Revision notes

Chapter 3 Kinship, Caste and Class: Early Societies (c. 600 BCE-600 CE): Foundation

The key points, rules to remember, tables and diagrams from all 5 lessons, on one page for quick revision. To keep a copy, use your browser's Print and choose "Save as PDF".

Lesson 1

Texts as sources and the Critical Edition of the Mahabharata

How the Critical Edition was made

  1. Collect manuscripts Sanskrit manuscripts in many scripts from all over the country.
  2. Compare verses A method was devised to compare each manuscript's verses.
  3. Select common verses Verses common to most versions formed the main text.
  4. Record variations Regional differences went into footnotes and appendices.
  5. Publish Several volumes, over 13,000 pages, after 47 years.
Questions historians ask of any text
QuestionWhy it matters
LanguagePrakrit, Pali or Tamil were probably used by ordinary people; Sanskrit was meant almost exclusively for priests and elites
Kind of textMantras chanted by ritual specialists reach fewer people than stories that could be heard and retold
Author(s)Their perspectives and ideas shape what the text says
Intended audienceAuthors keep their audience's interests in mind
Date and placeTell us which society the text reflects

A critical edition compares many manuscripts of a text, prints the version common to most, and records the variations, so that both the shared core and regional differences can be studied.

— Definition, in our own words

Key takeaways: texts are read with author, audience, language and date in mind. The Critical Edition (1919-66, led by V.S. Sukthankar, over 13,000 pages) showed both a shared core across the subcontinent and vast regional variation. Normative Sanskrit texts were authoritative but were questioned and sometimes rejected, as Pali, Prakrit and Tamil sources show.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 2

Kinship and marriage: many rules and varied practices

Key terms for family, kin and marriage
TermMeaning
KulaSanskrit term for family
JnatiThe larger network of kinfolk
VamshaLineage
PatrilinyTracing descent from father to son, grandson and so on
MatrilinyTracing descent through the mother
EndogamyMarriage within a unit: kin group, caste or locality
ExogamyMarriage outside the unit
PolygynyA man having several wives
PolyandryA woman having several husbands

Gotra rules versus Satavahana practice

  • Brahmanical rule
    • Wife adopts her husband's gotra
    • No marriage within the same gotra (exogamy)
  • Satavahana evidence from inscriptions
    • Queens kept names from their fathers' gotras, such as Gotama and Vasistha
    • Some wives of the same ruler belonged to the same gotra
    • This reflects endogamy, marriage within the kin group
    • Endogamy was (and is) prevalent among several communities in south India

Patriliny traces descent and inheritance from father to son. Exogamy is marriage outside one's unit; endogamy is marriage within it. Brahmanical texts favoured patriliny and gotra exogamy, but practice varied.

— Summary, in our own words

Key takeaways: the Mahabharata reinforced patriliny; Brahmanical texts promoted exogamy and kanyadana, codified from c. 500 BCE in Dharmasutras and Dharmashastras, with the Manusmriti c. 200 BCE-200 CE and eight forms of marriage. Gotra rules required women to take their husband's gotra and banned same-gotra marriage, yet Satavahana queens kept their fathers' gotra names and some shared a gotra, showing endogamy. Metronymics do not prove mothers held power: succession was generally patrilineal.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 3

Varna, jati and the 'right' occupation

Occupations of the four varnas in the Dharmasutras and Dharmashastras, as the textbook summarises them
VarnaPrescribed activities
BrahmanasStudy and teach the Vedas and scriptures, perform sacrifices and get sacrifices performed, give and receive gifts (dana)
KshatriyasWarfare, protecting people, administering justice, studying the Vedas, getting sacrifices performed, making dana, maintaining social order
VaishyasAgriculture, pastoralism and trade, along with studying the Vedas, performing and getting sacrifices performed, making dana
ShudrasAssisting the three varnas in the proper functioning of society

Why the Satavahana case shows that integration into the caste framework was complicated

  • Claimed Brahmana status
    • But Brahmanical texts said kings should be Kshatriyas
  • Claimed to uphold the four-fold varna order
    • But married into the kin of Shakas, regarded as outsiders
  • Practised endogamy
    • But Brahmanical texts recommended exogamy

Varnas were four and fixed in number; jatis were unlimited and grew as new groups and occupations appeared. Political power was rarely tied to Kshatriya birth.

