• Foundation
  • About 17 min
  • 5 practice questions

Consequences of Partition and the choice of a secular nation

Describe the human, administrative and political consequences of Partition, Gandhi's efforts for peace, and why India's leaders chose the ideal of a secular nation.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Describe the human cost of Partition using the textbook's estimates.
  • Explain what was divided besides territory and why survivors called it a 'division of hearts'.
  • Explain why the leaders chose a secular state, and Gandhi's role in 1947-48.

Partition was not just a line on a map. The textbook calls 1947 the year of one of the largest, most abrupt, unplanned and tragic transfers of population in human history. This lesson looks at what Partition did to people, to the administration and to the idea of India.

The human cost

There were killings and atrocities on both sides of the border. Cities such as Lahore, Amritsar and Kolkata were divided into 'communal zones', areas that members of the other community avoided. Minorities who fled often found shelter only in refugee camps, and the local administration and police were frequently unhelpful. People crossed the new border by any means, often on foot, and were attacked on the way. Thousands of women were abducted, forced to convert and forced into marriage; some women were killed by their own families in the name of 'family honour'. Many children were separated from their parents. For lakhs of refugees, freedom meant months or even years in camps.

Estimates given in the chapter
MeasureAccording to the textbook
People forced to migrate across the new borderAbout 80 lakh
People killed in Partition-related violenceBetween five and ten lakh
Muslim share of India's population in 1951, after migration10-12 per cent

Writers, poets and film-makers in India and Pakistan have recorded this suffering. They often used the survivors' own phrase for Partition: a 'division of hearts'.

What else was divided

Besides territory, properties, liabilities and assets were split. The textbook notes that even office furniture, typewriters, paper-clips, books and the musical instruments of the police band were divided, along with government and railway employees. Above all, it was a violent separation of communities who had lived together as neighbours.

Consequences of Partition

  • Human
    • Mass migration and refugee camps
    • Killings on both sides
    • Abduction of women; separated children
  • Administrative and financial
    • Assets and liabilities divided
    • Government and railway staff divided
  • Social
    • Communal zones in cities
    • Neighbouring communities separated
  • Political and ideological
    • Question of how to treat minorities
    • Choice between a religious and a secular state

Gandhi's last efforts

On 15 August 1947 Mahatma Gandhi did not take part in the celebrations. He was in Kolkata, in riot-hit areas, persuading Hindus and Muslims to give up violence. His presence improved the situation for a while, but when riots broke out again he had to fast to restore peace. He then went to Delhi, where he worked to ensure that Muslims could stay in India with dignity as equal citizens. He was also unhappy with what he saw as the government's decision not to honour its financial commitments to Pakistan. His last fast, in January 1948, reduced communal tension in Delhi, Muslims could return to their homes, and the government agreed to give Pakistan its dues.

The book records that extremists in both communities blamed him. On 30 January 1948, during his evening prayer in Delhi, Nathuram Vinayak Godse shot him dead.

The deeper question: a secular India

Partition had happened on a religious basis, yet the leaders of the national movement did not accept the two-nation theory. Did this make India a Hindu nation automatically? Even after large-scale migration, Muslims formed a large minority, and there were other religious minorities: Sikhs, Christians, Jains, Buddhists, Parsis and Jews. The textbook notes that there were competing political interests: the Muslim League had been formed to protect Muslim interests and led the demand for a separate nation, and there were organisations trying to organise Hindus to make India a Hindu nation. But most leaders of the national movement held that the state must treat people of all religions equally, that no faith should have a superior status, and that being a believer would not be a test of citizenship. They chose the ideal of a secular nation, which was written into the Constitution.

In a letter to Chief Ministers on 15 October 1947, Nehru argued that India's large Muslim minority must be given security and the rights of citizens; failing to do so, he warned, would poison the whole body politic. His reasons were both moral and practical, a point the chapter's exercises ask you to think about.

Secular state, as the chapter uses the idea: a state that treats citizens of all religions equally, gives no faith a superior status, and does not make religious belief a test of citizenship.

Worked example 1: reading an estimate correctly

A student writes: 'Partition killed 80 lakh people.' Is this right? Working: Step 1, check the chapter's figures: about 80 lakh people were forced to migrate; between five and ten lakh were killed. Step 2, the student has mixed up the migration estimate with the death estimate. Correct statement: 'According to the textbook, about 80 lakh people migrated and five to ten lakh were killed.' Always attach 'estimated' or 'according to the textbook' to such numbers.

Worked example 2: ethical and prudential reasons

Classify these reasons for treating minorities as equal citizens. (a) It is right to protect people who have lived here for generations. (b) A large minority that feels insecure would weaken the whole political system. Working: (a) is an ethical reason, about what is right. (b) is a prudential reason, about what is wise for the stability of the state. Nehru's 1947 letter, as summarised above, contains both kinds.

Key takeaways

  • According to the textbook, about 80 lakh people migrated and five to ten lakh were killed.
  • Women and children suffered terribly; survivors called Partition a 'division of hearts'.
  • Gandhi worked for peace in Kolkata and Delhi; his last fast was in January 1948, and he was killed on 30 January 1948.
  • Rejecting the two-nation theory, India's leaders chose the ideal of a secular nation, enshrined in the Constitution.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. According to the textbook, Partition forced about how many people to migrate across the new border?

    1. 8 lakh
    2. 80 lakh
    3. 8 crore
    4. 80 crore
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The chapter estimates that about 80 lakh people were forced to migrate. Five to ten lakh people were killed in Partition-related violence.

  2. 2. Survivors described Partition by which phrase, often used by writers recounting it?

    1. A tryst with destiny
    2. A crown of thorns
    3. A division of hearts
    4. An imagined community
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The textbook says writers often used the survivors' own phrase, a 'division of hearts', to describe Partition.

  3. 3. Where was Mahatma Gandhi on 15 August 1947?

    1. At the Constituent Assembly
    2. At the Red Fort in Delhi
    3. In Kolkata, in riot-hit areas
    4. In Lahore
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Gandhi did not join the Independence Day celebrations. He was in riot-torn areas of Kolkata, persuading Hindus and Muslims to give up violence.

  4. 4. Source-based: 'We have a minority so large that it cannot go elsewhere; we must give it security and the rights of citizens, or the sore will poison the body politic.' This paraphrases a 1947 letter by Nehru. Which idea does it support?

    1. A state religion for India
    2. Exchange of all minority populations
    3. Postponing the Constitution
    4. Equal citizenship for minorities in a secular state
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The passage argues that the Muslim minority must have security and equal rights of citizens. This supports the secular ideal of equal citizenship regardless of religion.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): Partition raised the question of whether India would automatically become a Hindu nation. Reason (R): Most leaders of the national movement accepted the two-nation theory.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    3. A is true, but R is false
    4. A is false, but R is true
    Show answer

    Answer: C. A is true: since partition happened on a religious basis, the question arose. R is false: the leaders of the national struggle did not believe in the two-nation theory, which is why they chose a secular nation.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery