the Manusmriti were added.
- Result A text of perhaps under 10,000 verses grew to about 100,000, traditionally attributed to the sage Vyasa.
The book asks whether new kings wanted their itihasa recorded more systematically, and suggests that the upheavals of state formation, when old values gave way to new norms, may be reflected in parts of the story.
The search for convergence
In 1951-52, archaeologist B.B. Lal excavated a village named Hastinapura in Meerut (Uttar Pradesh). The name could be coincidence, but its location in the Upper Ganga doab, where the Kuru kingdom lay, suggests it may have been the Kuru capital. Lal found five occupational levels. In the second (c. twelfth-seventh centuries BCE) he found walls of mud and mud-brick and mud plaster with reed marks, suggesting reed walls plastered with mud. In the third (c. sixth-third centuries BCE) houses were of mud-brick and burnt brick, with soakage jars, brick drains and terracotta ring-wells. The epic, however, describes a city packed with mansions, gateways and turrets. Was that description added later, when cities flourished after the sixth century BCE, or was it poetic fancy?
Draupadi's marriage
Draupadi's marriage to the five Pandavas is an instance of polyandry, central to the story. The text offers several explanations: Kunti's command to share whatever they had brought, which could not be broken; and two stories told by the seer Vyasa about previous births. Historians draw different conclusions.
| Interpretation | Reasoning |
|---|---|
| Polyandry among ruling elites | The authors describe it, so it may have been prevalent among elites |
| Falling into disfavour | So many explanations were offered that the practice was probably becoming unacceptable |
| A regional practice | Unusual from the Brahmanical view, but it was (and is) prevalent in the Himalayan region |
| A response to crisis | A shortage of women in times of warfare may have led to it |
| Narrative needs | Some sources suggest it was not the main form of marriage; creative literature does not always literally reflect society |
A dynamic text
The epic kept growing after the Sanskrit version: versions in many languages arose through dialogue between peoples, communities and writers; regional stories entered it; the central story was retold; and episodes appeared in sculpture, painting, plays, dance and narration. The Bengali writer Mahashweta Devi, in her short story 'Kunti O Nishadi', reworks the episode of the house of lac, where a nishada woman and her five sons died so that the Pandavas could escape, and raises the question the Sanskrit text is silent about: the six lives lost.
Worked example 1: does archaeology match the epic?
Compare Lal's finds with the epic's Hastinapura. Step 1: the epic speaks of hundreds of mansions, gateways and turrets. Step 2: phase two shows mud, mud-brick and reed houses; phase three, burnt brick, drains and ring-wells. Step 3: neither level shows a grand city of mansions. Conclusion: the match is weak; the description may have been added after urban centres flourished (after the sixth century BCE) or be poetic fancy.
Worked example 2: single author or many?
Build an answer. Evidence for many: oral composition by sutas; Brahmanas writing from the fifth century BCE; a Vishnu-Krishna phase (c. 200 BCE-200 CE); didactic additions (c. 200-400 CE); growth from under 10,000 to about 100,000 verses; vast regional variations. Evidence for one: tradition attributes it to Vyasa. Conclusion: the text grew over about a thousand years through many hands; the attribution to Vyasa is traditional.
Narrative sections tell the story; didactic sections instruct about social norms. The Mahabharata grew over about a thousand years from oral bardic tales into a text of about 100,000 verses.
Key takeaways: the Mahabharata's simple Sanskrit was widely understood; its didactic parts were probably added later. Sutas composed, Brahmanas wrote it down from the fifth century BCE, and it grew through phases to about 100,000 verses. Hastinapura's excavation (B.B. Lal, 1951-52) does not clearly match the epic's city. Draupadi's polyandry has several interpretations. Retellings like Mahashweta Devi's keep the epic dynamic.
Check your understanding
-
1. The term itihasa, used for the Mahabharata in early Sanskrit tradition, literally means:
- thus it was
- great story
- song of war
- sacred law
Show answer
Answer: A. Itihasa literally means 'thus it was' and is generally translated as 'history'.
-
2. During which period, according to the textbook, were large didactic sections resembling the Manusmriti added to the Mahabharata?
- Fifth century BCE
- About 200 BCE-200 CE
- About 200-400 CE
- About 1000 BCE
Show answer
Answer: C. The book says that between c. 200 and 400 CE large didactic sections resembling the Manusmriti were added; c. 200 BCE-200 CE was when Krishna came to be identified with Vishnu.
-
3. Read this source (written for this lesson): 'In the lower level we found walls of mud with reed impressions; in the level above, burnt-brick houses with clay drains.' Which excavation do these findings resemble, and what question do they raise?
- Harappa; whether the city was planned
- Hastinapura; whether the epic's description of a grand city matches the evidence
- Mohenjodaro; whether there was a massacre
- Sanchi; whether the stupa was Buddhist
Show answer
Answer: B. B.B. Lal found mud and reed-marked walls in phase two and burnt-brick houses with drains in phase three at Hastinapura. Historians ask whether the epic's city of mansions was a later addition or poetic fancy.
-
4. Assertion (A): Historians suggest polyandry gradually fell into disfavour. Reason (R): The author(s) of the Mahabharata offered several different explanations for Draupadi's marriage.
- Both A and R are true, and R correctly explains A.
- Both A and R are true, but R does not explain A.
- A is true, but R is false.
- A is false, but R is true.
Show answer
Answer: A. The book says the many explanations offered for the episode suggest that polyandry was falling into disfavour; the need to justify it is the reason for the inference.
-
5. According to the textbook, the original story of the Mahabharata was probably composed by:
- Brahmana priests in Sanskrit
- charioteer-bards known as sutas
- Buddhist monks
- court poets of the Guptas
Show answer
Answer: B. Sutas accompanied Kshatriya warriors and composed poems on their achievements, which circulated orally; Brahmanas took the story over and wrote it down from the fifth century BCE.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.