— Summary, in our own words

Key takeaways: the Dharmasutras and Dharmashastras assigned occupations to four varnas; the textbook stresses guna and karma and Vedic flexibility. Mauryas (debated origin), Shungas and Kanvas (Brahmanas), Shakas (called mlechchhas) and Satavahanas (claimed Brahmana status) show power was open to those with resources. Jatis multiplied; the Mandasor silk weavers and Brahmana or Kshatriya merchants show mobility.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 4

Beyond the four varnas, property and the social contract

Means of acquiring wealth according to the Manusmriti
For men (seven means)For women (six means)
Inheritance, finding, purchaseWhat was given before the marriage fire or in the bridal procession
Conquest, investment, workTokens of affection; gifts from brother, mother or father
Acceptance of gifts from good peopleAny later gift, and whatever an 'affectionate' husband gave

The Buddhist myth of the mahasammata

  1. An idyllic beginning Beings lived in peace, taking from nature only what each meal needed.
  2. Deterioration People became greedy, vindictive and deceitful.
  3. Choice The whole people chose one being to censure wrongdoers and banish offenders.
  4. Payment In return they gave him a share of the rice: taxes as payment for service.
  5. Implication Kingship rests on human choice, so humans could also change the system.

Mahasammata, 'the great elect': in a Buddhist myth, the ruler chosen by the whole people to maintain order, paid with a share of the produce, so kingship rests on human choice.

— Definition, in our own words

Key takeaways: Sanskrit texts portrayed forest people and nomads as outsiders but ideas were shared. Notions of purity and pollution placed chandalas at the bottom; non-Brahmanical texts like the Matanga Jataka hint at other realities. Stridhana belonged to women, yet men generally controlled land, cattle and money. Buddhists rejected status by birth; Tamil chiefs were expected to share wealth; the mahasammata myth based kingship on human choice.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 5

Handling texts: historians and the Mahabharata

Phases in the making of the Mahabharata, as the textbook describes them

  1. Oral compositions by sutas Charioteer-bards who accompanied Kshatriya warriors composed poems on their deeds; these circulated orally.
  2. From the fifth century BCE Brahmanas took over the story and began writing it down, as Kuru and Panchala chiefdoms became kingdoms.
  3. About 200 BCE-200 CE Worship of Vishnu grew, and Krishna came to be identified with Vishnu.
  4. About 200-400 CE Large didactic sections resembling the Manusmriti were added.
  5. Result A text of perhaps under 10,000 verses grew to about 100,000, traditionally attributed to the sage Vyasa.
How historians interpret the polyandry episode, as the textbook presents them
InterpretationReasoning
Polyandry among ruling elitesThe authors describe it, so it may have been prevalent among elites
Falling into disfavourSo many explanations were offered that the practice was probably becoming unacceptable
A regional practiceUnusual from the Brahmanical view, but it was (and is) prevalent in the Himalayan region
A response to crisisA shortage of women in times of warfare may have led to it
Narrative needsSome sources suggest it was not the main form of marriage; creative literature does not always literally reflect society

Narrative sections tell the story; didactic sections instruct about social norms. The Mahabharata grew over about a thousand years from oral bardic tales into a text of about 100,000 verses.

— Summary, in our own words

Key takeaways: the Mahabharata's simple Sanskrit was widely understood; its didactic parts were probably added later. Sutas composed, Brahmanas wrote it down from the fifth century BCE, and it grew through phases to about 100,000 verses. Hastinapura's excavation (B.B. Lal, 1951-52) does not clearly match the epic's city. Draupadi's polyandry has several interpretations. Retellings like Mahashweta Devi's keep the epic dynamic.

Read the full lesson

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery